Customer Reviews Naturalizer Jaye

I really liked the style, classic but with a modern twist; enough detail to add interest without being gaudy. There was even room for me to add a light orthodic for extra arch support. But they didn't fit my feet. Wish I had read the one review that addressed this. They are wide throughout. I need a narrow heel with a wide toe box. No matter how I tried to add padded inserts I couldn't get them to stay on my feet. It seems like the only way to get this is to get regular width and have them stretched. Seems like a lot of work but will try this next.

I need to figure out how to stretch them. I bought them to be my comfortable shoes but they are not comfortable at all. They squeeze the front of my foot

I bought 12W, feels a tad tight around the toes. Smaller than expected, REALLY need to break them in.

The shoe was too wide

These were cute shoes and would have been comfortable if they were a bit wider. Naturalizers are hit and miss for me, but mostly miss because they run narrow. These were par for the course unfortunately.

Was not comfortable at toes

Did not work for my bunions. It cut across my bunion.

I've had these shoes for a few months and wear them almost daily for my commute to work. They are not as comfortable or as cute as I hope. I actually find them to be rather matronly. While I wasn't looking for a fancy shoe for commuting, these are definitely very plain. The aesthetics would be less of an issue if the shoe was more comfortable. They are quite narrow and for some reason, they seem to get less comfortable over time. I think some of this has to do with the transition to warmer weather and feet swelling a bit but it is still disappointing. That said, if you want a very plain shoe and your wide feet are more on the narrow side, then this could work. For me, they are functional for the purpose but I think there are better options out there.

I ordered an 8WW, but found it snug even with the wide size. I think it has to do with the way the shoe tapers in the toebox, which then squeezes your toes together, even if the midfoot is wide enough. This shoe would probably work for someone with narrower feet, but I also found that the thin leather gaped as I walked. Not a fan.

As other reviewers have mentioned, these shoes feel more narrow than marked. I ordered them in a "WW" width and they weren't as wide as I thought they would be. That said, they did fit and I have been wearing them for about a month now. I have been wearing these as my daily "commuting" shoes to work. I don't have far to walk between the office and the bus stop but these shoes seem to be getting less comfortable as the weeks go on. It is the summer so perhaps my feet are swelling and the shoes are fitting tighter. The shoes are rather plain, and I think they seem matronly. While I was looking for something simple, these were much less appealing in person. All in all, they are ok - not a home run by any means.

The color is totally wrong. "Nickel Alloy" to me is a silver/pewter color, but this is an antique gold in color.

Lovely shoe, cushioned for walking. Toe box is too round and prominent for my taste. Regretfully, I am returning it and continue to search for a ballet style shoe for summer wear.

Runs a little narrow across the top of my foot. Toes felt squished. The wide width fit better in the 7W but it seemed a little long and the heel was a little loose.

I'm normally an 11W but this shoe was huge on me. Sent it back for the 10W and it just didn't feel good on. Like the style for summer.

The shoe felt a bit short but was also too wide at the heel. I have very narrow heels and this didn't fit the bill.

Great color, but runs small so now sporting a blister on my heel.