Customer Reviews SOREL Major Carly

Dang. I am so BUMMED these don't fit! I have wide feet that like Keen and Birkenstock footbeds. These were VERY narrow and my high arches wouldn't even allow me to squeeze into the shoe with the side zipper down and the lacing all undone. They are SO cute though! What a shame. If you have narrow feet and average arches, enjoy! I WISH!

This is super cute. Loved that looks like a lace up boot but it zips! The zipper is pretty well-hidden. The laces can be tightened for a more snug fit. Boot felt roomy in the ankle/shaft so plenty of room for thick socks. I typically wear a 9, sometimes a 9.5, but usually in boots I feel the need to size to a 10. Not so with this boot - it runs large. I originally ordered a 9.5 based on reviews that it ran large - and needed to go down to a 9.

These boots are top notch. They have everything from style to comfort right out of the box. The arch support is spectacular and my feet are comfortable throughout the day. These boots look fantastic on as well. I did order a half size smaller than my regular size and it was perfect. I still have room for thicker socks even when ordering a half size down.

Love these boots. I am size 8 so that is what I ordered. However, they are an entire size too big. I did decide to keep the 8 because I sometimes wear 2 pairs of socks. I have wide feet and the width is perfect. I recommend these boots for an everyday wear.

This is even cuter in person! I found they ran 1/2 size long so purchased smaller and fit perfectly! I'm usually a narrow width, but found if I tighten the laces as far as I could my thin ankle/lower calf along with a pair of heavy socks filled in just fine! The padded footbed made them super comfy with no break in period need! Love the grey/denim color had 2 compliments first time wearing because they're different!

Love these boots! Super cute and can't wait to wear them. Based on reviews that say they run large, I ordered an 8. I am usually an 8-8.5. The 8 was too snug, so ordered the 8.5 which was great. A little narrow, but will break in and be perfect. So I would say they are true to size, more than running large.

Love these! The laces help them fit more perfectly while the zipper makes it fast and easy to get them on and off! They are comfy right out of the box without needing to be broken in.

I love the look of the Sorel Carly boots, and revived them the day after I placed the order. I love Zappos fast shipping! I usually wear a 7.5 or 8 and ordered these in a 7.5, which is the size of my other Sorel boots. They do run large and I probably should have gotten a 7, but I wanted to wear them the next day, so I kept them. I'm wearing them with thicker socks, which helps, but they're still a little long in the toe. They are very comfortable and I would definitely recommend them, but size down!

These were super-comfortable right out of the box! Zipper is easy and can barely be seen. On-trend too!

LOVE these boots!! They are comfy, and fit perfectly. I usually have a hard time finding boots- I am a size 8, and my feet are slightly wide with a slightly high arch. I ordered an 8, and they fit perfectly! Tread is great, and the sipper/lace combo allows me to get the exact fit around my ankles/lower calves that I want. I HIGHLY recommend!!

I've have these for over a year now and are still holding up great. They are designed well and should last for a very long time. I have these in the curry color with the grey wool/felt like material on the side. I seriously get compliments on them every time I wear them! They are comfortable and easy to take on and off due to the side zipper. They look great with skinny jeans tucked in or tights. Love them!

These boots are GREAT! Purchased my normal size 9.5 and they are very comfortable right out of the box.

I waited a few days of wearing these to write my review. I am a size 8 in almost every shoe I wear and I got an 8 in these. When I first put them on they were comfortable and soft inside. I wore them to the mall and other errands, so a lot of walking. My little toes hurt after, but no blisters. Then the next day I wore them out again to errands and my heels hurt by the end of the day. I wore them the third day and nothing hurt. There is plenty of room for my toes now and no rubbing. I feel that after a few days, this boot molds to your feet. I live in a very frigid, cold climate and my feet were very warm (I don’t wear socks either). I wouldn’t say I could walk in a hill of snow and they would stay dry and warm though. I got the flax color and it is beautiful. It is a lighter tan/brown color though, but still very nice. They are also very easy to get on. Hope this helps!

My daughter loves these boots. They look really cool, and they're comfortable to wear. The zipper is a huge bonus - it takes far less time to put the boot on when you don't have to lace it up. They've survived snow, ice, rain, and heat - and continue to look great. We bought the wrong size to start off with, and Zappos was fantastic with the exchange, as usual.

I was looking for a boot that had both fashion and function...This boot was the answer..So comfy and good looking that I wear them for long walks and quick trips around town.

Love these boots! Ever since I saw the hiking boot trend on Free People, I wanted to find something that fit that more rugged look but was still stylish & versatile. This is it! And so comfortable out of the box. I can walk in these for miles. LOVE these.

These boots are great !! Received many compliments. Very versatile they look good with jeans and leggings . Fit is true to size.

So stylish! I have these boots in last year's colors: blue and gray and also the wet sand color. I always get compliments on both. They are very eye-catching and fashionable. I typically wear a 10 in a medium width, but purchased a 10.5 in the Major Carly's. The Carly's are cut narrow through the toe box, so if you are more slender towards the front of your foot, you could easily wear a half-size smaller. My feet are more square in the front, so I actually needed to size up to the 10.5 to get the width right. I am able to wear these with just tights, but have room for thick socks when the weather gets chilly. I can't recommend these boots enough! They make you stand out in just the right way.

I purchased these for my college age daughter. She wanted boots that had style but that would also be comfortable walking on brick sidewalks around campus, and these are perfect. She likes the height and that they lace up, and says they are very comfortable, with good arch support and a foot bed that feels cushioned. She usually wears 71/2 in dress shoes and an 8 in athletic shoes, and size 8 was perfect for these boots. They have a good tread and she has worn them in snow with good traction. They are not as warm as a true snow boot, but are cozy enough for walking to classes. The materials and construction are of high quality. She is very happy with this purchase! We greatly appreciate the customer service and fast, free shipping at Zappos, so always shop there first.

This is a great functional boot with lace up detail but zippers for fast on and off. I normally wear 8.5 or 9 and 8.5 fits well with thicker socks. These look great and I got tons of compliments every time I wear them.

I love these boots! They are so comfortable and so cute. They are easy to get on and off and look great with jeans.

These are cuter in person than online. They fit true and are comfortable. I get lots of compliments on them.

Love these boots! I have foot issues from plantar fasciitis and they are very comfortable to wear every day. Not really a winter boot in that you can't wear them in deeper snow or slush, as there is a grommet by the side, but I love them for the tread, comfort and style factor on a casual day running errands, shopping with friends or at the hockey rink. Good arch support and ran true to size, even with a light pair of socks. I'm between an 8.5 and 9 and the 8.5 is perfect!