Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

Wanted so badly for these to work. Alas- the 10 is tiny, probably closer to a full size smaller than a half- but they don’t make 10.5 and I know the 11 will be too big. *sigh* Wish shoe makers would care that big-footed ladies still need shoes that fit and we don’t magically grow one size bigger. Anyway, color is great but they run small.

While the leather is gorgeous and supple, the shoe is at least one size too small. I am a size 8, occasionally a 7 1/2 depending on the shoe. The size 8 that I purchased felt more like a size 7. Believe the hype: go up at least a half a size, if not a full one! I should’ve listened to the reviews. My bad. Gotta send these back as soon as possible.

Quite small, and no half size options over size 10. Very cute but I don’t think they would stretch enough. I’m usually a 9.5-10 and the 10 was really small on me, so order at least a half size up. Pretty sure the 11s would be too big, so these are going back without a reorder. I’m sad, because I like the style and colors (I ordered green and mauve), and the footbed was more cushioned than I expected. There were a couple of spots that would have needed bandaids until they were broken in, but I don’t expect miracles out of the box.

I did not like how snug the shoes were and due to the material uncomfortable.

This was so tight that I could barely get my foot in it. I don't have a wide foot, but this still felt a size too small and super tight on my foot. Had to send back, which is sad because it's so cute.

The 8M is too tight so I tried a 8W. But this was too big. Returning it sadly as I like the style.

Really cute, but the toe box is squishy and smashed my toes. It's the kind of shoe that pulls up at the toe so unless your feet are super skinny (or skinnier than mine), and you barely wear the size you ordered, they don't fit well. Ordered an 11, measure a 10.5.

I wanted to love these...ordered a 7 awhile back, and just traded them for a 7.5. I have rather narrow feet but still feel not enough room in toe box, while there seems to be an extra puckering around heel, and it digs into upper heal. Plain uncomfortable when walking. Love Lucky Brand, bummed these don't work for me, but alas they are going back.

I was slightly bummed when I got these shoes. The color was great (shimmery nude), but the leather was so soft that my big toe made this asymmetrical line across the front of the flat. Also, they were too wide for my somewhat narrow feet. I wish they had worked out but thanks, Zappos, for the good return policy, I will keep looking.

Loved the look of this shoe, I was so excited to get it. The fit was perfect and the leather was soft, but the heel placement was awkward and uncomfortable. I gave it a few days walking around the house but the heel placement was more irritating on harder surfaces. I decided I need a shoe I can walk around town in so I had to send them back.

I love the look of these and wear them out, but they dig into my heel and they feel hard. There is no padding in the sole.

These shoes are cute but I am returning them for the following reasons: 1. Back of heel rubs my skin. 2. No support. Very flat and hard. 3. Shoe is thin around toes, so you can see the imprint of your toe knuckles under the leather and to me it looks funny.

I've had these for a couple of months and while they look cute, they're still rather uncomfortable. They pinch in the back and in the toe and now it looks like part of the metallic sheen is wearing down to the black leather (or whatever it is) underneath. This only happens where my big toes contact the shoe and I'm worried it's going to get worse as time goes on. I like these shoes and will continue to wear them but the quality and lifespan could be a lot better.

Great look and well made. Unfortunately they di not run true to size. You need at least a half size bigger or they will pinch you across the top.

For a quick slip-on, this shoe works. However, even though I have narrow feet, high arches, and fall a bit under a size 10, this shoe is tight. Tight enough that I can't even wear little footies underneath. The black leather looks very nice, but when you flip over the shoe, you'll see the heel is actually a perfectly circular disc with the Lucky symbol on it. It almost looks as if you stepped on a black disc that got stuck to your sole. I wear mine with jeans for minimal errand-running; after hours at a Chuck E. Cheese birthday party yesterday (bad enough already), my feet were killing, especially over the nails on my big toes. An okay purchase for minimal wear. Look good, feel somewhat bad.

I love these flats however they are the most uncomfortable flats that I wear. I stay soar for days after wearing them. They squeeze your Achilles tendon terribly. I was hoping that this pair would be different, but they are the same. I am going to try the Emmie 2, as they look to have more support in that exact area with actual backing.

I bought these in red. They are very cute and stylish if not the most comfortable shoes in the world. I have wide feet, so I went up half a size, and they barely fit. They were tight out of the box but have stretched with wear. The heel does feel strange and a bit uncomfortable, and the sole is completely flat. I wouldn't wear these on a day when I had to do a lot of walking, but sitting around the office and work is fine.

I really wanted these to work -- they are cute, highly reviewed and moderately priced -- but they didn't. I wear a 5.5 or 6 and I ordered a 5.5 in these shoes based on other reviews. The sizing was fine and my toes weren't cramped, but the fit was uncomfortable. I ordered the black and the rose cream. The rose cream fit the best out of the two pairs and the color is neat -- it really resembles a ballet shoe. The black color fit a little tighter but was not too small. The two main problems were the way the back of the shoe chafed and put pressure on my heel, and the way the bottom of the heel felt. The bottom of the heel on the sole is a round disc which felt odd on the bottom of my foot. The back of the shoe applied so much pressure to my Achilles area that just during the short time I was trying them out and walking around inside they left a red mark. Maybe they would break in nicely but I'm just not up for days of blisters and abraded heels. They are going back.

I had to return these shoes. The instep side of the shoe looked weirdly big on one shoe when it was on my foot. It has no arch support, and since I am on my feet all day, it wouldn't work. I also noticed a lot of these shoes at a discount designer brand store which makes me think they aren't as popular as it would seem.

I wanted to love (even like) these so bad - I mean 98 reviews and 5 perfect stars. Why wouldn't I love them, right? Well, sadly, I just couldn't get the feel for the heel on the back. I walked around my house and it just bothered me horribly. I read several reviews and no one mentioned it, so it might just be me, but it was really uncomfortable. I also recommend you order a size up, as I normally wear a 10 and had to get an 11 - wish they came in halves, but I still wouldn't have liked the heel.

To me, this shoe felt a bit small, maybe because of the elastic. This is my first pair of flats with elastic, and there's a bit of getting used to having no arch support and having such an unsupported heel. I can't walk too long in these since the heel isn't large enough to cover the heel of my foot. Other than that, it looks good and is comfortable for short periods of time.

They’re cute but I'm still trying to figure out if they can be comfortable. To stay on the back elastic on the ankle is a little tight and the shoe is also rubbing on the top part of my big toe. I'm hoping after a few more wears that it will pass as other than that. The leather is soft and everything else is quite comfortable. I have very thin, narrow feet.

These just didn't work for me. I'm looking for comfortable shoe for a weekend trip to NY where I planned to do a lot of walking. These have no support at all.

The body of the shoe is really comfortable, but the circle on the heel is a big problem. I kept them because I only noticed the heel after walking in them for awhile and the heel became unbearable. The next day I had a huge blister on the bottom of my heel. The leather material is very nice, though it's a camel colored brown, not the nude pictured. Overall a nice basic flat if the heel doesn't bother you. I like them, but can't wear them for long before the heel starts to hurt.

This shoe is very narrow, my daughter has only worn it once and now we are stuck with a shoe that she can't enjoy.