Customer Reviews Naturalizer Jaye

For a shoe that was supposed to be WW, the toe box was very small (my big toe would have busted through eventually). Then the heel was comically large and didn't want to stay on my foot at all. Usually a regular wide width is sufficient for me but the color/size combo I wanted was out of stock in that size so I thought I'd try this; the regular wide would definitely not have worked either.

Wore them for one day at work and came home with blisters on both heels. Maybe if I stuck it out I might have broken them in, but I couldn't bear to put them back on for the second day. Returning.

I really wanted to like and love this shoe. The inside is super soft and velvety. The tops of the shoes dig into the tops of my feet because they're cut higher than most shoes. The backs of the shoes also come up higher than a lot of ballet flats and so I feel blisters coming on. I will be returning these shoes.

wide just wasn't wide enough. It crosses over right on top of my bunion

Wore these for one hour with minimal standing/walking. Developed a heel blister the size of a nickel--opened and bleeding. Roughly finished stitching at heel. Shoes were poor quality for price.

Nice looking shoe, but when I tried it on the sides gapped away from the inside of each of my feet, when I was just standing.

I bought these to run errands in. They are too narrow and hurt my feet so much that I avoid wearing them like the plague. They just chilling in the shoe cabinet now....

Very nice-looking but brutally uncomfortable shoes. After a 5-minute walk, the skin on the back of my ankles was shredded and bleeding. The shoe is made of a hard material that uncomfortably pressed on my toes as well. Will not be wearing these again despite the lovely design.

Like others reviewing this shoe, I found the middle bowed out and it made a sloppy fit. The shoe looked like a boat rather than a shoe. I wear a narrow width and that is why I generally get Naturalizers. I'm not sure other brands would fit as well. However, I have urged Zappos (a great company) to put some pressure on these manufacturers to get quality control in order. There is no longer any consistency. Perhaps, too many different countries are producing the brand? The large toe area on this shoe was angled and pulled in the big toe just a bit. Manufacturers really need to go back and study the human foot! Pushing the toes inward creates many medical issues for their customers down the road. A narrow shoe width should NOT gape open in the middle. My older shoes from Naturalizer are ready to get a hole in the bottom from over wear. But I don't want to part with them until I find a good replacement. Losing hope on that.

This is the most uncomfortable pair of Naturalizer shoes ever. Toe box is shallow and there is very little padding.The style is cute but the comfort is not there. I even ordered both the wide and medium widths but it did not help.

Cute shoe but too wide for my narrow foot. Didn't fit like the Naturalizes I used to buy which were always the right width for my AA foot. I'm sad they didn't fit because it's very hard to find a 9.5 AA shoe these days.