Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

A great shoe if you stand all day. Good arch support. My back and legs stopped hurting the first day after wearing them.

Loved them! Just had to get smaller size.

These shoes were not only wide in the toe box, but wide all over. I have a narrow heel so they won't work for me.

I chose these Keen Toyah MJ as a replacement for my previous pair. I love them. They are comfortable, durable, and easy to put on and take off. Depending on the season I wear them with socks - or not.

I was happy with this shoe though it did feel larger than marked - both in width and length. The issue came after only 3 months or so of abuse from me. The stretchy bands fell apart rather quickly and I had to ask Zappos (love you guys!) to return the shoe. I ended up getting another brand and am leery of Keen shoes. I may try them again because all those excellent reviews can't be wrong and Zappos can't make it easier to send back defective shoes.

I struggle with needing a wide toe box and with needing a 10.5. Keens are great for both, and these shoes didn't disappoint in the least. I manage a clothing store where I walk around from 8-10 hours a day, and these shoes have been awesome through the Christmas season.

Super comfy right out of the box. I am on my feet for 8+ hours a day and these shoes feel great all day long. I love the green too - adds just enough color to otherwise boring work outfits :) Zappos quick delivery is always appreciated too!

Perfect little mary jane for the slightly rugged. This shoe is light, comfy, stable, and cute. The elastic in the strap allows for easy on and off with no fuss. Highly recommended.

The Keen sizing system is a conundrum to me. A few years ago, I bought this in my proper size and it felt great. Then gradually, it stretched out until it felt like I was wearing rowboats on my feet. But I liked the look and the initial comfort. So I've ordered again, this time going down a half size. For now, it seems tight, but I'm hoping it stretches out. I like Keens, and have bought other styles. Some have been perfect from the start. But in other cases I had to buy a half size larger and they still didn't feel big enough. So I'm a little confused, and now own some pairs of Keens shoes that I can't use anymore.

These have been the most comfortable shoes I have worn in years. I have plantar fascitis and high arches - most shoes are agony for me to wear. The strap is adjustable, the toe box is wide and does not ride up too high against the top of my foot. These aren't stylish enough for the young, I would suppose, but they are attractive and suitable for even casual office wear.

I am looking for a comfortable shoe that I can wear to teach in, commute on my bike, and walk around. I want a shoe that does everything and I thought these would be them! These shoes are pretty close to the style I was looking for but have just a couple problems. I have one 'problem' toe, and these accommodate it nicely, but even with socks I had too much heel lift while walking around. They're also a little too bulky. I think I'm going to go with Merrells instead.

The shoes looked used? Scuffed and scratched. Not up to the usual Zappos speed? But very cute shoes! Can't wait to get the replacement.

Very comfortable shoes right from the start. Nice and wide shoes. Decided to get the closed toe, laced up version for our trip, however, in case of rainy days/wet feet.

In general, I love these shoes. They have fantastic arch support. Keens tend to run pretty wide, which works great for my feet. These shoes are not the most beautiful, but they are semi-sporty and cute. My only small complaint about them is that they are hot. I do not know why. This is my third pair of Keens and none of the others do this, but these shoes hold in all the body heat. They will be great this winter, but there is no way I could wear these once the temperature rises above 60°.

I love these shoes! I have 2 pairs of Presidios and I thought those were really comfortable, but the Toyah MJ's are even better! I wear them for work, running errands, etc. my feet never feel tired and my back and hips don't hurt. My very favorite thing about great shoes, not being "aware" of my shoes. When I can focus on other things and forget about my shoes, that makes life so much more enjoyable. I really like the style too. They're so cute and they have the Keen toe bumper, which I love about Keens. Keens shoes are the best! These do run a bit large. I usually wear an 8 in Keens, but in these I needed a 7.5. I can't say enough good things about Zappos! It's the best place to shop. I buy all of my shoes and my sons shoes from Zappos. I wouldn't go anywhere else!

very functional comfortable shoe - not the prettiest shoe but wears well. I work in the emergency department and spend a great deal of time walking and running - these shoes are invaluable.

I have several pairs of Keens and this Toyah was my first slip on, but I am sending back because it is just a bit too big, slips on my heel. If I make the strap tighter, it's too tight across the instep. I love Keens and hope I can find a style that will work.

These shoes are really nice looking and are constructed for wear in all kinds of weather. They are exactly what I was looking for but beware...Keen has a serious quality problem with the sizing. I ordered three pair of these shoes and have officially given up. The first pair swam on my feet. The second pair (in a half size smaller) was too tight, almost as if it was a full size smaller than the first, and the third pair was really whacked. One shoe fit and the other was too big, even looked visibly different. I am really disappointed in Keen. A pair of shoes at this price with the Keen brand should not have these problems. Zappos provides a wonderful service. It seems wrong to send shoes back and forth because of a manufacturer's poor quality control. When I order Birkenstock shoes, they fit every time. A size is a true size. Shame on Keen.

I love Keen shoes. they are always comfortable, cute and they always have my size (11). This model is a good shoe for about town or even moderate hiking.

I was looking for a walking shoe - comfortable, supportive, but cuter than white athletic shoes. I called Zappos telephone support to inquire about sizing due to various reviews I'd read about this shoe an about Keen's in general. Customer service was swift and helpful, tho' they didn't have a "consolidation" of review information I'd hoped. I ordered my regular size and Zappos was fast. Upon receipt of the shoes, I reported to my friends that "expensive" shoes really did feel better! These shoes are a bit "clunky" but are supportive and comfortable (a full day of walking around Yellowstone National Park) and look decent. I don't like the working buckle -- wish it was decorative on an elastic. These shoes and Zappos excellent service had me placing another order within 2 weeks!

My husband always remarks on how few pairs of shoes I own. I invest in a few gorgeous work shoes, a few Dansko clogs and Keens (a pair of sandals and a pair of "walk to works"). These were my replacements for a very old pair of Keens that I don't even remember what they were called, but they were more like ballerina flats. I love these shoes so much, but I'm clearly between a size 9.5 and a 10. They feel a little heavy and clunky. I settled on the Sterling City MJ in a 10, it's much more "agile" feeling and doesn't have the grey sole - so it looks a little dressier. I really wanted to love this shoe, but settled on another, especially considering that I walk around a mile and a half round trip to work every day.

This shoe was what I hoped it would be after reading reviews. I, too, wish the buckles were easier to use. The holes are are too small to find or stick through easily; then they don't come apart easily either. Once on, the shoe is comfortable, offers good support, and is surprisingly good looking.

I just love these shoes! They run a little big so get a size smaller. I had been have foot problems and after I got these shoes for work my foot problems have almost disappeared! Very good support!

These shoes look cute but the quality is not what I am accustomed to with Keens. The shoes are flimsy compared to other Keens. They do not fit securely. I would not buy these again.