Customer Reviews Trotters Simmy

I have a very wide foot & usually wear an 8 or 8.5. I felt the 8.5 WW in these ran a tad short and the toe box seemed not as deep as it should have been. I'm contemplating trying a 9 but it probably would be too loose in the heel and I never wear a 9 in a shoe except for some slippers & flip flops.

I have a narrow foot and ordered this shoe in Narrow but it was too narrow just behind my toes, the widest part of my foot. It felt good at the heel.

Very comfortable shoe. Exactly the shoe I needed to be able to wear all day without pain. Trotters' brand is what I buy when I know I will be walking and sightseeing on vacations.

Love these shoes!! My feet have problems, wide feet, bunions etc. This shoe hides it all. The back of the shoe comes up high and my foot slips out but I am going to get heel grips to keep them from slipping. Its not the shoe its my feet. I recommend the vegetable leather much softer if you have problem feet. Love them! I also bought another pair in different color, nice leather and well made.

I have a 7N foot with an extra skinny heel. This flat is one of the few I have ever found that stays on. The front allows my toes to spread comfortably. The diagonal strap held my foot in place with no slipping off the heel. I definitely recommend this shoe for the Italian foot.

I love that these shows come in wide. Though, I ear a 10.5 D so that's what I got and they slide in the back so I recommend getting a half size smaller. They fit my arch support inserts which is great. The strap doesn't do a ton to help your foot stay in, it is more for decoration. So if that is why you want to strap, I recommend trying a different shoe. Overall, cute and comfortable.

the fit is perfect for my 10S size foot. Trotters seem true to form. I just want this in a dull dark color rather than the tumbled veg style.

First, I put arch inserts into all my shoes even with shoes that have support in them (these do). The strap keeps my foot in the shoe securely even with the added insert. That's good. This particular color has varying areas of darker color which is actually rather attractive. The squared off toe gives it a nice style. The shoe comes up high enough over the toes to eliminate any rubbing on tailor bunions. Yes, my feet need help but I don't want to give up style. And I don't have to with these shoes. Will consider other colors.

Very comfortable shoe. It is light weight and very cushy. I was worried about the color being sage, but it is more of a lighter brown than what I would call sage. It's a good color for brown dress pants or blue jeans. I didn't want a tan brown and this worked great! I like the Mary Jane style with slanted strap. It makes it look more up to date. I tried other brands and the narrows are not narrow. This shoe is a true narrow and fits the heel perfectly.

Super comfortable. I added heel grip inserts and then they were perfect. Nice cushioning for a flat. Good all the long wedding day I got them for.

I have short wide feet with a very high instep and arch. I've always bought and owned many styles and brands of shoes (in all price points), as most don't fit well. I ordered the Simmy in size 6ww. I wore them in total comfort from day one, even the strap is long enough to fit over my high arch. They were so comfortable, I ordered another pair and also ordered the Doris style.

Cute shoe but a bit long (and I wear an 11). I will reorder in a 10 1/2. I have found that Trotters shoes are inconsistently sized, so I am glad Zappos has such an easy return policy. The only other thing is that the bisque was darker than I anticipated and looked more like the rust looked on my monitor. I was hoping for a more nude shoe look. Still if I can get the size to fit I will keep them.

The red color is more orange. The toe box was narrower than I expected but the heel felt fine in the narrow width. I returned because it rubbed the joint of my big toe.

These are comfortable shoes but... To help all you buyers who are hard to fit like me: I have a D width toe and have a AAA width heel (see, and you thought you had it bad! :) These are soft, supple and beautiful. The toe box is a little too tight and the top of the toe pushes down a bit as well. I was hoping that the wide width would compensate for the narrow looking toe. The rest of the shoe was too wide so I can actually walk right out of the shoe. Before you suggest heel pads I have tried them and they always push my feet forward into the toe box rather than just snugging closer to my heel. I am returning these and hoping to find my dream close toed shoes. Wish me luck, as I have not found them in 50 years but I keep trying!

I have mixed feelings about this shoe. On one hand it's a nice basic flat; the strap helps with the fit. On the downside I have found after wearing the heel is loose and they are not staying on very well. Could be me.

Nice looking flat. Great for those with a narrow heel such as myself-no slippage. I will be returning them because these are too narrow through the toe area.

Nice looking shoe, didn't work for my wide toes and narrow heel.

Odd fit, especially in the toes.

I absolutely love this shoe. It was so comfortable right out of the box. I wore it to a conference. I wore no show peds which kept my feet from sweating. It does not slip off my heels. The strap is comfy and I got compliments. It has good support too. Worth the price.

These are the most comfortable shoe you can wear the whole day. It's hides my bunion it has arch support the little square toe makes the feet look smaller I'm a size nine, they are true to size room enough for socks or swollen feet after lots of walking the strap looks cute no matter what age you are arch support walking on a cloud is so refreshing love this shoe . Getting more what a find perfect

I have one foot that is a whole size larger than the other so I need the strap for the smaller foot. Usually such shoes look too clunky. These are slimming, classy and so comfortable.

Very nice comfortable shoe without looking bulky. Quality is nice, insole is very cushiony but firm. Looks best with a no-show sock. Seemed a bit narrow upon first try but I am keeping them as I already feel they are conforming to my foot nicely. My second pair of Trotters.

My toes are wide but my arch area is narrow - this shoe is great because it has a more squared off toe but has the strap across to keep the shoe on my foot. Instantly comfortable.

These are really cute shoes. I got the blue suede. They are very versatile, and can be worn with jeans, dress pants, dresses. They are comfortable and better looking in person than the pictures represent. These are great little shoes!

Love this shoe! The box-y toe gave me some wiggle room. It was a perfect fit with a low heel. This isn't a style for a dressy affair, but could still look nice for business attire.