Customer Reviews Columbia Redmond™ Mid Waterproof

I purchased this shoe locally late last winter and was very upset to find that even though they claim to be waterproof, one of them was not. The right shoe seems to be waterproof, but the left one definitely is not, which defeats the very purpose of my purchase. I live on a farm and wear them all winter when I work outside and walk my dog in the fields. I expect more from Columbia and am extremely disappointed, especially because they were not cheap!

I so wanted to love these boots. They are cute, with the pink accents to give them a little feminine touch. They felt good enough when I tried them on and during a brief period of time walking around the house to test them out. When the time came to put them to use, I found that my feet quickly became sore and uncomfortable in them. I don't usually have trouble with shoes, so this was a bit of a surprise. I decided to give them another chance, thinking maybe there was a little break in required. My next hike in them proved that something is just not quite right with them, as my feet started aching halfway through the hike. By the end, I couldn't get out of them fast enough! I did get a chance to test out how waterproof they are and found that to be agreeable, but comfort is of prime importance with hiking boots and these let me down.

I ordered these online and was very disappointed in the product. I read the reviews and chose to go a whole size up like everyone mentioned. The size up actually worked out but the boots were really uncomfortable. No cushion or support in the sole, and my feet felt like they could move around pretty easily in the boots, even though the length for my feet was perfect. I didn't feel like I had that great of ankle support either. That being said these boots are on the way back to the store.

Had to return - left foot a tad bit small.

Nice shoe . Not for wide feet. I had to return them. They do run small. And narrow. Bummed .

I've had great Columbia hiking boots in the past and I am so disappointed in these. I hike as a part of my job and these were put to the test from January to April. I thought that maybe they needed to be "broken in" but they're still so uncomfy!! They claimed waterproof guaranteed, they are not waterproof. Usually I wear a size 8, 8.5 still fits very small. Underneath the removable sole, the fabric/ material bunched up and deformed underneath the toes and it makes it very uncomfortable.

I've had great Columbia hiking boots in the past and I am so disappointed in these. I hike as a part of my job and these were put to the test from January to April. I thought that maybe they needed to be "broken in" but they're still so uncomfy!! They claimed waterproof guaranteed, they are not waterproof. Usually I wear a size 8, 8.5 still fits very small. Underneath the removable sole, the fabric/ material bunched up and deformed underneath the toes and it makes it very uncomfortable.

I bought these on vacation when my other boots fell apart. When I walked around the store in them they felt good. I had to go up half a size. Once I began some serious hiking my toes were throbbing. The toe box is narrow and my toes were jamming up as I hiked. I'm unable to wear these now. I've only worn them once, and feel I've lost the money I paid for them.

I bought these boots for my daughter. She loved the fit and feel from the start. Unfortunately, after 5 month, she wore these in the rain and in less than 1/2 hour these boots were TOTALLY soaked thru. Maybe if Columbia used their OutDry technology on these, they would be more waterproof? Until then, we cannot recommend these boots for anything but light dry weather walks.

I don't know who good and comfortable these shose are cause I can't where them there to small. And I don't have the box anymore can't return them so I am stuck with boots that don't fit . so not to happy that a played all that money for something I can't use.

Way too narrow, no matter which size I tried on.