Customer Reviews Jack Rogers Jacks Flat Sandal

I'm on my 3rd pair of Jack Rogers - I LIVE in Jack Rogers in the summer, and I wore out my first 2 pairs. They are slightly narrow, and they take a couple days to break in. I'd been wearing these in a half size larger than my normal size (an 8) but mistakenly ordered my correct size. I could hardly get them on because the leather was SO tight, I thought I was going to have to exchange them for a half size up, but then I remembered how much my old pairs stretched. I kept the 8's and am glad I did - the leather stretches a LOT and really loosens up. I know the heels can hurt a bit at first but once you break them in, it's so worth it.

These were painful to wear in the beginning. Blisters galore. They are very narrow and tight along the toes and middle of the foot. Overall, the style is cute and goes well with any spring/summer outfits. I got them in platinum which is a very neutral color.

The sandals go with everything and definitely look nicer than flip flops. They're not meant for walking long distances (only the heel has padding), but they're well made and I'd love them in another color!

If you live in a place where you walk a LOT (I live in Manhattan) -- these are not practical, unfortunately. I saw the 5 star reviews and couldn't wait to order a pair, and while they are comfortable in short distances or when I'm stationary...walking more than several blocks on concrete, up and down subway stairs--these are just not comfortable, they're heavy and clunky. I still wear them at least once a week, but city-dwellers--take this into consideration.

I wanted to love these sandals, and really like the look, but the truth is that the sizing seems off. They seemed to run both small and narrow, and after trying a larger size, they didn't fit perfectly either. Back they went.

Almost can't wait for it to be summer just so I can wear these again. :) Very preppy chic. They go with everything. I always wear between a 6 and a 7. I originally ordered a 6.5. These run a small and unfortunately, I had to exchange them for a 7 but Zappos is always makes this part so easy. Surprised that with the 7 my heels are still dangerously close to the back edge of the sandal, but I trust that as I continue to wear them in and the front of the sandal loosens it will be an even better fit.

If you plan on buying these -- which you still should because where I come from they are a summer staple -- you need to know a few things. It took me a year to fully break mine in. This included a variety of times when I wore them. At first, I wore them around the house, to my graduation, out to dinner, etc. These were all for short time periods and during which they weren't broken in. I truly broke them in when I started wearing them all day to school - a solid 7 hour time period. More than once I walked home from school which is 2 miles. This is when I really broke them in. Because of all the time I made myself spend in them, gradually working my hours up, they are now thoroughly comfortable. The bottoms used to be slippery and I'd slide around on carpet, but now if you look at the bottom you can see my big toe and they are thoroughly scuffed -- no more sliding! When you look at the top of my shoe, you can see my foot is molded into it and this area is darker. Now I wear them with a breeze, just know that breaking them in takes a while. But you should know that in the breaking in process I never got a blister, but after those walks home my feet did hurt a lot and I sat on the couch the rest of the day doing homework...but who ever said beauty is painless?!

Cute style for my daughter. Match with almost everything. Silver lining over the heel area came loose within two weeks and needed to be glued back down. Interestingly these are less comfortable than the knock-offs she has which have a slightly padded sole. But these shoes are what everyone else has, so she is happy with them.

I love these shoes. Don't get me wrong - they're a classic, and they look gorgeous. But they're not the most comfortable shoes. They have no arch support and can be pretty uncomfortable if you wear them all day. They also stretch out quite a bit. I'm a true 7.5 and the shoes are now way too loose - wish I had gotten a half size down instead!

I have narrow feet and typically wear a 9 (9.5 in designer). However, the 9s in these were about half an inch too long. The 8.5 was perfect though. I can imagine that for someone with average or wide feet that these would take some breaking in but for me they were just fine and the three dots on the heel do not bother me at all.

I really like these sandals. I am still working on the comfort level. They are taking a while to wear in, but I think that they will hold up much better than other sandals. The Platinum goes with everything and as they get more worn in, they get more comfortable. This is not to best show to walk around in all day, but they are doable to wear all day at work. I am not on my feet all day, but up and down throughout.

They are nice to look at, but not quite wide enough at the toe for me, and the toe post was very uncomfortable - way too thick. I have been anxiously waiting to get this shoe, and am extremely disappointed that they obviously won't work for me, in any size.

the color is NOT a high gloss gold, but more like a muted brushed gold. BIG difference from photo, whereas same shoe in SILVER is the high gloss bright silver the photo shows.

I returned these.

These sandals are even prettier in person! However, even in a Narrow width, I had an inch between the top of my foot and the main strap. It didn't look good and it was difficult to keep on.