Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

Cute shoe however I felt it ran small - will be returning them.

These are the cutest shoes ever! well made, like all Fryes. I ordered the silver in 5.5 but the pointy toe really pushes down on my big toenail, I'm going to try the 6. Otherwise the shoe fit. If it helps anyone: I have a low volume foot, narrow heel and normal/wideish toebox. I have a lot of trouble finding a shoe to fit, let alone a slip on; I can usually fit my hand in the shoe on top of my foot. If you have a wide foot this may not be the shoe for you. But such a cute shoe!!!

Normally, I'm between a 9 and a 9-1/2. The 9-1/2 in the Melanie was too short on one foot, (my larger foot, and where my 2nd toe is longer,) so I ordered the 10. It's a bit better, yet still might be short on my toes. I'm hoping the softness of the leather will stretch and mold to my feet with time. They are very pretty, otherwise, and fairly comfortable - not like an athletic shoe is comfortable, but good enough for a short time. I tried the grey the first time, but was disappointed in the drabness of the color. The cognac is, like it shows on the screen, a brighter color.

I like a bit of a wedge heel and thought it was built up inside the shoe. It was not, it was too flat for me. Wonderful style and left soft. Sorry it didn't work.

Love the slip on simple style! As others have stated, toe space was tight at first but soft leather has stretched to provide a comfortable fit. Would have given 5 stars if there was arch support...none. At this price...should have.

I ordered a size 9 because that's what I wear in their ballet shoes. According to other reviews they're true to size, but even though I have a narrow foot, they are still too tight. I wore them around the house for a couple days hoping they would stretch out. Sadly, I'm sending them back. I ordered the Dylan hoping they'll work out better for me.

The shoes seem well made, and the leather is very soft. They are however for narrow type of foot. My feet are not wide at all, yet these shoes felt too snug. Because of that, they did not look nice on my feet, neither were comfortable. It did not help that I ordered half size bigger. I believe that for the narrow feet these may be nice and comfortable pair.

Love these shoes! Look great, feel great. I have a very high arch and instep, and also a wide foot, so they are a bit snug right out of the box. But the leather is so soft and smooth that I'm sure they'll mold to my feet in no time. To the other reviewer who said she got a used pair - that's part of the design! If you look closely on the photos, the marks are there as well. They make them to look a little "worn in." Frye has done this on a number of other shoe designs as well. So if your white soles have a few black marks on them - that's part of the broken-in look. I gave 4/5 on comfort and overall because of the stretch-in time I'll need (whereas with the Frye Reagan shoe, I can wear right out of the box).

These shoes are terrific. They have soft, comfortable soles and leather uppers. They are good to wear with skirts or pants, but why the heck do they not make a 10½? The 10, on these pointy-toed shoes is pinchy across the ball of the foot, and the 11 will not stay on. If they bother to make an 11 at all (and hooray for that), why not make the 10½? I would have bought two if they did. I had to return both pairs.

I love the shoe's soft leather, and they feel really nice...for the first hour or so. Then the left shoe starts rubbing on the top of my foot, and I end up with really sore toes. I have fairly normal feet, so I'm a little disappointed. But they sure are pretty.

I was looking for something in between a slip-on skater brand shoe and a ballet flat. These fit the bill. Fairly comfortable straight out of the box. I bought the gold, which has a purposefully worn look as shown in the pictures. Overall this shoe is a keeper, but I feel it is slightly overpriced.

Great slip on for everyday in the summer. Terrific caramel color. Fits my widish foot perfectly. Decent arch support will help. Bottom soles are adequate.

difficult tp write size as the help was loose and the width tight

Fits slightly large. Not much arch support

Nice looking casual slip on. Wish the toe box wasn’t quite so narrow

I love this shoe, I have two other pair in the same style. But this was definitely not grey. More of a dark tan or taupe, maybe, so I am returning them. Really a great shoe, though I love this style!

Leather is lovely. however I do not think it will stretch out enough - it's just too small entirely even in my usual size. Returning.

Beautiful looking shoe but too narrow for me. I'm usually a regular/medium width.

It rubbed my heels and I have huge blisters, don’t think I can wear them again unfortunately

Loved the style and leather looked very nice, high quality. Unfortunately, the 6.5M felt loose and wide without any arch support. I could barely get the 6M on so too tight. Very disapppointed.

Doesn’t feel like leather. Too flat. Pretty shoe but hurt toes and loose around heel.