Customer Reviews Cole Haan Air Carma Open Toe Pump

I had to return these shoes and I was so sad that I had to ship them back. I am looking for a polished dressy shoe to wear to parties, weddings, etc. and I have had my eye on this pair for a while. I am hesitant to spend this much on a pair of shoes! I got these the other day and the second I put them on, they hurt my foot. I got my true size and I don't have a wide foot. This shoe pinched my toes and I didn't want to take the chance of breaking them in. Usually I will wear a pair of shoes with thick gym socks to break them in. I didn't want to risk it with these babies. This is a gorgeous shoe and it is timeless. I wish it would have worked out for me!

When I saw these pumps came in Wide, I thought I had died and gone to Heaven. Unfortunately, it was too good to be true. True, I got my foot into them (unlike regular Cole Haans), but they were still too tight for comfort. I am a very true 8W (was actually a fit model for another shoe company) but even the 8 1/2 was too small. I considered going to a 9 but I am still not sure the toe area would have been comfortable. So sad...

Similar to my review of the Carma black patent leather slingback version, except this one was much more uncomfortable. Toe box painfully squished my toes. Beautiful to look at, but not when I was walking in them.