Customer Reviews Comfortiva Tobago - Soft Spots

Material was stiff. Would take a lot of "breaking in" to become comfortable even if they had fit me..

I normally wear a size 9 1/2D or 10D, but I ordered a size 11W after reading the reviews. The sandals do run short, so it was good advice to order a size up. However, the width was way too big. There was a big gap around my upper foot, and the fit was not comfortable.

The length was okay, but they were way too wide. I usually wear a D width, and that's what I had ordered.

A little too small, I need a half size up

This is an adorable shoe, well made and great to look at. However, it is uncomfortable to wear. I wore around the house, even buying cotton toe-toppers to soften the feel as I was determined to keep them. I soon became realistic, however, and sadly decided to return.

The sizing of this sandal is really off. I usually wear a 9.5 N and ordered a 10 N in this shoe. It was still WAY too small. It isn't available in a 10.5, so I ordered an 11 and we'll see what happens. I've never had to order a shoe larger than a 10 (which is the size of my athletic shoes). It has a cushioned sole, so it seems like it will be comfortable if it fits.

I have narrow feet and the Narrow shoes were too wide. The shoes themselves seemed quite "stiff." Had to return. The Zappos return policy is very poor compared to Amazon. I had to buy another box to return the boxed shoes. I had already wrapped the shoe box in heavy brown paper, but the UPS store said that Zappos requires an actual additional cardboard box. Not having a random cardboard box around that would accommodate the size of the shoe box, I had to buy another container from UPS store for $5.00. So even though the shoes themselves came from Amazon in its "standard" white plastic bag, I had to buy another container to return them. Will not buy from Zappos directly again.

I ordered a 7.5W. They seem true to size although I found them uncomfortable due to the weaving of the leather. Cute but am going to return then since I doubt I could wear them for any length of time due to construction.

I'm consistently an 8.5 wide and these were too big.

The side straps cut into my feet. I liked the design but they just were too uncomfortable.

I order a 10 WW because my feet is swollen by the end of the day, so the width was great, it was the back strap that wasn't long enough for me to fasten the shoe. I thought about re-ordering a size 11 but then the shoe would be too long, so I had to just return the shoes.

This shoe felt very uncomfortable because the leather rubbed on several parts of my foot. I also did not like the hard heel. It's noisy when walking.

10M was too narrow and short

For me, just wasn't comfortable

ed a 9.5 when I wear a 9. I should have ordered a 10! My experience is these run small and tight. I like the shoe tho. I suspect they'll stretch a bit. I just received them so my star rating may be off a bit, hence the 3. Time will tell. Warning: If you use a gift card - Zappos has (to me) an unfavorable policy when it comes to exchanges. Be aware and read the fine print. Other than that, we love Zappos!!

I liked these huaraches and the fit was good. However, there is no way it has a one inch heel. They are almost like flats and I can’t wear flats. I’m really disappointed because otherwise they’re what I was looking for.

Cute shoe but not comfortable especially if you have bunions. It ran small as well.

I really like this style of shoes, but it is too tight over my bunion joint. Very disappointing.

I tried these on but they were uncomfortable...I've returned them.

I always wear a size ten and it was too short. The color (natural) seemed more orange than expected. Liked the style but another color in 10.5.

True to size. Very cute on my feet. They rubbed my feet in multiple spots when trying them on and I thought my feet would be full of blisters within less than an hour, so I returned them.

It was a cute shoe but the fit was off. I usually wear and 81/2 WW but even in a half size larger it was tight. I’m disappointed because I liked the look of the shoe itself.

They did not fit, and I returned them

I love these shoes. Unfortunately, even though they are my regular size, they are too small; I cannot get the straps to go closed.

Very versatile shoe; should have read the reviews, as it is too short.