Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

Look good and feel warm.

Adore these. My go-to winter boot now in northern WI! Cute, comfy, dry and warm. Easy on and off. A winner.

Love it. I needed some snow boots for a trip at the last minute, and these were perfect. They fit really well and still leave enough room for thick socks. Plus, they’re lightweight.

These boots are extremely lightweight and water-proof. I walked through slushy snow and my socks were dry. However, they don't look as nice as in the picture. The top of the boots look almost identical, often I can't distinguish which side is which. They look more like a pair of walking braces. They make the heel noise when I walk. They also run big. I have to wear a pair of thick and a pair of thin socks to feel comfortable in them. They seem to be stretching too. I would have returned them had I not worn them already.

Cute Boots! I was looking for a cute winter boot after my NF ones were stolen and these will do the job. They are cute and warm and at a great price!!!

I wear an 8 and occasionally need a show with a wide toe box or an 8.5. I ordered an 8. They fit. They feel a wee bit short, cram my toe a little. I can't decide if they'll give enough to keep them. Nothing special about styling, they look a little like the interior of a European rental car -- stiff and basic. I wanted boots to protect my feet in moderately deep snow. These would do the trick.

I purchased these boots for a trip to Lapland, Finland and Sweden in the beginning of February, so it was quite cold with lots of snow. They were WONDERFUL! My feet were never cold and we did a lot of activities such as dog sledding and reindeer sledding. Everything was covered in snow and the boots were great. I wore heavy wool socks with them which is a must. The boots are Very supportive of your ankles and arch. I'd still be wearing them daily if I didn't live in a sub tropical climate!

I went 1/2 size up from my refular shoe size. The best part is they are so light .

Love these boots! After reading tons of reviews & trying on 3 other pairs of highly rated Columbia boots, these are my IT boots. Just wore them for the first time in 6 inches of snow at 27 degrees. After this half-hour walk, I'm thrilled. Comfy, toasty warm! And really cute, even on my size 10 feet. I have narrow, bony, flat feet. My orthotics and thick wool socks fit easily, with room for toe wiggling. By way of comparison, although the other Columbia boots (Heavenly Omni-Heat size 10 & 10.5) I tried all felt 1/2 to 1 size small, the Ice Maiden boots are true to size for me.

I never write reviews of shoes. But these boots are AMAZING. I bought them for a trip to Iceland. They are sturdy, warm, and super comfortable. I put my whole foot in water several times and they were completely water resistant. They definitely ran at least a half size too big, but this was OK because I wore two pairs of socks under them which I had intended anyway, to ensure staying warm. I am really picky about shoes and these totally got the job done. You can wear them for hiking, touring around, or just regular every day stuff and they look smart doing all those things, which is a bonus. Highly recommend.

I ordered my regular size 6 and with my heavy socks the fit is perfect. They feel a bit wide to me. I need more arch support than these boots have, but there is room to put supports in them and still feel comfortable. Boots feel nice and warm. A bit clunky feeling, but comfy. Style is great. Would be nice to have this style knee high. Great price!

I have wide calves and narrow feet, so finding boots that fit well is a challenge. I also live in snowy Western New York and I walk a lot. Basically, I am pretty hard to please where boots are concerned! Overall, I am very happy with these. They fit me very well. They're super warm and definitely waterproof. Not the cutest boots I've ever owned, but not the ugliest either. My only complaint is the lack of arch support. They feel comfy when I first put them on, but the lack of support leaves my feet achy in a short time. If you plan on walking a lot in these boots, I recommend inserting some sort of arch support for a cheap fix. Other than that, these are perfect!

I purchased these boots for a trip to Colorado in February and they were wonderful! They were super comfortable right out of the box and didn’t need breaking in. I ordered my normal size and they are great both with thin and thick socks. I was concerned about how warm they would be as I have circulation problems, but I never had an issue with cold feet! I wore them with thick wool socks and my feet stayed nice and warm even chasing my 3 and 6 year olds through super deep snow. I have thin legs and was also concerned with being able to get a snug fit. Due to the laces I was able to tie them tight enough to go through snow up to my thighs with no leaks. Feet stayed warm and dry no matter what I did! Now we are back home in Texas and they are great with thinner socks on rainy cold days. Would highly recommend!

I bought these boots at the last minute because there was snow at our destination. I normally have a lot of difficulty breaking in new shoes, especially boots. However, these boots were comfortable right away. They were also warm in the 10 degree weather. I had to go a half size up because I usually wear wide and I have orthotics. Because of that, I ordered size 8 although my foot measures 6 1/2 and I normally wear 7 or 7 1/2. Thanks, Zappo’s for prompt delivery and free returns!

I really like these boots. I have a Morton’s neuroma and they do not cause pain in that area! I wore them around the house for a few hours to be sure they would work. I usually get a wide shoe but these were plenty wide! Very nice!

Hands down: best winter boots! They’re light and keep my toes warm. They look nice and are easy to out on and off. I don’t think they’re completely waterproof, but don’t go puddle jumping all that often anymore so that’s fine for me. I’d definitely recommend, especially since they’re not too expensive!!