Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

They take a while to break in, and I bought them a little small, but I LOVE these shoes!

Cute shoes, true to size. However, the back elastic part is really tight on your achilles tendon :o(

I have this shoe in a different color and like them. Emmie doesn't offer much in the way of arch support, but they're still a comfy, inexpensive basic ballet flat! I wanted a more "nude" shoe, so I ordered the Tuscany. Boy, did this color suck. It's much darker than camel or nude. It's more reddish than pink and way too dark for my fair skin. I'm returning it.

Cute, basic ballet flat. I bought basic black. They smell and feel like pretty good leather. I usually wear a 6.5 or a 7; I went with the 6.5 here, and it fits, but I wish I had gone with the 7 so I could stick an insert in. There's not much between your foot and the ground. But the little bit of stretch in the fit is nice, as it took all of about an hour to break them in.

These shoes are so cute and comfy, and the color is a perfect Fall red. They are comfortable in the fit; however, because of the lack of arch support, these shoes aren't practical for a lot of walking on the street like I wish they were.

This shoe is a perfect dupe of the Tory Burch Eddie for about 1/3 the price. No one will know that this is an imitation unless you tell them. For me it fits really well (I normally wear a 9.5, ordered a 9.5, no problems). Since the whole point of these shoes is the very soft leather, it's painful to bring home the Torys knowing they are going to take a beating when you wear them on the street. This is a much saner price for a shoe that looks exactly the same. (I bought the nude color, which I believe is called "Sweet Autumn" in the Emmie.) It doesn't feel exactly the same on the inside. I think the insole is synthetic and it does make your feet hot. Also, the Eddie has cushy padding underfoot and the Emmie seems to have less of that. Still, if what you are after is a comfy flat that perfectly recreates the pretty simplicity of the Eddie at a lower price, this is your shoe. I plan to buy a few more pairs in different colors.

I love these shoes, they are exactly what I was looking for! One warning though, the back heal did cut into my foot. I wore them around the house with band aids for a week or so until they stretched. Now they are fine.

I see why so many ballerina slippers have decoration on the toe. It may hide the shape of the toe under the tip. This shoe is comfortable, though, and durable. It's not particularly dressy though so I often commute in them to work and slip on something more substantial once I get there. These are great for jeans so long as they aren't too long. Over all a great value and I use them often. I bought a half size larger than normal bc of other reviews and they fit perfectly.

They're cute, the color is nice and matches a ton of things. Not extremely comfortable because there isn't much cushion in the bottom, but true to size and not bad as far as flats go. Didn't rub at all on the back or sides. I'm keeping them and they serve my needs!

Finally, a basic flat that does not give me blisters! I love that they're soft at the back so they do not rub on my heel. Only problem is that is has that weird elastic back which pushes your foot forward so I had to go with a half size up to compensate. There ends up being extra room in the bottom of the heel which is odd but a trade off for comfort I guess. I knocked a star off because there is zero support so I had to buy a cheap insert which made a huge difference. But why not just add some extra padding in the shoe? Overall I'm happy with them.

Slightly smaller than thought, so watch those toes. Feels broken in, but in a good way and comfy.

This review is solely based on my flat feet. This is not a very flattering shoe if you have wide, flat fit.

Elegant fabric (I got the "jeans" color that looks like a Chanel suit bouclé) but the shoe was uncomfortable from the first minute I slipped a foot in it. The elastic at the toe box digs at the base of my big toe articulation (not a bunion per se, but could become one with poorly conceived shoes like that). No comfortable sole either, or arch support or supple inner lining.

The leather and construction was nice, but these shoes have zero support or heel. Not what I wanted.

I have these shoes in black, but these brown ones were quite a bit smaller. I returned them. I really like my black ones though!

Beautiful color. Very soft. Half size too small.

I feel a little like Cinderella's sisters, trying to get these shoes to fit my feet. I originally ordered a 1/2 size larger in a 7/1/2 wide and returned them because they were too short. Because I really liked the color and style, I ordered another pair in a size 8 wide hoping it would fit better, but the toe box of the shoe is so tight it makes my toes ache. I am SO disappointed that In have to return them again but very thankful for Zappos' return policy. I really want to find a pair in the same color that fits.

They fit okay but they were so “flimsy” in the toes, so I returned. The leather wrinkled badly at the toes, making them look worn out already.

These ripped up the back of my heel in less than 10 minutes! Had to put band aids on to help with the digging into the back of your heel. I haven't worn them since :( They are super cute but I need to find a way to break the back of the shoe in without getting blisters.

Super basic flats. They served their purpose, but were nothing to get too excited about. they weren't that comfortable for the price. They looked fine with jeans or something super casual, but look pretty sloppy with any sort of dress.

One shoe was not sewn correctly. The seam on the back was way off center and something in it was poking into the back of my ankle. Otherwise, they were as expected. I think this style of shoe needs some soft padding at the back of the ankle. Even the shoe that wasn't defective felt like it might rub my Achilles heel too much.

This shoe was a 10 and I always wear a 10 but this shoe feels like a size smaller. I thought they would stretch out a bit but they haven't. I really wish I wouldve returned them for an 11 as I barely wear them now :(

They are not high quality and no support, but they were so cute! I'd wear them anyway, except they were too small.

So, full disclosure: I’m a size 8 naturally. When I first purchased these, I bought a size 8M, and they fit more like a 7. So I purchased an 8 1/2, but I accidentally ordered a Wide. Needless to say, my foot was swimming when I tried them on, and they went back with the too tight pair. I just ordered #3, hoping for my Goldilocks moment ??