Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny 2 Wide Calf Leather Riding Boots

These boots are great in every way. The fit and feel are fabulous, especially if you wear a larger size.

Love the look and the richness of this boot. Great height and gaps a little at knee, but so comfortable that I’m keeping. I have a narrow heel and these slip a bit, but I’ll just wear a thicker sock or put in a wedge at the heel. Have looked a while for a boot this nice at a great price.

Great boots, I’ve worn them every day since they arrived and get compliments from my friends and family

Just came in and I tried them on. They were so comfortable I ended up wearing them all day. I am 5ft and they came just below my knees and the footbed is very comfortable. I am very pleased with them! I find it extremely hard to find boots to go over my calves. I have muscular calves and these boots had plenty of room and didn't squeeze my skin. I love them so far!!

Runs true to size. Great for wide calf & tucking pants into boot.

I’m usually a 9.5M wide calf. After three tries I have the perfect fit, a 9W wide calf. These run narrow and large by 1/2 size. A tiny gap at the top but I can live with that. Super soft, luxury leather and right at bottom of knee. Wore all day the first day and my feet are happy.

Love these boots! I always have a hard time getting "wide calf" boots that are actually wide enough. These are! The leather is soft and supple and very comfortable. The back zipper takes some getting used to as I have always had boots with a side zip. I like how the top is a bit asymmetrical for more slimming look. These are my new favs!

I love this boot so much. Last year I bought the black pair and I had to splurge on the brown pair as well. They are soooo comfy. I have one calf that is fatter than the other so I struggle to find boots that fit. I have an inch difference. They are perfect. Love, love love.

These are my favorite boots. I love then so much I’ve now bought them in multiple colors. I’m an athletic person and they comfortably fit my more muscular caves while providing a good deal of footbed comfort. Love!

These boots were beautiful but unfortunately the calf was too wide for me. I had to return.

This is the best boot I’ve ever bought in my life!!!

These are true to size and width, the moderate arch support is amazing! The boots look incredible and feel incredible as well!

Love these Boots my 4th pair own them in all colors ..A true Zappos shopper

After wearing my black pair all fall and winter last year, I decided I had to also have the Whiskey color as well. I have a wide foot and loved that these come in a wide calf and wide width. Makes them super comfortable to wear with jeans and socks and still have circulation to your feet. I can walk miles in these boots. There's not a ton of support, but they are well made and don't hurt my feet. Highly recommend them!

Beautiful boot. You only need a 1/2 bigger (I went full plus wide and it was too big). I have never purchased or needed a wide width but based on the reviews purchased and loved it! First boot I could fit over a 16.5" calf. My calves are muscular and the ankle was a bit loose and I have a normal width above the calf muscle. The top by the knee is about 1" to wide and so I had to return them because they looked ridiculous. I am so disappointed because the rest of the boot is beautiful.

Love them! Takes a couple wears to break in the zipper on the heel, but then they are great.

Love these boots! Very stylish and high quality. I am only 5'0 tall, calf is about 13" in length from ankle bone to knee cap, calf is 14" round at the biggest part (just below the knee) and these boots fit perfectly. I do feel the boot ridge slightly under the knee when sitting but nothing unbearable.

These are absolutely lovely boots. I was extremely pleased with the buttery soft leather and the fit and comfort. I returned them reluctantly through no fault of the boots. I was hoping for a little more height in the shaft. I have really long legs, and I was hoping they would come up high enough to pass as brown riding boots for actual equestrian use. Since the zipper is up the back, you could use them without scratching your saddle, and the heel is correct for riding. They fit my 17” calf very nicely, not tight and I could have tucked in slim trousers. They felt very comfortable on my size 12B feet. I think the quality was worth the price and I will certainly consider buying Sam Edelman footwear in the future.

Sadly I had to return. The boots are the most beautiful shade and butter soft! They fit the top part of my calves great but bunched a bit at the ankles, and it altered the look. If you’re thinking about them, try them just because they are so pretty!

Love!! Very cute and comfortable. I have wider calves and they fit with a bit of room to spare.

Fav boots!

This is easily my favorite boot. So fashionable and crazy comfortable. Classic, chic, LOVE!

Love them!

Love these boots! They go with everything. I ordered a half-size up to be able to put insoles and it work out great.

These boots have beautiful buttery leather. I got them in Forest grey and they are gorgeous! I had to get W even though I normally but M width. It's slightly wide for me but regular M is narrow. Also the shaft is true wide calf. My calf is probably about 18 inches and these fits perfectly. But only on the W width pair. Overall very happy with it!