Customer Reviews Lucky Brand Emmie

Yuck! These looked horrible on my feet. They looked cheap and just were not flattering at all. But they were comfy.

I like the way these fit and they're cute. I needed a pair of flats in a hurry for the weekend otherwise I would have returned them. The material is cheap. They're already scratched in a couple of places and I've only worn them for a week. I probably could have done as well at Payless and spent way less money.

There was nothing I liked about these shoes. They were huge and the leather did not look or feel real. It was stiff and hard and had a weird pattern in it. They are headed back and I will keep looking for a pair of navy ballet flats.

This is a cute shoe, but it is really uncomfortable. I can usually tough out the break in period, but my ankles were bleeding even through socks. The material at the heel has almost no give and the seam has been placed in just the wrong way. I have a similar pair from the same brand in cloth that are the most comfortable shoes I own. These do not come close!

I ordered the Emmie in black and the rose gold color about a year ago. When I got them out of the box one of the rose gold shoes was wrinkled looking - whereas the other was not. I should've sent them back for another pair but I liked them so much I wanted to wear them right away. I wish I would've exchanged them though because soon after wearing them, the "wrinkled" looking one started to peel away its finish. So disappointed.

I bought these flats based on the other reviews. I bought my size, the half size up was too big. My toes are slightly crushed. I thought they may have stretched out a little, they did not. The circular heel is very uncomfotable when wearing them for more than 4 hours. My feet absolutley hurt. I woudl not recomend these for anyone who stands for more than 5 hour work days. Very disappointed.

I returned these right after getting them. I got the rose cream color and it was just odd, kind of like a shiny skin tone. The shoe was way more casual than I expected and the leather was creased in some areas. In wearing them, I was overly aware of the heel support and it felt like I had something stuck on the bottom of my shoe. I bought them because of the reviews, but returned them very disappointed.

Really uncomfortable. The round shape of the heel is the problem. My heel weight lies 3/4 on and 1/4 off that round part of the sole. Digs into my heel in every step. Too bad... the leather is soft and shoe is a bit wide already so I would think it wouldn't look stretched out after wearing like other flats do.

I am an eternal optimist, and when I read the reviews I always think, "How bad could they be?" The answer for these ballet flats: Bad. They're the most uncomfortable shoes I've ever owned. The little flat plastic heel rubs and causes blisters on the bottom of my feet; the tops are cut just so they rub on the top bones of my feet when I walk and cause blisters there too. They're not even cute enough to put up with the pain. I threw them into the closet and never want to see them again.

I bought these last year, a 1/2 size up from my normal size... they were on super-sale at a local store so I could not return them. Red flag. I bought a size 9 and still, almost a year later, they continue to hurt my feet. My toes feel cramped and the elastic on the ankle leaves indentations. I cringe when I think of wearing them. Since I couldn't return them, I do still wear them but they are not comfortable.

These shoes are super cute, but are definitely not worth the price. The heel pads are placed way too far back on the shoe, and so your heel falls off uncomfortably. Also, I have two friends who also have this shoe, and we all noted that one of the pair would cut painfully into the back of your foot, as if they weren't made quite the same size. These are DEFINITELY going back.

I really wanted to like these flats. I'm not sure who decided the curved UP ballet flats were a good idea. I unwrapped my box and home and was wary when I saw the curved up. I put them on and of course were already digging into my Achilles heel. I sadly put them back in the box and shipped them back because I wasn't going to put my feet through that.

The picture looks great...nice stripes...the shoe unfortunately has gold threading striped in and looks cheap.

This is a high quality flat; it doesn't seem like it will fall apart after 6 months of wear, like so many other flats. The leather is sturdy but soft; the elastic well-enclosed and doesn't seem like it will fray. However, the sole of the shoe has a major design flaw that makes it uncomfortable to walk in: the shoe isn't completely flat on the bottom, it actually has a short heel (maybe 1/4" tall). This is only a problem because this heel is not large enough, meaning, it needs to be wider and longer to accommodate the striking surface of the stride. The elastic of the hem pushes your foot farther forward in the shoe, so you end up with the center of your heel on the edge of this weird circular heel of the shoe; because the sole of the shoe is thin and soft, the consequence is that you feel the edge of this heel hitting right in the middle of the heel of your foot, like you're stepping on a ridge. I agree with other reviewers that the shoe runs small; I attribute this to the elastic edge pushing your foot forward into the shoe so that you feel your toes up against the shoe; I had plenty of room in the heel of the shoe, so you might call this another design flaw: the elastic is too strong so it shoves your foot forward. In spite of the fact that I like the style and the structure of the shoe (5 Stars for Style), I have only worn them once because this heel problem was awkward and uncomfortable. I'm going to see whether Zappos will take them back, even though I have worn them outside once.

Looked okay, and seem like they would be comfortable, after going 1/2 size up. However, after less than a day of wear, they caused a pain in the heel. This might have been caused by the odd small round heel. Or perhaps by the very thin sole. Or maybe both.

Although the shoes are attractive, I am returning them. They cut into the upper part of my foot. also, my foot is forced forward due to either the design or the lack of support. I found them uncomfortable, although stylish. I pick comfort over style.

Yikes, these shoes arrived today and they are flat and flimsy with zero support. They feel like slippers and I'd be afraid to get them wet for fear they would fall apart. I don't get how they got five stars. Really? I got them in gray and the color is darker than it looked on my computer screen. In my opinion, spend a little more and go for the Merrells. These were not good for me. Back they go!

Not anywhere near as cute as their picture; no arch support whatsoever, but I expected that; despite the elastic, they feel sloppy and wide, yet not long enough; they also feel weirdly stiff and were jabbing my feet in odd places, such as my arch. Don't waste your time with these.

These shoes are horrible for your gait. The heel is completely impractical. It has turned me off to the brand. They were cute, but a bad fit and not healthy.

I actually am returning these. They are cute, but way too tight. They really squeezed the back of my heel to the point of pain. I ordered a 7.5, and I usually fluctuate between an 8 - 7.5. So if you are considering these, go a size higher than usual.

I had really high hopes for this shoes based on all of the positive reviews it has received. The shoe was cute, and felt comfortable until I walked in it. I normally wear a Size 8 and these felt like the right length, but when walking the heel on the base of the shoe only covered the rear portion of my heel. The result was very uncomfortable and I am returning the shoe.

These shoes were really comfortable but I thought they looked a lot different than they appeared online. I ordered the rose cream color and when they arrived I noticed they were more rosey than I expected and very shimmery... they shimmery look wasn't what I wanted so I returned them. But I had great customer service! I still love Zappos!

Super comfortable but only in the short term! These are not, let me repeat, NOT running around on your feet for ten hours shoes. There is absolutely no arch support and the base of the shoe is super thin. I know they're styled as a ballet flat, but they essentially really ARE ballet flats, which certainly aren't mean to be worn on city streets for ten hour stretches. Definitely super cute, but I would never repurchase.

Not at all worth the cost. Size runs a tad small and you have to break them in before the elastic at the heel stops digging into the back of your foot. Problem is by the time you've worn them in, you've also worn them down. Scrapes easily from walking outdoors. They do look great and are comfortable, if you are buying them for light wear / indoor wear...good buy. If you plan to actually walk - not the right pair.