Customer Reviews Cobb Hill Cobb Hill Bethany

I tried these in two different colors, the gray and the almond. They are comfortable, but the foot liner almost feels too padded. So much so that it makes the shoes feel awkward. The boot was nice, but for the price, I would expect them to look nicer. They are pretty shiny, and to me, that equates to cheap-looking. I returned them.

These were just okay. I had to choose between several pairs of boots and only keep one, and the Doc Martens won out over these. A rear zipper on an ankle boot is a hard sell. Bottom line was, these are nice, but not nice enough.

Loved them until the back zipper broke. Is it fixable?

I have these same boots in the black suede and love them. So I thought I'd try the leather version. Well, they look cheap and fit like a completely different shoe. So I'm sending them back.

The height and heel of these boots were great. I liked the zipper entry. But the arch support was not enough for my recurrent plantar fascitis.

I have a pair of these from 1-2 years ago in teal, which I love, and I really wanted another pair in red, but they aren't making that color this year. SO disappointing! I tried this black and brown flowered pattern, as it was the most interesting looking of the colors available, and they are pretty. And the fit is just the same as before, which is perfect. But the zippers were so hard to zip and unzip that I returned them. Please bring back the bright and interesting colors in this boot!

I wanted to love these but they looked a little cheap for the price. I ordered the Sorel combat boots and these and the Sorel's won. These felt really stiff out of the box. Maybe they would break in if worn a lot but I like shoes to be comfortable out of the box. Sadly sending these back.

I usually take a B width in Cobb Hill shoes, but these were tight. I got the black multi color and the design is floral, which I couldn't really tell online. Of note -- It was clear upon opening the box that the pair of boots I received had been worn previously. The zippers and laces were undone and the shoe showed creased areas where someone had worn them around for awhile... perhaps just in their home deciding whether or not to keep them because the bottoms weren't scuffed, but long enough to no longer look brand new. I have never received a pair of shoes in this condition from Zappos before. I am returning them and hope this was just a fluke.

Good looking boot

Cute boot with good support Height was a little awkward on my short frame though

Not very comfortable. Color (grey) was not very nice. Made a weird pooch in the front. Not good for people with wide toes and slender heels.

Did not work for my feet. I have a slender foot but require a large toe box. These boots were too narrow in the medium and the wide was too wide. There is also too much room in the boot which made the front of it slouch and look weird. Style was just OK. They didn't seem that good of quality for the price. I returned and went with a pair of Taos boots instead.

I have a wide foot, but I found the wide extremely roomy - too roomy in fact. I couldn't get the shoe tight enough to feel supportive. It was cushy in a way that I wouldn't want a shoe to be, it was too soft. The grey leather was beautiful until it got scuffed. It didn't scuff in a worn vintage way, more like a wow that looks terrible way. I really wanted to love these shoes.

Love the style, unfortunately way too small.

The fit is great. I usually wear a 6.5, but my boots are always 7 to accommodate slightly thicker socks. These easily size up or down a little bit because of the laces. At first the arch was a tad uncomfortable, but I'm used it it. These boots could easily be worn 18 hours a day, every day, walking/standing/whatnot. I couldn't give them full stars because the color is not accurately represented on the website. The "wine" is more of a lighter redish pink than the awesome purplish red I wanted and which is pictured.

The wise does not feel like a wide shoe at all. Unfortunately I wasn’t able to keep them because of the narrow fit.

I have many boots in this style that I love. This leather, however, seems not to be of the same high quality. The leather gaps at the ankle when laced up, creating an unattractive bulge. The color is attractive, however, and the construction seems otherwise solid. I regret having to return them.

This is not for wide feet ~ it's for fat feet. This is a darling shoe, and very comfortable, but the toe box is narrow despite the fact that i ordered in in Wide. And the middle of the shoe buckles upwards in a weird way... then i figured out ~ this is for feet in which the whole foot is fat ~ not normal feet that are wide. Darn! I'm sure this will be comfortable for many women, but not those with true wide feet.

Cool boot, cool color- sand like. Yes very comfortable but not sturdy like a boot should be. Seemed cheap in construction despite the price. Had to return ð???

I give a 3 overall because after wearing these for only 6 months the sole is coming off the left boot. I was so excited to finally have a comfortable pair of everyday boots and now they're falling apart! So sad.

I hate to write a negative review for a shoe that is so nice-looking and obviously so popular, but I know I am helped by reading reviews, so I will leave one for others like me. I have bunions and the B width in this boot was uncomfortable for me. It was so uncomfortable, I couldn't even zip up the back of the shoe. The seam on the toe hits the bunion exactly where you don't want anything to hit, and it is tight. Loosening the laces doesn't affect the fit of the toe box. I even bought it a half-size bigger than my usual size. It's so cute and lightweight (and that zipper in the back is so handy) that if it came in a wide width, like the Cobb Hill Pandora bootie does, I'd buy it in every color! For now, I'll have to stick with getting the Pandora in multiple colors.

I thought these boots would offer good support for my problem feet. I was a loyal Merrelll customer but have been looking for alternatives since Merrell seems to have become more hit or miss in terms of consistency in sizing and support. These did not offer the support I was looking for. They are, however, very nice boots for the average person and I do wear them, switching off with my Dansko clogs because they are so stylish I get a lot of compliments on them from my 20 something co-workers. Love the red! But am still looking for the right boots for my problem feet.

I loved wearing these boots, and still do, but they have changed color drastically. When they arrived they were the deep olive color I ordered but after a few months of moderate wear they are now a full light brown. Since I already have a pair of brown ankle boots this is a bit disappointing. At least the green did not come off on my feet - it seems to have just faded away. They need to quality-control the leather dying process because these boots are too expensive to fail like this after such a short time. Really comfortable, though!

I've really liked these shoes and found them to be very comfortable. Unfortunately, in a little over a year, the sole has worn through leaving me with wet feet on rainy days! I took them to my shoe repair place but they sad they aren't able to replace the sole, which is too bad since the uppers of the shoe are fine. I expected more durability (or at least more potential for repair) given the cost.

These arebeautiful boots (that color!), but even the medium width is too narrow for me - and I have narrow feet. Low score for comfort so I hard to return them.