Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Penny Leather Riding Boots

I bought these for my trip to Paris over Thanksgiving and they were perfect! Comfortable and didn’t hurt my feet, even after walking an average of 10 miles a day, and were warm and stylish!

I am a petite 5’2” and wear a size 6 & have a narrow foot & high arch - these boots fit perfectly & are very comfortable

I own several pairs of Sam Edelman shoes and I know they typically run narrow. Still, I have a fairly narrow foot and it’s never been an issue before. Based on reviews I initially ordered a 7M in this boot (normally I wear a 6.5), but ended up exchanging for a 6.5W and found that to be the perfect fit. I wanted extra room for thicker socks if needed, and the 6.5W was the ticket. Great boot!

These boots look and feel great. However the calves were tight so I returned

Everything was perfect except I’m probably a 12 not 11 ½, I wish the calf girth were smaller, not as baggie, but beautiful boot I regret I’m returning :(

I have wanted boots like these for a while. I also ordered Sam Edelman Priscilla (size 8, black on both)and had a hard time choosing. The leather on the Penny boot seemed a little nicer so I went with that one. I’ve worn them 3 times already and love love love them! They are sleek stylish and comfortable (all day with lots of walking). I have several other Sam Edelman booties that I feel the same way about. That said I am going to order them in brown too! Thank you Zappos for making shopping and returns so seamless ??

I absolutely love these boots! I wear them almost every single day and my feet have not hurt, even once, in them. Super comfortable and soft leather. These boots stay up all day - you don’t have to keep pulling them up, like some boots. Have had tons of compliments. Most comfortable boot I have ever owned and super cute too. Grey is a little lighter than pictured but I still absolutely love them!

These boots are super cute and fit great! They were pretty snug at first to the point where I was worried I needed to size up but they were broken in within a day of wearing them and now they feel perfect! Definitely size up if you want to wear thicker socks though. I read a lot of reviews complaining that the whiskey color wasn’t exactly like the picture and was too orange, but I don’t feel that way, I actually like the color a lot! Definitely recommend these if you’re looking for cute, simple riding boots.

Great boot, just couldn’t find my fit. Nice craftsmanship, liked the back zip & quality leather tab. 8 was too big, 7.5 too small. ?????

I love these boots so much. They go with every outfit. It's so hard for me to find a boot with a wide toe box but not an overly wide ankle and shaft. I had to do a quick exchange because one of the buttons fell off the closure over the zipper. Hopefully, this is just a defective button and my new pair with last longer.

I’ve been drooling over these for so long and finally ordered them! 7W and they are too tight! Wah :( These really we’re not a true wide. But they are so pretty!

I really shopped around for a pair of tall brown boots. These Sam Edelman Penny Riding boots are absolutely perfect! A reasonable price for quality leather. The boots are the perfect shade of dark brown and the fit is perfect too. I have the short Sam booties so I ordered the same size in this boot and it's a perfect fit. The boots are very comfortable, arch support seems fine to me and they are sleek fitting without a lot of extra room like some tall boots have. My calves measure almost 14" and they zip up nice. Great boot!

True to fit and size. It rubbed against my right ankle the first couple times. I had been looking for navy boots and these were perfect at a reasonable price.

Great boot! I'm usually a size 8(M) but went with a 8.5(M) so I could wear thicker socks in the winter time and they fit great. I have smaller legs/calf muscles and have a hard time finding boots that aren't overbearing - these boots are perfect!

Get genuine leather. Boots do not scrunch like other boots I have owned in the past. Felt true to size and am able to wear regular socks with them. No blisters and complete comfort when wearing them all day. So many compliments!! Highly recommend!!

I have narrow feet & thin legs. Most boots l try on look like fishing waiters with my thin legs & calves. These boots fit me perfectly & the leather is so soft. Love these boots!!!

In love with these! The style is timeless and they combine with my favorite everyday looks, and can work with a bit more dressy outfits. I have somewhat thick legs and all knee high boots tend to bit a little bit tight around the calves. These are just right. The wides were too wide.

These boots are very comfortable but they have little arch support. The leather is butter soft and a perfect shade of navy. Great value!

Boots are exactly what I was looking for. The fit is perfect-I have a wide foot and shoes are hard to find that fit this well.

Beautiful boot to tight.

These boots are spot on! Exactly what I wanted. The fit is very true - I normally wear a 7.5 or an 8 and usually size up but didn't this time and glad I didn't. They are super comfortable and that zipper up the back is awesome. I do not have large calves so sometimes boots can look ridiculously big in that area but these don't. You get what you pay for and these are a great price for this boot. Get them!