Customer Reviews Sam Edelman Petty

I'm usually a 9.5-10, and I was a perfect 9 in these (good for the ego, I guess!). These shoes look and feel great -- I can walk around in them all day no problem. I noticed another reviewer said that they are pretty hard inside (not a lot of padding in there), and I can understand that. If I have cushy socks I don't notice it. Tempted to buy in a couple more colors! Great closet staple.

These are beautiful boots!! They definitely run a little narrow, but I would stick with your normal size, as you can get them worn in pretty quickly. They do carry them in "wide", but I wouldn't recommend going that route unless you truly have a wide foot.

I LOVE THESE BOOTIES! They wear well right out of the box! I was looking for an alternative to my high heel booties & needed a lower heel with style (and a little lift!). I ordered my true size & was very pleased that they fit well. They work well with my ankle jeans, leggings, and dress & tights! I chose black, because it's my go to and classic.

I love these shoes! They are so cute and were extremely comfortable from the first moment I put them on. I wear them to work, but they can also be dressed down with jeans.

Stylish and great quality. Returning because I have very short legs and they come up a little too high on me. I'm 5 ft. However they are very low compared to most boots and are probably come up low enough for most

These booties are so cute and a go-to fall/winter staple. I have wide feet and a high arch/instep so it is often difficult to find comfortable shoes that are also stylish. I gave these a 4 for comfort because I definitely felt a lack of support/padding on the balls of my feet in particular, and rubbing on the sides of my ankles. I have only worn them twice and believe they will break in nicely, so these are keepers!

I like these short boots but they don't fit well.

I've had the same pair but in black for about 2 years and absolutely love them, so I had to get brown this time. They definitely break in and are so comfy!!

Great bootie. I wear a 6M and that size fits perfectly. The heel was a bit higher than I wanted so am keeping the Nine West that I ordered which has a lower heel and a toe that is a little bit more pointed. I am ordering this bootie in black calf though!

These were so tight at first, but they stretched! I ordered my usual 8 and was so bummed when I got them because they felt so tight and narrow around the ball of my foot and toes. I panicked and ordered an 8.5 to compare (since Zappo's return policy is fantastic and easy). So glad I kept the 8 because my foot was falling out of the back of 8.5 when I walked. I wore the 8s around my apartment a few times they felt so much better. And after a few hours at work they feel GREAT! Don't be discouraged by the narrow-ness!

This shoes is very comfortable and stylish. I rarely can find a leather booties with low ankle coverage. this is one is satisfying, because shorter at ankle, showing more leggs. And it is so comfortable. I bought a second pair because I worry this shoes will run out of stock not be produced again.

So far, I am loving these shoes. I have fairly wide feet, and found the size wide were still a little narrow on my right (larger) foot. Otherwise, a great pair of boots!

These shoes are very cute, verstatile, and very comfortable. I have an odd size foot--true size is probably 5.5 wide, but that's an impossible size to find so I usually wear a 6M which always feels too narrow to me. I purchased this shoe in a 6W and it is so incredibly comfortable--this is what shoes are supposed to feel like! It's a little loose in the heel, but that's fine because it's a boot so I'm in no danger of slipping out of it. And it doesn't have a lot of cushion, but no shoe is perfect. I'll take a hard sole over pinched toes any day. The shoe looks great with dresses, leggings, ankle jeans, etc... You can dress it up or down. It is high quality leather. I'm planning to go back and get a pair in another color!

So cute, so comfortable, and I love the shearling. (I bought the black slick suede/shearling). I am loving them!

Love these booties! The fit and heel height are perfect. Highly recommend.

I've been eyeing these for a long time and finally went for it. I absolutely love them. Great for work, play, winter, and they look awesome with skinny pants. I think they run a little long, though. I ordered a 6.5W, as that's my usual size — but I ended up getting a 6W. They were a tiny bit snugger, but I'd prefer that over tripping constantly.

Loved the look of this boot but unfortunately, it was too narrow

Best little bootie ever! I now have them in 3 color! Get them!

Nice boot, but narrow and I don't have wide feet. Also, fairly wide at the ankle, but I have really bony ankles so that may not be a problem for others!

Very happy with my purchase

Love!

LOVE these! gorgeous-beautiful workmanship and dare i say it: comfy! wore for fall pix today and they were perfect and will be a staple in my wardrobe for a long time! 5 stars!

I am in love with these booties!!! The leather is beautiful and so soft- they were super comfortable right out of the box, and just keep getting softer! I am 5'10", so it's difficult for me to find a stylish boogie with a lower heel. But these are the exception. My favorite fall staple, hands down!

These booties are super cute and fairly comfy. I'm considering an insole, but the longer I wear them, the better they get. They go with any outfit and the leather is very high quality. My only complaint is that I should have gone with the smaller size. I'm typically a 7 or 7.5 and while the 7.5 feels ok right now, I'm afraid they'll stretch out over time. I do like my shoes to fit snugly, though, so that may also be part of the issue. Overall, these are super stylish, comfy booties that I would highly recommend.