Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Nicole

My second pair of Cobb Hill boots to purchase this winter and would highly recommend to anyone. I have very narrow feet and hard to find size. These are comfortable and wore an entire day the first time on.

This was a cute shoe and VERY comfortable for my wide forefoot and bunion. The color is more gray than it appears in the photo. It just wasn't the best color choice for my wardrobe.

This boot was SO good looking, unfortunately it was not comfortable. I ordered the 7 1/2 W, which is my usual size for Cobb Hill. It fit fine as far as length and width, unfortunately, the pre-formed wrinkles in the leather on the forefoot of the boot hit in exactly the wrong place for me. One of the wrinkles was right overtop of a bunion and I could feel the ridge through the boot. Ugh....I really wanted these to fit because the spruce color was just the non-color that looks great with jeans and casual pants. The heel height is perfect and the sole is a nice molded shape with the spruce color infused into the rubber - very classy looking. I did notice that the soles were thinner in the forefoot than I like and there was not as much arch support as the other Cobb Hill boot I have. I'm so sorry that I have to send these back, they are everything I wanted in a boot, minus the comfort.

Great looking boot, pale green/ brown color, nice rubber like heel should be comfortable for walking. The gathered top did not seem to be fastened to boot, moved around, something hard under sole of right boot. Returning.

nice booties and very supportive of arch. nice looking but the left shoe zipper rubbed on my ankle so had to return

These were cute and casual. They fit well. I returned them simply because I am looking for a bootie I can dress up or down. These would very hard to dress up. Great for what they are, though.

These boots are cute and comfortable although the left boot is rubbing my ankle a little bit. I am a narrow and this boot works only with medium to thick socks for me. So it's a tad wide for a narrow.

I loved this boot, cute, comfy and stylish BUT after trying on in the house for only any hour the suede on the front toe was already showing its wear. A leather instead of suede would have been perfect but I need the black color so I'm sending back unfortunately.

I love Cobb Hill, and usually order 9W. That is almost always perfect (same with Clarks). This time I ordered a 9W and 8½W just to make sure that I got it right. Unfortunately the 9 was too big and my heel lifted out. The 8½ was perfect on one foot the other has a higher instep, and I could not even get my foot inside (not enough opening space). So the 8½ would have worked had it had a little more give in the opening. Too bad because these are super cute, and comfortable. I have another pair of Cobbs with the same footbed and heel, and they are my daily go to shoes.

Fit was fine, boot is attractive, but not much comfort on the bottom of the shoe. Sadly, they went back

I think that Cobb Hill is starting to scrimp with the padding in the bottom of the shoe/boot. I have a lot of Rockport/Cobb Hill and they are very comfy but I am sending 2 paid of bootie back as they feel as though I am walking on the floor. Too bad-the styles are really cute!

These boots are so comfortable, I bought it in a wide, which was very good fit. I wore them to work the day after I received them and even did my 30 minute walk during lunch with no problem at all. The only issue I have is the nubuck. It looks cheap. I scratched the tip of my boot on the stairs and it looked like a shiny bald spot...I tried brushing it with a shoe brush but still looks shiny....

The toe box is too narrow for me. I need wide a wide width, which is why I selected this brand, but my toes were squished and uncomfortable. Otherwise it's a pretty shoe and I would have kept it but for that issue.

I ordered a 10N and 10M were in the box. It seemed that they may have been worn though I could be wrong about that. The fit was off because the wrong was in the box that was labeled 10N. Not sure if I will reorder. They are a cute boot and comfortable if correctly fitted.

Unfortunately for me, these nice looking shoes didn't fit, and I ordered them a half size larger and in the wide width. The shoes really look nice and they feel nice and soft--very comfortable in your hands. Now, I do have hypertension, and I do get swelling in my feet on some days, but on the day the shoes arrived and I tried them on, my feet and ankles were fine. I'm going to stop ordering shoes and find a store with lots of wider width shoes available. I hate sending them back, but back they must go.

These are a good looking boot. Normally Rockports Cobb Hill shoes fit me great. But these were too small across the toe box. Length was true to size. Sadly, they are being returned.

I did not love the color of these boots. They were neither brown or black, just a muddy looking color

These were just okay. I ordered my usual 8 wide and they were sloppy both in the toe box and the heel. I could have tried reordering the medium width but, bottom line, I just wasn't wowed enough by the overall style and feel of shoe to bother.

The booties are true to size, very comfortable, but the "black" is not a true black, more like a very dark gray.

I found it hard to get on

I've been searching for boots like this to wear with my black tights and thought I finally found them .... but the black suede color looks more like a dark bluish/grey against the black. I have a narrow foot and this boot fits perfectly, but the color is a disappointment. Maybe because it's suede and not a leather material. Am returning them and will keep looking.

I have the Cobb Hill Alexandra boots and really like them. I bought this boot because I was looking for the same comfort in a bootie with a lower heel. The boots have a trim, stylish look. The outer material does well so far in somewhat reasonable weather. To me, the color is better that it looks online. More of a dusty color. These boots seemed comfortable out of the box, but got less comfortable the first time I wore them. After walking for about 30-45 minutes, I noticed my feet were moving around a little in the boot and rubbing on the ankle. The size was right, it was just something about the shape of the boot that made it move around. I don't have this problem with the Alexandra boots. Since I've worn the boots I will keep them, but unfortunately will not be able to wear them for long periods of time without hurting my feet.

I wear 10 w's and have issues with a flattening arch, pronating, plantar fasciitis, a pulled perineal tendon in one foot, and a healing bone spur in the other. They just weren't comfortable enough for me to keep them. There was a hardness to the sole that I didn't care for, and not enough arch support. LOVE the style and the zipper worked perfectly. The search continues... PS My teen has these boots and wears them with jeans, but she has no foot issues at all. She likes them!

I really like the way this shoe looked but they are too tight with orthotics and when I remove the removable sole, they aren’t cushy enough. Too bad, I would have liked t keep these.

These were really cute, but the narrow was still too narrow for me. My foot was slipping out of the shoe/boot.