Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Shayla

Easily the most comfortable heels that I've ever bought. Great quality leather, looks good, very comfortable arch, feels very roomy.

Love these shoes! I have flat, narrow feet and suffer with plantar fasciitis. Got these shoes last night and wore them 10 hours at work today. My feet feel (and look) great!

Comfortable and cute. What a surprise for my wide feet. Wide in the toe area--not in the heel (so hard to find shoes with this fit). Yay!

Love these shoes, they are cute and comfortable.

Comfort and Style

I bought these shoes for part of my 1940s-themed outfit for a party my hubby and I were going to attend. They ended up being an addition to my “favorites” repertoire of shoes. This coming from a woman who wears ANY kind of heel under painful protest is a rather miraculous outcome. I have had back issues since my early 20’s, bunion surgery on both feet, and balance issues due to who-knows-what, and have not worn heels of any description for years. I ordered these waaay in advance because I figured I would need to “practice” walking in them so I wouldn’t fall on my face. WELL!!! Surprise, surprise, I put them on and they were comfortable, not to mention super cute! Wow. I was still a bit skeptical, though, because of the heel, so I kept them on all afternoon — and FORGOT I had them on! The fact that they are well-made was the cream on top. Yup, definitely keepers. I’ll be looking for more styles from this brand.

These shoes are perfect for the office, and are well made and comfortable. Unfortunately, I wear a 10 1/2 W, and since nobody apparently makes that size (WHY NOT???) I ordered up to an 11. It was just too long, and the heel was slipping off my foot. I think if I ordered a 10, it would be too tight in the toebox. If you are a wide, my experience is that the width is perfect. If you have a narrow heel, it probably won't work for you.

I? bought the brown ones and the black ones three years ago and wore them interchangeably to work five days a week. I? just bought another two pairs to replace my old ones. They were still in decent shape but I? prefer them to look crisp and new. I? absolutely love these shoes. They are SO comfortable. I? get SO many compliments on them. Several people have asked me where I? got them from because they want to buy a pair. They are perfect heel height with my work pants. Love the rubber soles. They don’t click clack when you walk. I? shine them occasionally and they look even better. These are truly the best and although a little pricey, worth every penny. You get what you pay for. In this case...high quality, comfort, and style.

I wanted a vintage-styled heel that is not too attention-getting. I love the look of these and I have been stalking them on zappos.com for a long while. I really appreciate the quality and level of detail that went into them. I love the padded Achilles's heel, a necessity for the modern foot. I also love the padded full insole, perfect arch support. I think I may have to add a foot petal, but I wear sneakers or sandals everyday. The inside is a soft fabric and the sole appears to be a soft suede leather, very soft and comfortable. I love the decorative detail on the toe, subtle and pretty. The heel is the perfect height, not too high and the sole is non slip rubber. These don't make the clomp-clomp-clomp sound that I get with most heels that makes me feel like a horse. They would not be my everyday shoes, more of a once in a while shoes (okay, maybe I will wear them grocery shopping.) But, if you are looking for an everyday shoe these are an ideal pair. I am returning the pair I received initially. I am not sure if my feet have grown (it's possible) or if the sizing is small, so I will refer you to the other reviews to make that determination. The 8.5 was a bit tight and I am usually between 8.5 and 9, medium or wide, so they are not horribly out of range.

Bought these to wear with a pantsuit and I love them. They are stylish, fit well and are extremely comfortable. Wore them an entire day without any complaints from my feet!!

These are one of my best shoe purchases! Great quality, super comfortable, and adorable!! Love them, may buy them in black too!

Comfortable from the start and feels well-made, too! These are great for office wear and the classic look is a plus. I have wide feet, and sometimes "wide" still feels narrow with some shoes, but these were perfect.

Reviews are correct...comfortable straight out of the box...cute shoe...retro look...

Wonderfully comfy shoe! I bought this to use as a character shoe onstage. It's perfect - fits beautifully and looks retro. Heel height is perfect too.

Comfortable shoes with decent support. They felt a bit long for 7.5. Design seems to work with skirts or slacks.

I love this style of shoe. It is not quite the Sheila that is no longer available, but they are comfortable and cute with office slacks or jeans.

Comfortable from the day one! I've gotten multiple compliments from strangers on them, too.

Beautiful shoes but they increased the height of the heel so I can no longer wear them. :(

Very comfortable! Wore all day after receiving and was so pleased with the fit. I have narrow feet and it's hard to find a true narrow show.

I'm so impressed with how comfortable these shoes are. I was on my feet most of the day the first time I wore them and I'm very satisfied. This is my first pair of Cobb Hill shoes but I will be purchasing another pair.

Super cute and comfortable! The heel is not too high and easy to walk in. I loved the laser cut details! They fit nicely without socks, but too snug with thin socks. I tried going up a half size, but still too snug with socks. I highly recommend them if you want to wear them sockless!

I was very impressed the first time I took these for a walk to break them in; I didn't have issues with them; they have cushion in good places and are quite pretty.

This is my second pair of shoes in this style from Cobb Hill. I love the 1920's look and that they are stylish with pants or skirts/dresses. I wear them to work every day and no matter how much I walk around, I never have to take them off. Because I have issues with bunnions and callous, I do have to wear the callous and bunion support until it is "broken in." I would definitely recommend these shoes especially if you have long days.

I wore this to a party last night and was so happy with the comfort. I rarely wear heels and can't imagine walking in stilettos, but these were a great compromise. I was so glad to find it in wide. Many thanks, Rockport!

I love these shoes and plan to order another pair. The only problem I had was the toes scuff badly. Otherwise I have worn them with dresses, skirts, and pants. Very comfortable.