Customer Reviews Trotters Paulina

I was so hoping that these shoes were the nude low heels I had been seeking. They were so uncomfortable in the toes! Need to be designed longer in the toe bed. It's not the point, but that they are not roomy enough down there.

Don't quite look the same in person, so a bit disappointed with the style. Needed some low heels for all day wear at work.

Very narrow and a short toe box. I ordered the wide size 7 but it was very uncomfortable. Looks good though.

I have the red patent of this style and I hardly wear them. They are not comfortable. I sure hate too because it's very difficult to find red pumps in a 12N. I bought these because I couldn't find a higher heeled one. I should've skipped it and waited.

I have this shoe in another color but same size. The black one is too small but the nude patent one fit. I find Trotters sizing to be a bit erratic across styles - and now apparently in the same style but different colors.

I ordered a 9.5 wide, which is my usual size. These shoes were way too small and not wide enough so I am returning them. Even if they had fit, I think the toe might have been too long and pointy for me.

Bought this shoe for a wedding I attended. I just needed a black pump with a low heel. Wore it once and the tip looks like the color rubbed off. I am very picky about my things that annoyed me!

Narrower than expected. I have bunions and sometimes the pointed toe shoes will work if the width allows. THis did not. Felt a size smaller but length was correct. Definitely not a EE. Nicely made and very pretty for the price. would have loved them had they fit.

The heel was too wide and I slipped right out of it; the toe box is too narrow (but for me that may be that I have not tried narrow toed shoes in a while.

I received a lot of compliments at work on this shoe. Purchased the nude color. They look very nice with slacks. The toe is fairly long in length which I was initially undecided about. Quality made shoe. However, not the most comfortable shoes after a long work day particularly with a bunion. I couldn't wait to get them off. I guess that is to be expected with heels. This would not be my everyday go to shoe but for occasional wear only. Size and width were fairly true to size at least for me with a bunion.

I have really wide feet - usually a 7 in wide, or 7.5 in narrower shoes. The 7 wide made me feel like Cinderella's step sister. Ordered the 7.5 WW and the things were slipping off my feet. Ordered the 7 WW and they are SO tight. There is such a difference in size. I love the look, but just could not get a pair that fit. :(

Very weird, I think the pair I got was defective. This size always fits, or is a little large. I ordered this and one size smaller (8WW) and the smaller ones fit great! This pair was too short and too narrow. I checked each shoe for the size - marked correctly.

Cheap. I ordered the black patent leather in 9M. The left foot felt great but the right foot was a bit tight across the pinky toe. They did not have as much padding under the ball of the foot as I expected. I walked halfway down the hall when I started to get the pins and needles feeling in my foot. I pulled the shoe off and looked more closely at it...I don't think there is anything that is sewn on this shoe... made in China and glued together; "Uppers: All Man-Made Material" !!! If these were leather like I thought I was purchasing, I would keep them as they would stretch... this was a waste of my time and Zappos' money! Back to the store they go!

I didn't care for this shoe. It felt too short, rubbing my toes and crowding my heels when I took a step. I would've tried a half size bigger, but I also didn't like the way they look on: the vamp (the part over the toes) comes up pretty high, which looks not stylish to me, especially in a pointy toe shoe. I have tried other Trotters that fit better, and appreciate their narrow widths and high quality, so I'll try again. (For reference, my feet are long (9.5) and narrow with high arches.)

These shoes really pinched my toes especially crushing my large toe. I normally wear a 9W and there was a ton of room in the heel when I wore the 9W. The toe was way too pointy, but if you like that sort of thing, then this shoe has a really pointy toe.

I have very hard to fit feet, and ordered two different sizes in double wide for a wedding. Didn't realize until I was packing them up to send back, that I'd been sent a pair containing two different sizes. No wonder they didn't work. For wide (bunion) feet, these shoes will also feel quite wide on the heels. Ultimately, had to haul out an old pair of shoes for the wedding but at least they fit.

Not really what I was hoping the shoe to be. It has a yellowish-brown cast to it, not really the nude neutral color I was hoping it to be. Plus the pointed toe made my feet look huge and squished my toes together, even though I ordered a wide width. The only plus for the shoe is that the heel is not too high.

Nice looking and true to size, but heels are too narrow and spindly, so the shoes are too wobbly for walking safely comfortably.

These are a really pretty pair of shoes. In my estimation, they are much pointier in the toe than they look. I'm a 9.5 and they fit me well but were just way too pointy for a big foot.

I had to return these shoes. I've never had an issue with a shoe being too tight - but this one was way too tight. Also, the red color has a lot of orange in it. Seems like a fairly nice shoe otherwise.

This shoe is cute with the right heel, however not the right width for me. I need the WW width. My feet has taken a new shape of its own, so I have to really search for shoes that is stylish and COMFORTABLE. I think the width is more medium than wide.

This was a pretty shoe - but ran small and was very stiff. I thought about exchanging shoe for 1/2 size larger but wasn't sure that would be big enough. I have a very high arch so maybe this is part of the size problem. I usually wear bootie type shoes but am in need of a pointed type dress shoe. Unfortunately these have to go back.

I had high hopes for these pumps, as I am always looking for stylish kitten heels. I have wide feet but narrow heels. I bought these in a 8½W, and 8½WW as well as a 9W. Sadly, I had to return all of them. The 9 was too long, so for me, they ran true to size (I am usually an 8½ but order up because of the pointy toe). The 8½W pinched my toes, but the 8½WW was too wide in the entire footbed/heel of the shoe. I was very disappointed, but these just did not work for me. I was really hoping that I could find a pointy kitten heel, but pointy just does not work for my wide feet. Also, for pointed shoes, the toe seems especially elongated. So, even if they did fit me, I think that I would feel a little self-conscious in these. If Trotters reads any of these reviews, I would love it if they made a round or at least an almond-toe kitten heel. The search continues... We need more kitten heels!

This shoe is perfect -- exactly what I wanted. I was surprised that Trotter has no arch support whatsoever, at least in a AA width. I need the narrow for my quad A heel, but really a B in the toe would have fit well. I considered a half size bigger, but it would have been too long. I hate to return this shoe, but I have to because I know it will never be comfortable or give me any support. Trotters puts a cushion in the heel, but not in the ball of the foot, which makes no sense even in a kitten heel like this beautiful doll of a red, red shoe! Goodbye, my lovely. I hate to see you go, but there is no way you are ever going to be comfortable or give me support. I highly recommend Soft Style by Hush Puppies "Alesia" if you have a narrow foot and a high arch.

These were lovely shoes that I had to return because the edge of the shoe was hitting a bone the wrong way on just my right foot (the small bone that is on the inner side of your foot, above the arch). These shoes also look really long! It is just the style with the long pointed toe area - but I wear size 5 shoes, so the look was not a problem. I liked the arch support and low heel, but the one area of discomfort on that bone was too much for me to try to get used to. It could just be me, since it was only on one foot and not both.