Customer Reviews SOREL Major Carly

Super cute and comfy. Love these boots. Happy with the purchase and would recommend.

Love them, I would go a half size down. I usually wear a 10 in Sorel but went with others advice and glad I went down a size they run long. I have a wider foot and when I took them out the box I just knew I would have to return them because they look very narrow. Oddly enough my foot fit seems it forms to your foot as it goes on. I kept them, very impressed.

I have the wet sand color. I love the edgy military style of this color. I've had these shoes for a year now and they still don't feel broken in. The leather over the toe cap and heel is very thick and the canvas on the shaft is not very bendy. This does not been they aren't comfortable. They are. I have narrow feet and for me they were true to size in width and length(6B).

I love the look of these but they were really stiff and felt too tight. I guess I could try a size up and hope the stiffness softens up but they didn't feel like they had enough potential to do that.

When this came out, I immediately ordered them cause they looked so cute. After putting them on for a couple of hours to do errands, my feet hurt like crazy even with thick socks on. They were so narrow and mind you my feet are not even wide. Design and style is beautiful tho. I was gonna return it but thought I'd give it another try maybe it just needed some breaking in... well still hurt my feet. Didn't return it cause after second use there were scuff marks and decided to keep it cause it might still work for just shorter walks.

Super cute Sorel boots, but super narrow. Nothing like the comfort of the Joan Wedge by Sorel. These were very stiff to walk in as well. Too bad as they are very stylish!

Wanted to love these so so much! They are super adorable! I normally wear an 8 or 8.5 in shoes. I ordered both with reviews given on these. 8 was too narrow from the get go, but felt right in the toe. 8.5 was too long in the toe & felt like I was wearing a steel toe where the crease fell. So bummed, maybe I got a freak pair. They are so cute!! I have my shoes shipped to my office, all the gals agreed these were cute, but they all have bigger feet than I.

Super narrow toe box and mid foot.

Beautiful shoes, but the sizing was very weird. They were quite narrow and also way too long. I would have tried a size down, but given that they already felt uncomfortably narrow I felt a size down would not have fixed it. My toes and heel were floating nowhere where they needed to be. It's a shame because the styling is very nice. They are definitely thin fashion boots, not warm winter boots, but for fashion boots they were nicely made. I returned them because of the sizing issue.

So cute, and a very soft foot bed so comfy in all but one spot -- right on the outside part of the food, below the pinky toe in bunion danger territory there's a seam and a little metal rivet. Which I could feel instantly and think would only get more painful. Sad to return them, hopefully they'll work out the design flaw.

These are super cute boots BUT they're too wide for my skinny legs even when I tie them up tight. Returning them.

Pros: Good looking pair of boots and versatile too. Can be paired with skinny jeans or a skirt. Cons: too narrow for me considering my feet aren't wide. Wore this from morning till night walking around. By the time I took it off my feet hurt like hell. Don't think I need to size up. It's just too narrow and long. Tip: order your normal size. Usually wear 6.5 or 6 in boots but ordered a 5.5 based on reviews. Even with medium thickness socks, still had some space between toes and edge of the boot.

I'm usually a size 10, I got these in a size 10 and they're way too big. They're surprisingly narrow given how long they are. I guess if you have long narrow feet they might be a good choice for you. My feet are very average in length and width so my heels kept slipping out and there are too much room in the toes. Since they're so narrow I think a smaller size won't fit. Besides that, they are lovely boots. More of a fashion boot than other Sorel boots for sure, but still good quality.

I was pretty excited about these boots and they ended up being wider at the top than I expected, thinner in the foot than I expected, and thinner material all around. More fashion boot than boot boot.

Definite degrade in construction, fit, and sizing accuracy since the company was bought out. These are not the Sorels of old.

I am a big Sorel boot wearer but these boots felt way too narrow for me. Sadly they will return to Zappos.