Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

This particular shoe did not "fit like a glove," that my prior experience with Keen shoes has been; they flopped around on my feet, including the heel, even though I was wearing the same thin hosiery that I usually wear with my other Keen shoes, and the same size, 8 Medium. The style was the same, also, a Mary Jane type shoe I was planning to wear as a work shoe, due to foot problems.

I tried these on in a store, but the heel seemed loose so I didn't purchase them. Then I decided to try again and this time ordered from Zappos. The length is my usual 8.5 size. They are a bit loose in the heel. I have the strap hooked as tight as possible. I have been wearing these shoes for walking for the last three days. They are very comfortable, but the best is the wonderful arch support that they provide. I love the black olive color. I am happy that I bought these.

I love these shoes! I have now ordered them in 2 other colors. I have back problems and carry too much weight. These shoes are providing excellent support. No knee, ankle or other joint pain.

These are the most comfortable shoes ever! They are hard to take off they feel so great! I ordered my true size and they fit perfectly with a small adjustment to the strap. They slip on without having to unbuckle due to stretch in the strap which is a bonus for me. I love the madder brown which is a rich reddish brown. I will wear with pants most of the time but they would look cute with the right skirt. Thank you Zappos for such great service!

I have three pairs of Keens in my closet from years ago. I love them because they last forever and fit true to size. I don't know what has happened at Keen. This year I have made several attempts to order various styles of Keen shoes and the sizing is inconsistent. If the shoe fits in length, the toe box is too small. If the shoe is too long, the toe box is just right. I'm sad to say that I cannot order Keen online anymore.

These Keens are extremely comfortable. They look nice with work casual or jeans. I got them in brown and black because they really provide a lot of support and I'm on my feet all day. They fit like all keens so I order them slightly larger.

Super comfortable, able to walk in them long distances without pain. I have a history of foot pain, have no arches and very wide feet. Some Keens work for me and some don't, but these definitely do. Only slight annoyance with them is they had a very strong leather smell for months and months, more so than usual with leather shoes, but that's no big deal.

I stand and walk constantly during work, and the soles of my feet ache by the end of the day without truly an excellent shoe. These shoes, however, are the answer to that malady -- the very best I have found for a lot of standing among the many styles and brands I've tried. If you stand during work, do consider buying this style. They were certainly worth every penny I spent on them.

I really like these shoes in every respect except the foot bed which is nothing short of flimsy. I recently purchased from a replacement footbed by Smart Foot. What a difference these made to my Keens! I very pleased with the resulting comfort.

i love Keen. Nothing beats them when you get a good fit. Beware of what size you order, though. Sometimes I am a Keen size 8 and sometimes a size 9. I bought a size 9 pair of Toyah MJs and the shoes slipped on my heels with my thickest socks on. But the Keen Howser is a tight size 9. I suggest you read reviews like this to find out how the pair of Keen you want are sized.

I cannot say enough times how much I LOVE THESE SHOES! I own them in both black and green, and am thinking of purchasing them in the grey/gargoyle color, too. I have been wearing Keens for years and have tried different styles. I usually wear an 11 in Keen and that is what I wear in the Keen MJ Toyah. It is plenty wide and I wear one of the two pairs of this shoe almost every day! I slip my feet in without unbuckling (I know it’s a bad habit!) and they have still maintained their support and structure. Prior to this Keen, my favorite for comfort was the Presidio, but this Toyah MJ is my new fav!

I requested the Keen Toyah MJ in black for Christmas. I read a few reviews about the shoe running large. I normally wear a 9 so I asked for an 8 and they were way too small. It was only after this that I read one review that said to disregard the reviews that said to order down a size. So we returned the shoes to Zappos and had to order them via another online store since my size and color combination were sold out on Zappos. Now I have my size 9 and absolutely love them. They fit great with my wool socks that have moderate cushioning. The toe box is roomy which is good because I was having problems with rubbing in other shoes. I will definitely buy these shoes in another color.

Extremely comfortable. Cushy for walking and standing around on hard floors. Not ugly; just a bit clumpy. Pretty color; goes with everything.

These are great shoes! I particularly like that they are water-proof and the inserts are removable so that I can put in my own. The shoes feel solid and secure and had no breaking-in period.

These are great shoes...they run a little large (for me) but as long as I tighten the strap, they are fine. Very comfortable shoe for being on your feet all day.

These shoes are great. They are very comfortable, just the right thing when a sandal isn't enough and a fully closed shoe is too much. There was no break-in time needed. I did have issues with the infamous Keen sizing inconsistency. I have a wide foot with high arches and for Keen sandals I need an 8 1/2, for lace-ups I need a 9, in this shoe I take an 8. Zappos was great with the exchange, as usual.

My wife just loves this shoe, now she has them in all your colors.

Love this shoe and they look good with jeans. I particularly liked the fact that I can easily get in and out of these shoes without unbuckling them. I also own the lace-up Toyah which does hold my feet more securely however I find myself grabbing these more often. With the MJ, I need to wear thicker socks and use the tightest hole on the buckle strap. This shoe might be ideal with someone with a wider foot. However, I find that most Keens, these are the perfect casual comfort shoe.

I love these shoes! And they're green! How could I go wrong? Super comfortable & sturdy, and a great look.

I already owned a pair of the Toyah oxfords which I loved. I wanted a different style with the same comfort. The MJs fit the bill. They are every bit as comfortable. I need good arch support and these have it. As usual they were great right out of the box. I like to wear thick socks and there is plenty of room in these shoes for that. And as usual Zappos was great.

As a busy grandmother to a 13, 7, 4 and 2 year old love these shoes as I look somewhat stylish and yet can run to catch them, play whatever activity comes up, and can get my feet run over and stepped on without any damage to the shoes or feet. I do try to keep up with the kids and these allow me to do it. I love the shoes and kids.

I love this shoe - I've had 2 of the Sydney II but they don't make it anymore. But these have to go back -- they are too big -- I wish Keen would get their act together and make their sizes consistent between shoes. I don't think a smaller size will work as the heel box is so wide it is going up and down on my heel.

I really love these shoes. I bought them to replace my Keen Calistoga Mary Jane's which I've had for about 4 years. They are not quite as cute in styling, but still way cuter them some of the boxier Keen styles. I've worn them in rain and snow so far and they performed great in both.

Love the style! Too wide through the heel for me; my foot was moving around even with strap tightened all the way down Unfortunately, these will have to go back.