Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Alexandra

The style was just OK. Toe bed too tight. Maybe a WW would fit better, but I did not like the style enough to try it again.

The length is what I need but even the narrow was too wide in the heel. That was disappointing. I ended up going with a half size smaller and the heel fit much better. It was even a medium?? So wonder if the size 9 was not marked correctly - maybe it wasn't really a narrow. Now, I just hope going a half size too small doesn't bring discomfort down the road.

These are very cute and seem comfy - but were too wide in the heel for me (common problem for me with booties). Width across the foot was good and length seems true to size. What’s odd is that I got another rockport Cobb hill bootie in the exact same size (6.5 wide) that fits great. Nice support.

I really likes the ruched styling on these boots, but unfortunately they did not fit well. These were wide width (D), but still were tight on my feet. Every manufacturer has a different measure of wide width for W, WW, D, E, EE, so it is hard to tell if a particular width will fit.

I liked the style, but it was just too small.

Fit my feet weird. They seem like they are designed for long slender feet because they don't have much room in the toe box. Comfort was just ok and style was nice but nothing special. I usually wear 7.5 and the 7.5 fit well other than being too narrow in the toes and too wide in the heel.

I ordered a wide and a half size up and thought the rounded toe would be more comfortable, but it just wasn't roomy enough. Definitely narrower than most wides although to length worked out fine. They also made my feet look larger than most boots. They were pretty comfortable but I knew I couldn't do a lot of walking in them without rubbing. Sorry they didn't work out.

Heads up ladies, the blue is all teal and VERY shiney.

The one that looks like a regular brown color in the photos and is labelled "Stone" is really much more of a stone color - very taupe and not at all brown. If you're looking for a brown boot, this isn't it.

The fit was ok I just didn't love the style for me.

cute shoes but to tight in width, i wears an 8W and these were very tight.

These shoes WOULD be comfortable, if the Cobb Hill logo on the inside weren't raised with very pronounced stitching around it. The raised bit extends part way into the ball of the foot with the result that it feels like something is bunched up inside your shoe. The stitching ends right in the middle of the ball of the foot, exactly placed for blisters. Also, I wanted a blue shoe, but these are more 80s teal. Finally, Cobb Hills run small. Half size up always fits best.

Very nicely padded but even the W width isn't quite wide enough for my problem foot...oddly enough the taller-shaft version of this boot fits me very well in the width. I was hoping for the same fit in this style, but will have to return them.

NOPE! Pretty color, nice detail, but this shoe runs narrow in the toe box.

I hate to be the nay sayer amongst all of the positive reviews, but these did not work for me. I have very wide feet (6w) with bunions on my right foot. Finding comfortable shoes has been next to impossible task. These were pretty comfortable, I was surprised that my extreme wide right foot actually fit in the boot. (Ordered a 6W) Initially, these felt comfortable. I usually walk around the house for about an hour to make sure before I decide to keep. Within 5 min, I can already feel that the ball of my right foot started to feel a bit sensitive. Even the slightest heels, with no arch support tend to do that for me. I live in LA so we don't walk far. However, I've been in search of comfortable, water proof boots to wear for my trip to NYC. If I hadn't found a super comfortable ECCO boots last weekend, I might have kept these. However, I just didn't see myself being able to walk for hours in these boots. I didn't want to spend $150+ on something I can only wear for an hour. So back it goes.

Very good quality boot, but has narrow toe box.

These are quite cute, but I'm having 2 issues - first, the inward tapered heel feels a little unstable; and the width is narrower than what I typically need / get in M.

I really wanted to love this boot. The blue color was beautiful. I ordered in a wide, but it was still too snug. I don't even really have a wide foot . I only ordered wide to accommodate for thicker socks during winter and it was really uncomfortable. Beautiful looking boot but width just wasn't right for me. Sadly, going back.

I was really excited to get this boot. I'm usually a very true 8.5 wide. This boot I could not even get my foot into. The style was super cute and I was not happy having to send them back.

cute boot but there's no way you could wear this boot with a short sock because the zipper scraps the side of your leg. very uncomfortable. You have to wear a longer sock or stockings.

I wish I could upload a picture to this review. The pair I received does not look like the picture. The strap is a different color; the brown of the strap makes the rest of the boot appear more of an olive color. My first thought was that the strap is fake leather. Not the quality of my other Cobb Hill shoes and boots.

These boots are so cute and the inside seems comfy but my heel slips up in the back. I have average/narrow feet and skinny ankles, and the opening was way too wide.

Nice looking, but not the Cobb Hill fit I expected. Got the 9.5M. A little snug, tight toe box. Usually a 9.5M, 9N Cobb Hill sandals fit well so the fit of these boots was a surprise. The heel was a little narrow for me, felt a wobbly on them. Returning.

Really soft leather. Feels good, but...I could tell by looking at the soles they were not really wide. Maybe they would have stretched enough to not pinch my toes, but since the last was so narrow, I wasn't willing to risk it. Color was much different than the picture. I though it would be bluer. It was much greener. With luck, I can wear a 6M, because wides are so hard to find. The 6W was fine in length, but not wide enough for my duck feet. Back they go and I have to keep trying.

I LOVE Cobb Hill because their other boots I've purchased fit me in an 11. In many brands an 11 is too small and a 12 is too big, and there are few 11.5 so I'm stuck. But Cobb Hill 11 fits me like a glove. Until this shoe. Which is so small in an 11 that it hurts. They're so cute. Sadly, they're going back.