Customer Reviews Columbia Ice Maiden™ II

I was most interested in traction. But have not been able to test that yet

Materials used in construction are very good, but fit is highly questionable. Rhe advice to order one's regular shoe size is incorrect. Yes, they will fit "snugly instead of being sloppy, but a regular shoe size is too short and too snug (narrow) - no room for warm socks. Reviews consistently say they don't keep the front half of the foot warm. What good are stylish winter boots if they don't keep you warm? I am returning them, which is a huge disappointment.

this is the worst boot I ever purchased...They have no cushion or arch in them...stay away if you have bad feet, neuropathy and older than a teenager...

The wide is way to narrow and not much insulation inside boot.

Love the style and look of the boots but was too narrow. Returned for wide width and there was no difference.

The wide size didn't feel any wider than the normal sizing so had to return. They are super cute but just not comfortable and didn't fit well.

there was not enough room for my foot to fit comfortably with my orthotics in. It is a nice looking & well made. It was not wide enough for my 4E left foot.

Liked the look and seemed sturdy but didn’t fit me well. The sole wasn’t very form fitting and I don’t think an insert would change that.

I absolutely love this boot. Sizing was perfect, design cute and very warm. In fact I loved them so much I bought a second pair. in another color on another website, because Zappos did not have it in my size. Ill be prepared for winter wonderland vacation in Vermont.

I haven't been able to wear them out in the snow yet since it's only November, but they will definitely keep me warm and dry. I love the lace ups.

These boots fit great and are so comfortable, warm and waterproof for winter wear!

Just loved them, but inherited a pair of boots from a friend, so didn't need them. Wish I wasn't in Texas and could rationalize spending the additional funds.

My feet grew after having my son and none of my winter boots fit! Living in MN that’s not ok, so I took a chance on these and love em! I am a 10.5 with a wide foot and they fit great! Best part is they are so light but warm. And really cute with out make my big feet look like Bigfoot

Fit was true to size. Will be wearing them when it snows.

I really wanted to like these but these boots were just plain uncomfortable, even after I traded in my normal size 11 to try a size 12 - neither fit and both were uncomfortable. The toe box was a snugger-than-comfortable fit, and the overall size felt a full size too small. I couldn't even tell a difference between the size 11 and size 12 pairs. And once I stood and walked around on these boots (in both sizes) the sole felt hard, not cushioned at all and I knew by the time I spent more than a half hour in these boots my knees would be aching me. Nice style, but two thumbs down for fit and comfort.

The top painfully pressed on my big toe knuckle.

I have small feet but knowing I would also wear winter socks I ordered a size 6 and it fit perfectly. Tomorrow is our first snow day and can't wait to walk the dog and my feet stay warm!