Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

Super cute!

Love these boots! Color and style are perfect. The metro guys in my office noticed them right away and had high praise for my fashion sense - win! They worked great on my wide, dancer/runner granny feet - a little too wide for the thin sock I wore first time out. So happy with this purchase.

I absolutely love these boots! I was looking for boots in this color without buckles and that wouldn't be too big in the calf. I hit the jackpot with these boots! I am going to order the black as well! For reference, my typical size 9 fit perfectly and even can accommodate my inserts for my high arches. My calf circumference is almost 14 inches and these fit well! I love the whiskey color and it feels so soft.

Perfect fit, so soft, so comfortable, so fabulous. Thank you!

Love these boots, I have them in 3 colors!!!

Love! I am usually a 7 1/2 and boots and I ordered these and a 7 1/2 and they fit perfectly

These riding boots the bottom part fit true to size, but the shaft was way too big. Really wanted them to work, Navy color perfect, price was a steal, leather was ready to wear, no break in time required. Sent them back.

My foot is a true 9.5 and these boots feel like they were custom made for me. The boot leather is very soft and the heel height is perfect - no back aches.

I have looking for a new great pair of classic go to black boots. Finally found these and love them. Put on and fit perfect..exceptionally comfortable and for a mid price boot they are amazing. I didn’t want to fork over the difference for Frye and so happy with these! Highly recommend!

Loved them. Very comfortable and didn’t need to be broken in.

I’ve had these boots now for over a year and they are fantastic. They’ve held up really well and look great with everything. I’m thinking of getting them in more colors.

Beautiful leather! I originally listened to the reviews and ordered a wide width and calf. Those were ridiculously huge so I returned them and ordered my usual 9M Regular Calf and love these boots!

These boots were a birthday gift for my wife. They fit great. Always kind of cautious about buying shoes on line without being able to try them on. Great fit.

I’m only 5 feet tall and it took some getting used to the shaft height of this boot. I typically wear a youth size 3 and they run a little shorter in the shaft. Once I modeled them for everyone who walked through my door, it was unanimous that I could pull off then taller shaft. Love them!

Sagged just a bit on the ankles but still looked beautiful!

The perfect size for me is 9M. But I wanted to put heavy socks on so I ordered 9 1/2 W to accomodate. Perfect fit & comfortable. Love the classic/simple styling too.

I love them but they do make my feet hurt if I stand for more than 1 hour

They are a perfect fit....but I ordered a 1/2 size longer to wear woolen socks, but I had to exchange for a wider foot too, to accommodate the heavier socks.

The boots are lovely leather, supple. They fit my calves with pants zipped in which is fantastic. Overall they were a bit too plain and not quite as red as I would have liked. Beautiful boots.

I finally found a boot that fit. I had to purchase the wide calf. Upon receiving these boots, I put them on and wore them around the house the rest of the day. They are so soft and comfortable.

Very comfortable first time I wore. Love the back zipper for ease of removing!

Super cute and comfortable. I get compliments on them every time I wear them!

I have been searching for a knee high boot for a while. This one is perfect. The shaft height is perfect and it is snug but not tight. The leather is soft and it is well made. I did not give comfort a 5 star is due to the odd shaping of the foot bed that takes a little to get use to. Still I would recommend the boot.

Great looking boots. They were a bit tight when first trying on but others have said once worn for a short time the leather stretches. It was no more than an hour and the tight feeling on the width of the boots then felt very comfortable.

Love these boots but 1/2 size too small Really wish I could have exchanged them