Customer Reviews Massimo Matteo 6-Eye Wing Tip

I usually wear an 11.5 and bought this in an 11 after reading some reviews. That turned out to be pretty perfect. The shoe is comfortable overall, and very nice looking!

My husband loves these shoes. Not only do they look great, but they are very high quality and he says they are extremely comfortable!

Wow! Great looking and extremely comfortable right out of the box. Excellent heel and arch support. Highly recommend, especially for the price. I wear an 8.5 Asics running shoe and ordered an 8 of this shoe. Ample toe width but not excessive.

High quality shoe that stands up to the other popular brands. Buy them!! This is my second pair

Great shoe, particularly for the price. They are very supple and break in quickly.

I was initially skeptical of these shoes. I couldn't find much information about the brand online, but they looked really nice and were in the same price range as a similar product from Johnston and Murphy. I ended up ordering both pairs and keeping the one that I thought was nicer (this one). These shoes are made in Italy (the competition is made in China), the leather is very soft, and the shoes smell like a brand new baseball glove (this is a good thing to me!) They were comfortable right from the start and have needed minimal break in, unlike some other fully leather dress shoes that I've owned. I can't comment on their durability yet, but so far, I'm in love with these shoes.

This is a very good quality shoe, although hard to tell in the image but it is a two tone tan/brown. Looks really good with formal and casual wear, I've wore them to a wedding once and I have worn them with jeans and a dress shirt. Very comfortable shoes and I highly recommend them, 5 stars!

I'm very impressed with these shoes. I'm giving them a five star rating because they are more than you expect of a shoe in this price range. If you are trying to decide which shoe you should buy and these are on your list, pull the trigger on these you will be so glad you did. If these are not on your list WHY NOT?

What a great looking shoe. The tan model is even better looking in person. Light tan with some darker areas along the stitching. I REALLY wanted to keep these but the fit was just not right. I wear a 9.5 in athletic shoes and a 9 in most dress shoes or boots. I got these in a 9 (standard width) and they were a little too big. They were slightly longer than my other size 9 dress shoes but also wider. I couldn't lace them up snugly. The arch support is also out of place in my opinion. It's too close to the heel of the shoe and feels strange. If it were just a poor fitting arch I would have kept them but overall these just didn't fit so I returned them.

Shoes run 1/2 size larger than Cole Haan.

I give these a thumbs up. I ordered these in "Bordo" and they are pretty much exactly as shown on Zappos' website. Quality is commensurate with the price. I say that because $160 is approaching calfskin territory and these are not calfskin. For plain leather shoes, quality is good. Add my voice to the chorus of purchasers saying these run large. I wear 9D. Based on the comments here, I ordered 8 1/2D. The 9Ds clearly would have been too big, and I might even have been able to go down to an 8D, more for width than for length. In any event, the 8 1/2Ds are satisfactory and I will be keeping them. Comfort-wise, these feel about the same as my other dress shoes, which are Johnston & Murphys.

The shoe runs a bit large. I would step down in size when ordering a normal width. They are very well made and look terrific. They will be slippery on all surfaces so be careful not to crash.

Seems very well made. A handsome, sleek wingtip that stands out among frumpy Rockports and “dress” Crocs. Good value!

I like these shoes a LOT. Unfortunately, after wearing dress socks and lacing the shoes as tight as I could, I felt like my feet were "floating" around inside the shoe. Felt like a wider shoe.

Nicely made shoe. They will need some breaking in before the event to which they will be worn at. I kept with the my regular size as the shoe fits tighter by end of day.

Great looking shoes. Stitching was darker than the picture- I bought them because of the stitching, but unfortunately, they don't show as much. Contrary to other reviews, my pair was about a half size small. Overall, very nice and high-end looking. Leather is good quality stuff. If the burgundy/brown goes on sale, I'll buy them.

When I first unpacked them, I thought they would be too narrow. After I laced them up they were surprisingly comfortable. Nice sleek look, feels like they will break in nicely.

Its nice quality for the price point and looks like expensive shoes. However, price needs to stay below 150.

Sharp

Beautiful shoe at a reasonable price point. Toe box is longer and narrower than expected, similar fit to Allen Edmonds' Park ave. As other reviewers have noted, the soles are EXTREMELY slippery; walking on carpet feels like a game of Russian roulette.

Looked very nice and appears well constructed. I prefer a removable footbed though and the size runs a half to full size large.

these are nice looking shoes and seem to be well crafted very happy with purchase so far

I love the look of these shoes and the leather seems to be of good quality. Also, the break in time for me was only about a day and a half which is really good for leather shoes. The only disappointment for me was the sizing. I wear a 10.5 in ALL of my other leather dress shoes so of course I ordered a 10.5 in these and they were way too big. I ended up having to do 3 different returns/exchanges and ultimately ended up with a size 9. On the bright side Zappos customer service was great and helped me with all the returns. I just wish I had known before that these shoes ran that big.

Blueish gray in color. Great looking shoe if you are open to stepping outside the usual color choices. Massimo Matteo's quality, fit and finish are second to none.

I started off with my normal shoe size (an 8) and was swimming in these shoes. There was no 7 available in the burgundy color (which is what I wanted), so I ordered the 7.5 and hoped for the best. 7.5 was unfortunately too large as well. So, I didn't ultimately buy these shoes. Couple observations: Quality seemed excellent and they are a very nice looking shoe. Very comfortable. I did notice that the color varied between the two pairs I tried (one had a more aged and darker look and the other was a "brighter burgundy"). Also, the soles on these shoes are incredibly slippery on carpet. That said, if I could have found a pair that fit I would have kept them.