Customer Reviews Trotters Paulina

Beautiful shoe but so uncomfortable. I was nearly crying by the end of the day. They're just so tight. Zero comfort.

I found this shoe wider than most narrow width in the heel. It slips off. Next the toe box is very uncomfortable...I am very used to pointy toe stilettos, but this design had me limping. I bought this as a nice business shoe. I am going to see if I can return it. However, one redeeming point - the color is stunning...I would not recommend this shoe.

Very disappointing that I am a standard size 10.5N and was happy to see that rare size, but they stretched out and they are just too big to wear. I've tried lots of cushions and pads and still feel like a kid walking around in my mom's shoes. Too worn to return after many attempts at wearing them. Would be comfortable if they fit.

These shoes are very pretty, and a true red color, which I really wanted. However, they run small and were too short for my average 9.5. Order up!

I bought this based on other reviews but this shoe came in 7W box but no markings on the inside of the shoe and it is most definitely not a wide fitting because I bought a 7W as well and they both measure the same width! This shoe is hard and not something I would want to wear all day at all. After cramming my foot into the wide fitting (which isn't) the base of my toes were really tight in the shoe indicating no wiggle room at all in the shoe. It is also low on the heel making it hard to keep on the foot. Disappointed in this make as they were given such good reviews.

Didn’t like it.

I bought this couple of years ago for a meeting. I left it in my office forgot about it. I found it recently and wore it for about an hour. I noticed that the black lining on the inside had degraded and rubbed off on my toe nails turning it black. It was gummy and I could not wipe it off with the paper towel. Later at home, I had to use the nail polish remover to get it off. I am very disappointed since this happened on my second time wearing the shoes. While the Trotter shoes try to sell on comfort, it does not matter if it does not hold up. This one appears to have been made with inferior material.

I usually wear a size nine in Trotters pumps, however with this style, I could barely fit my foot into it. It really seemed more like a AA. Very nice style but cut much too narrow for a normal foot.

I usually love Trotters shoes, but these were not up to the quality I'm used to. Both shoes had some flaws, the heels were too wide, and the seam at the instep was glued, not stitched. Also, the nude color was a too yellow for my taste.

I ordered this shoe in an WW and it was way too narrow. An extra wide shoe with a point needs a more obtuse angle than a regular width shoe. This shoe does not offer a wide sole. This shoe is also not as attractive as it appears in the pictures. I am returning it.

Really disappointed! I really wanted these shoes. First try received my size, way too small in width...sent back and tried half size larger...still too narrow.

Not very good. I thought maybe the color appears yellow in the picture because of the lighting, but no, it is a distinct yellow-orange hue, not "nude" as advertised. The fit was way off, with a huge, unattractive gap between my foot and the topline and too much room in the heel seat. I'm not sure the narrow size would have helped since the front-end width actually fit pretty snugly. Overall the shoe felt too rigid and made my feet look big. I returned these and will continue searching for the perfect kitten heel in nude.