Customer Reviews SOREL Winter Carnival™

No comfy enough for me. I was hoping the lining was a fur type lining, but it wasn't. Too hard. Not comfortable to walk in. Almost felt like a ski boot. Who needs that?

Seemed UNauthentic. Do not like feel of leather (?). Fabrics feels flimsy ; like It could tear easily . Doesn’t seem sturdy. Just got them and wore around the house only. Still has tags on them Not as I expected. Will return them this week . Have purchased Sorel in past and liked all the ones I have purchased But not these . Bought them due to Boston weather

They were definitely warm however overall the boots were wide and clunky. Alas I returned them and got a different pair of Sorels for a cheaper price and much more feminine.

I knew it when I ordered them but I guess I had to see it again.... this style of boot is just so clompy and big. I just can’t do it ... my feet are kinda big anyway and in these boots they look like buckets - cute buckets !... but still buckets :( sorry I have to return

These boots are quite heavy and clunky. I have pretty long, skinny feet and I felt like they were moving around inside the boot which was rubbing my ankle the wrong way. They are very sturdy and well made, just felt heavy and awkward on my feet.

These boots felt like they were very warm and would be waterproof and good for the snow. I didn't love how bulky they felt at the bottom. They were very wide and I have a wider foot. They felt a little clunky when I walked in them. I think the style is cute and love the material at the top but they didn't lace up as snug as some others I have tried. I am going to look at other Sorel styles and send these back.

Great boot...but, alas, Sorrels are always loose in the heel.

Nice color & great quality. It's just a bit too clompy for what I want. I was hoping they were a bit more streamlined than my old Sorrels, but no. Too bulky for snowshoeing & no support whatsoever. Very warm & a bit more fashionable with the fleece cuff, but they're Sorrels.

Really cute, but sort of clunky. I am a solid 6 in boots, and this shoe felt huge on me--at least 1/2 or maybe a full size larger than I expected it to feel, and I would need to size down so they don't feel like flippers (for comparison, I am a 6.5 in the Slimpback Lace model, so this would be a full size difference within the brand). I have a wider than average toe box, and my feet were swimming in the Carnival. I purchased inserts for comfort, but it still didn't change how huge they felt. There is no arch support (and I do not need much). Overall really cute and warm, but would definitely size down from your normal shoe size.

Very cute boots but my heel flopped right out of it even after sizing down. A smaller size would’ve been too short. I usually wear a size 9 in a ballet flat and a 9 1/2 in a athletic shoe. I ordered the 9 and much too wide and not very soft and comfy either

They seemed really big and bulky, not very attractive on.

I really wanted to love these boots, but the back heel dug into my foot and made it uncomfortable. I tried two sizes, but neither worked. Not a lot of arch support, but they are super cute.

They seemed really big and bulky. My calves are on the wider side so the top of the boots didn’t fit well.

Was not expecting such an awkward fit. The boot in nice and roomy in the footprint but is not "high" if that makes sense so the tops of my feet were squished. If I had gone up in size I would have been swimming in the rest of the boot. The sherpa on the top of the boot also looks kind of worn/dirty so I can only imagine it would look worse with use. Too bad these are going back :(

These are very wide and not comfortable to walk in. I was hoping for some good boots for winter walks but had to return.

Canvas seemed thin/felt cheap.

I really wanted to like this boot because the style is super cute! The problem was the heel is way too loose and it also cut into my heel which gave me a really bad blister. They are warm but you really don’t want to do much walking in them.

I am usually a 7-7.5 and order a size 7, but it was a little small. Also, the fit was strange. At the back of the boot where the rubber ended, it cut in somewhat and the shaft felt like it was angled forward. Overall, I was disappointed. It's going back.

I am a 7.5 wide, and often order an 8 in shoes/boots that don't come in wide. Based on the reviews, I went with a 7.5 The boot was enormous. It felt like a size 9. I sent it back, and am trying out a size 7. I am only doing this because the boot itself is so cute, the blue color looks great, and Zappos has such a great return policy.

These look like serious snow boots. Translate into "these are not pretty". They look very wide, but don't feel as wide as they look. That said, the tongue is attached up to the top lace loop, so that's better than a lot I've tried on. They lace up tightly with one easy pull of the laces. There is a coated canvas upper, with a felt/wool (?) liner. The liner is split in the middle so you can get your foot in. But it doesn't even meet in the middle when I tie the boots -- there is still a small gap (about 1/4 inch) where my foot is covered only by coated canvas. The thought of that at minus 10 degrees isn't pleasant. I'll keep searching for the perfect boot.

These fit lengthwise, but were very tight around the top of my foot. They were also HEAVY. the way they laced, also make me think that snow would easily get into the top of the boot.

Look huge in real life...I really liked how they look in pictures, but in reality they are very clunky. When I took them out of the box, my initial thought was that they sent me wrong size. I have small, narrow feet - usually wear 6 or 6½ - ordered 6 and it looked like 8 ??

Fit is very weird. Wide in toe but short. Returning