Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I ordered a 1/2 size larger than my usual size and they are perfect for wearing with my usual socks and with thicker boot socks as well. These boots are warm, comfortable and very cute! They seem well made.

These shoes fit very well. They are very comfortable and warm.

Love these boots. Warm and comfortable and easy to get on and off.

I was in the hunt for winter boots for a while and tried 9 other styles before settling on this. LOVE them, comfortable, stylish and SO SO warm. Absolutely perfect.

These boots look fine but are not as “cold weather worthy” as I thought they would be, nor do they provide an arch support that would make them more comfortable. Adding an orthotic would only make the boot too snug which, as we all know, makes your feet get cold quickly. I used them while shoveling my driveway and my toes got so cold they started to cramp. Outside temperature was 31-34. These are good for running to the store, but for working outside, guess I’ll have to get some warmer boots!

Right boot bothered the inside of my ankle.

Keeps my feet warm and dry! This is my third pair in a different color. Great quality for the price.

Very comfortable and keeps my feet warm and dry ! This is my third pair in a different color.

I bought these boots for playing in the snow with my grandkids. They seem very warm & comfortable. There is no arch support so I kept the 8 1/2 instead of the 8 & took out their supports & put in my own. Now they feel perfect. I think they are pretty cute.

These are so so comfortable and I think they will keep my feet really warm. I look forward to trying them out in the snow.

Simply great boot and price. I have a narrow foot and it worked. Laces help. Cute style.

I ordered a size 8 1/2 (my normal size) and a size 9 to see which pair felt better with thick socks. They both were exactly the same size. I measured with a tape measure! So I sent the size 9 back and kept the 8 1/2. I think they were sized wrong, but the tag on the inside said 8 1/2. ?????

I could probably have ordered an 11 and been happy with it, but 10.5 was the biggest they had at the moment. They are a sturdier, more supportive boot than my last snow boots, which is a big improvement. I love the way they look--I've been getting compliments on them.

I like these boots overall, I’ll be keeping them. A couple things to consider are... They are rather clunky, the thick rubber soles don’t have any give to them so it feels a bit like walking on platforms. I also read in many of the reviews to go a half size up if you want to wear thick winter socks.. I’m a true 7 and that’s what I ordered, there is plenty of room for thick socks and if anything they are still a little big. If I had gone with a 7 1/2 I would have had to return them. Despite those things they are comfortable enough and I think they will serve the purpose of walking around Germany this winter.

Went half a size up, and they fit perfectly. Wonderful boot for Wisconsin winters.

I followed other's recommendations to order a half size up, as they run small. Sure enough the fit was very good with room for my thick socks. My size would have been too snug. They are really cute, comfy and warm.

Very happy with my purchase. My feet were warm and dry

These are comfortable right out of the box. So warm. They feel sturdy but they don't feel like cinder blocks on my feet. Highly recommend.

The boots look nice, but they are not 100% comfortable: a bit of a push on the toes I am not sure they will stretch since I believe front part is not leather I am still keeping them though

I love them. They are really comfortable!!