Customer Reviews Frye Melanie Slip On

I have two other pairs of these shoes and really like them. They are very comfortable and easy to throw on and looks good. I returned these shoes because the grey color is actually taupe. It is not grey at all! I compared it to a grey shirt I have thinking maybe it would blend nicely, but no. I am returning it for the silver. If you are looking for more of a nice taupe go for this!

Overall these are comfortable. I bought them because I am pregnant again and I am not traveling for work in heels this time! These are fashionable and cute while still being supportive. They are a little stiff at first but I think with wear the leather will soften. I think I will order another color

Yes, beautifully designed shoes, cheap execution: Very tight and narrow in the toe box. The metallic felt 1/2 size smaller, yet same length as antiqued gray. (size 9.5) The leather is mottled and distressed, random stainings. Extremely comfortable. Allowing for a couple of days breaking in, lightly prancing around inside, I was committed. Day two of prancing, to my horror, I spied rubber coming away from leather top right side right shoe.. Yes, I was horrified. There was no gapping on sides, no heel slippage and soles are thin. Made in China, I had not noticed. I realize now, too good to be true?

Great look. Disappointed in the insoles. Not very cushy or comfy for a flat but I like them anyway and will keep them. Soft leather.

So loved the appearance of the cognac shoes. They were comfortable, but the fit was wrong. I must be between sizes, which doesn't sound so bad, but with the soft leather, I am sure they would stretch to a point of being way too loose. I considered ordering 1/2 size down, but don't think that will work. So back they went.

Cute shoe but color is definitely purple, not gray. Returned these.

I love this shoe! The pewter is beautiful and so versatile. Sadly I have a higher than normal instep and it was simply too tight.

Stumbled upon these while browsing and really was taken with their look. Ordered them and they arrived almost immediately (thank you Zappos) but unfortunately they are small in length and width. I am a true size 8, occasionally finding 8 a little large and these were small. Reading the reviews it seems they do stretch but they would have needed to stretch a lot and I really can't take the chance they might or might not so I am returning them. Very disappointed as they are really a sleek and stylish casual shoe and I LOVED the antique grey color. Such a pity - so Frye please get your sizing checked!

I ordered/received the pair in white; which is actually more of a bone color. Appear to be true to size in length, but with a slightly narrow toe box, due to the pointier toe design. Leather appears to be supple and should stretch to fit in short order. I have a narrow heal, and the fit is comfortably snug for now. Hoping I won't see as much stretching in heel as I need in the toe area. I was a big fan of the old school Keds Champions, so I'm hoping these become an acceptable substitute. Also these are more pricey than leather Keds, so I'm hoping for durability. Was hoping for more arch support, but I have added leather arch supports, and the fit seems to accommodate this addition.

Wanted a spring slip on that was a little jazzier and classier than my Toms. Got these in red which I love. Agree with other reviews that the toe area is a little tight but they seem to be stretching out. My feet are long and narrow and these feel great. I think they will be a good travel shoe as well.

These are very cute shoes! I am usually a 7 and these were a little too small, so I am going to exchange them. Also, the white part of the shoe is not a stark, clean white. It's almost kind of "weathered," as if they'd already been worn. It's visible in the picture if you look close enough. I'm not sure it's a deal-breaker, though.

Cute shoe, but shallow for me in the toe box. I would say this is a true flat, not the 3/4-inch heel indicated in the description.