Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

Love them! Put suede protector on them right away. They need a little breaking in, they are more comfy with socks. Zipper is kinda uncomfortable on ankle without socks, but I think as I break them in it will get better. Love the style & quality.

These boots are fabulous! They are comfortable and the color is great. I get so many compliments on them. I ordered a second pair.

This a beautifully crafted short boot. The fit is wonderfully true. I have lots and lots of foot problems--including one foot that is fused in 4 places. So, coming across anything that is wonderful and I can actually get on my feet and then walk comfortably all day in, I joyfully celebrate. This boot ticks all my odd boxes and gets complements from others. One word of warning though, on the first try, these boots don't go on easily. But I don't give up easily--so after the first wear, that issue disappeared.

I LOVE these booties! I own them in another color as well. I ordered a size 7.5 and had to exchange them for a 7. They are so comfortable you can wear them all day out shopping the first time you put them on! My exchange process was seamless. Zappos offers the BEST exchange process ever and a special thanks to Joshua who was the customer service rep I spoke with!

Unbelievably comfortable! These boots fit perfectly. They arrived within to days after I ordered them.

I bought these almost a year ago and I am still wearing them. They look better with a little wear and tear. I get a ton of complements on them and they are great for all seasons.

I have plantar fasciitis and these are the best boots for it. The perfect height. I ordered my normal size (6.5) in wide and was planning on using the superfeet black insole but they accidentally sent the wrong size of insole. I ended up using an insole from an athletic shoe and these became the cushiest shoe I own. I'm so glad the other insole didn't work out! I used them without the insole once and they're comfy but not heavenly.

I have several colors in this boot and love them all. The navy suede is pretty but I find it to be to dark in combination with the black heel. When you put them on with navy or dark skinny jeans it just looks like a black boot. They are pretty boots if that is what you are looking for. I will be returning and looking for a boot with a lighter color heel in hopes that the color navy stands out more. FYI, I ordered my regular size and they fit fine with regular sock but would be a little tight if worn them with a bulky pair. But this boot is not really a bulky sock style of boot in my opinion.

A wardrobe must-have!! Beautiful, comfortable bootie that looks great with pants and skirts. The blue is gorgeous, too! I wore these booties while walking all around San Francisco for days- soon comfortable! I got lots of compliments, even from my husband who doesn't typically like low heels or booties with skirts.

Love these! I am on my feet most of the work day so was a bit nervous about wearing them all day but they were extremely comfortable! The heel size is perfect for comfort and style. The width was a bit tight at first but quickly loosened for a good fit. Going to get them in black next!

Beautiful boot, beautiful color to go with everything!! I bought these with no time to break them in for a trip to Knibbe Ranch in San Antonio. Was on my feet for two days running. These boots are now my best friends! Really great looking, and so sweet to my tender feet!! I absolutely love them!!

Love the boot. Looks really nice, heel just right - all day comfort! I have narrow feet, and these are perfect - orthotic in one fits just fine.

Great boot! Look great with everything. The picture looks like the boot is brown, put it says it's moss green. Trust what it says. It is definitely moss green. I love them. Have them in black too! I wish they actually had a brown one because I would get that one too.

A little narrow (could be because I have hobbit feet) but a well made shoe. Super comfortable and I get compliments every time I wear them. You won't be sorry you bought them!

These booties are so stylish and required no break in period. I love them!

This is the perfect ankle boot! I needed something that wouldn't cut my leg off at a weird spot and this bootie is perfect (I have athletic type legs). They felt a little tight across the top of my foot the first wear, but seemed to relax a bit with subsequent wears. This is a new staple in my wardrobe!

Classy boots. They're comfortable and look great with jeans. The soles are a bit hard, but if I put insoles in them, it makes the shoe too tight. Oh well, they are still keepers!

Bought the black suede and the heel/bottom section in wood is darker than the picture, but it looks SO much better! Super cute and comfortable, this will not be the only pair of the Petty I am purchasing. 10/10.

This is a great little boot in size and quality. I bought myself as well as my daughter a pair. They are true to size and comfortable.

I am loving these booties, and just trying to figure out how to justify buying two more pairs, in addition to the three I have already purchased. They were comfortable the first time I put them on, and have remained so. Doesn't matter if they are suede or leather. They just give me the little bit of extra height I need. Highly recommend them for fit, comfort, and affordability.

I saw these boots on Pinterest and thought they looked so stylish, I would give them a try even though ordering shoes isn't typically something I do. I bought mine last fall and found they fit my medium narrow, very thin, size 7½ feet well, but the real test is in how well they wear. Well, I hardly wear anything else when I go out. I have worn them shopping, to appointments and just around in my house without once feeling the need to take them off. Usually, I wear moccasins or go barefoot inside my home. But these shoes are so comfortable tat I wore them as I completed a task that involved going outside several times and doing some light cleaning. I bought the putty color which looks great with a boot cut jean or cords. I wore them this fall with a just above the knee dress and loved that look also. These boots were true to size, and they have moderate arch support. I am here to order them in black. My sister, who has seen me wearing them, texted me last night asking about the brand. I routinely get questions and compliments when I wear them so they are very flattering as well as wearable.I agree with others that the sole should be sturdier and offer more support, especially for the price.

I always avoid heels because I find them uncomfortable and I'm tall enough but I went ahead and tried these out since it is a low heel and I really did want to have something more fashionable. I have worn them all day at work with no problems. I'm very picky about my shoe comfort so I am happy to say they felt great after wearing them all day with plenty of walking. I would even feel comfortable taking them on vacation where walking all day was anticipated. I have the moss green color. It doesn't look that green online on my screen but they really are more green than brown in person.

Comfortable and fit true to size. Initially very slippery sole and I fell and twisted my ankle. Once I scraped the soles a bit on the concrete they are better though. I know I will wear these a lot. At first I was worried about people saying they are narrow, but I have wide toe area and these are fine. Not roomy in the toe area, but comfortable and probably will stretch a bit with wear.

These boots are really cute. Great material and color. They do run a little bit big, but I'm keeping mine anyways.

Amazing service! Ordered and delivered in two days - Christmas Eve in time to wrap and give!