Customer Reviews SOREL Major Carly

These were one pair of about a dozen boots I ordered from all over and were the only ones I kept. They are comfortable, fit well, and can be tightened or loosened on the calf depending on the outfit. They look rugged but not ugly, just cute and badass. Love these boots!

Love these boots! I can already tell they will last forever - like all Sorel boots I've purchased, the quality is great! I read a ton of reviews before ordering and noticed folks saying these run a bit big so, while I normally wear a 6.5 or 7, I decided to order a 6 (my winter Sorel Joan of Arctic boots are also a 6). The 6 in these Carly boots wound up being pretty tight width wise but fine length wise. I then ordered a 6.5 and they were a perfect fit - a little wider but didn't feel any bigger length wise. I wanted to write this review for those that are in-between a 6 and 6.5 (I don't know if the same holds true for the 7 vs. 7.5 and so on). I thought the 6 felt more than a half size smaller than the 6.5. If you are in-between, go with the 6.5 as it fits perfect with a medium thickness sock.

Love these boots!! I ordered a 10.5 and they fit perfectly!! I usually take a 10 in frye boots and 11 in most others! Going to wear them today. They are stylish and fun. Love the side zipper, easy on and off

I wear a 7.5 - these fit really nicely and I think they are true to size. Probably wouldn't be comfortable with a bulky sock. I've worn them for about a week and they have had no "break-in" period. Comfortable right out of the box. The zipper is fabulous for slipping them off and on very quickly. They are not a foul weather boot -- just leather and a comfy sole with decent tread.

Love these boots! Super cute and very comfortable! The are great with jeans - a nice neutral boot that goes with everything!

These boots are FABULOUS. Great look, extremely comfortable, and will go with everything from skirts to jeans. So glad SOREL is adding more fashion boots to their collection. I got the green color and they look exactly like the picture. The zipper on the side makes for easy on/off and the laces can be used to tighten things up if needed.

I like the color and style, they feel comfortable but I have not used them other than trying them on for size.

Loved these boots right out of the box! Very comfortable and stylish. I am living abroad and walk almost everywhere so comfortable boots are a must for the winter! I ordered the nutmeg and the color was just was I expected, a little darker than the picture. I wear between a 6 and 7, but ordered a 6.5 in these and they fit perfectly. I wear a 37/38 in Havianas and a 6.5 in Toms if that is helpful.

Sorel for fashion> its a brave new world. These run a teensy bit large, which works for me. Width is dead on. They appear to be well made, and I love the bit of whimsy that the stacked "heel" gives these attractive boots. If these are still av available in your size, do it. I have not worn them yet, so I can't comment on their ability to last, but we shall hope.

This was my "birthday boot" that I had my eye on as soon as I saw it on Zappos. This is my 4th pair of Sorel boots and I am likely to buy another soon. Very comfy. They fit my "bad" foot great (bunion). There is room for heavier socks and they have a nice spongy spring to them as you walk. I love the grey/blue color-wanted something different besides brown or black. Easy to slip on with the side zipper and you can tighten the laces as tight as you like. Excellent details and super cute. I great boot at a great price. I am very happy with my birthday gift to myself!

My order came on time. The boots are exactly as pictured. They feel very comfortable. These are not foul weather boots they're more for fashion. I'm not quite sure about the color. I thought they'd be more cinnamon colored but I think they're more olive. All in all very happy with the purchase.

Love the style of the boot. Really cute on !!!

I love these boots. So comfy. Go well with many styles and outfits. I wore them on a trip to Europe and walked for miles in all types of weather in them and they were perfect!

great looking shoe, however one boot fit strangely and rubbed. I love the style of the boot and previous reviews are correct, narrow cut and runs a bit larger. All positives for a 12 N person trying to sneak into an 11. toe length great however just didnt crease right and hurt left foot. grrr great looking and i will shop earlier next year and get the 12.

Had been looking at these all winter an finally decided to order. Was looking for boots that would be casual and stylish to wear during our ND winter months. True to size and the flax color was beautiful. Really good tread for walking in snow/ice when running errands. However, I had to return bummer! I have thin ankles and wasn't able to get them laced properly to look good with skinny jeans n leggings. They gapped and looked odd. Perhaps it's just the style on me. Very cute, just didn't work on me. For reference I wear size 10 running shoe and 9.5 in boots/dress shoes.

Love these boots. I'm very picky about fit and feel and these passed the test. I have a narrow heel and am a 7.5. Felt true to size and immediately comfortable. First pair of Sorel's and I see why they are loved!

Awesome Boot. I'm a 7.5 and it fit the bill. Narrowish heel but it doesn't slip too bad. Comfortable toe bed, no rubbing. I'm super picky about comfort and these passed my tests!

I would recommend sizing up if you want to wear socks. Also on the narrow side width size. The heel did rub during the first wear but they feel great now. Have gotten lots of compliments.

Very cute boots, they fit well, a little tight across the top, but I have wide foot and know they will stretch with time. If you are buying a boot to keep your foot warm this is not it, although I usually wear them with a thin smart wool sock.

I love these boots they are so beautiful. BUT....they are soooo narrow and they need to be ordered a size up. I will order them again in a size up, and give the smaller ones to my kid.

This are adorable shoes so I am sad they did not fit. They are a bi narrow and my small toe rubbed. I wont keep them if they are not 100% comfortable.

Very cute boots. They don't fit as large as I thought they would based on the reviews - they are very, very narrow. I usually wear a 9.5 and I ordered a size 9 and they are a bit on the small side. I wish I had ordered the 9.5.

Very rugged looking and cute in person. The removable foot bed is great. I easily fit my orthotic with plenty of toe room. They zip up on the inside so they are super easy to get on and off, but they are too long. Debating on trying 7.5 or moving on to another boot. They run long and narrow. I got these in 8. The length is that of a 9 and the width is just narrow enough I'm afraid if I size down they won't be wide enough. I usually wear 7.5 Wide or 8. Wish they worked!!

Super cute and very comfortable. Not meant for standing around in 40 degree weather. Toes froze even with wool socks!