Customer Reviews KEEN Toyah MJ

It is the best shoes for walking! So comfortable. I usually get backaches after walking for a couple of hours. These shoes didn't hurt my back at all! My feet didn't feel as tired either. I just wish it was more stylish...

The arch support is wonderful but the shoe is way too heavy and clunky for summer wear. I had to send them back.

I just returned from wearing these for 10 days in rainy London/Paris spring weather. I bought these mainly for their waterproof feature. They were outstanding for that! A little clunky feeling, and not as comfortable as my Aasics I wear for heavy duty walking, but an good choice for wet weather. They did not aggravate my plantar fasciitis, which was important. I would buy them again. I found the length true to size, but they were a little roomy inside top to bottom. But that didn't affect the comfort level, no blisters or anything. I usually wore these with no socks so maybe that was the issue.

Love this shoe; it felt a little snug at first (I have wide feet), but it's stretching perfectly.

I love the look of this shoe-but it feels a bit sloppy on my foot, have to wear a thicker sock - sometimes the size of Keens is a bit unpredictable - an 11 can fit too small and next time be too big, but overall they are my fav. brand of shoe.

These are not the most attractive shoes but Keens are very comfortable. I stand 10 hrs or more a day at work so comfort and support are a must. They are about a 1/2 size larger than marked, so I will need to exchange them for smaller size.

This is a comfortable shoe. I liked the arch support, and it felt sturdy and cushioned, like a good walking shoe. There were two things I didn't like: the edge of the toe cap cut right across my bunion and it made my feet look enormous. Too bad, as I think it would it would make a comfortable walking shoe for anyone without bunions.

I had purchased these for a 2.5 week trip to Europe. They were very comfortable and I'm confident my feet would have been fine, but I felt silly with the big black "duck bill" in the front of the shoe. I already have large feet (size 10), and the black toe seemed to emphasize that. I'm assuming the black Mary Janes wouldn't look as silly. The red color seemed a lot more red than what is pictured on screen.

A nice comfortable shoe, but far too wide in the heel for me. Even after ordering a half size down and even with the strap, I was walking out of the heels. I love Keen's closed toe shoes, but for some reason the more open varieties don't work for me. The search for shoes that work with wide toes/average heels continues.

I have this shoe. I love the look and feel on my feet, but my arthritic knees hurt much worse when I wear them. I keep putting them on though because they are so cute.

These don't unbuckle easily - maybe they will with some wear. Also, while in NY this summer I had purchased a pair of the Petaluma Mary Janes in a size 8.5. The Toyah MJ 8.5 is smaller than the Petaluma. The Keen rubber sole eliminates static electricity - good for office wear in the cold and dry winter climate.

Great shoe! Comfortable and cute. I was a little concerned at first because they slide on my feet a bit, but I've worn them with and without socks with no problems. They are quite chunky, which is what I was looking for, but if you prefer a slim MJ, these might not be for you. Otherwise, I would recommend them. Only minus is the stitching has started coming loose in one little spot (probably a flaw and not regular).

These shoes are very supportive. Considerably more structured than my last pair of Keen Mary Janes. As a result, I think there is a bit of a breaking-in period that I didn't have with the softer shoes. In the end, I like these best!

These are quite comfortable, though Keens don't have quite enough arch support for me. The reason I returned these is the green is not a matt finish but an iridescent color that was not obvious from the photo. the color is unique and pretty but not what I was looking for.

I loved how these looked; I've got high arches and wear orthotics and have had great success with Keen, and these seemed like they would be perfect. But they were loose in the heel and tight on the sides. Felt like a weird fit compared to other keens that I have. I had to send it back!

I have a small wide foot. The leather was hard and the heel slipped up and down. The toe box was great. Had to return.

I have always been a size 8-1/2 in the Keen brand; however, lately it's a hit or miss on their sizing. This style did seem to run a half size larger and the width seemed wide even for my wide feet. I also have a high instep and this style was very generous with the straps so no problem there. I got the midnight blue, which was a very strange color and the reason why I only gave this 4 stars. I think if they were a good fit, they would be very comfortable.

These were heavy and clunky for me. They run large. I usually love Keen's but these just were not for me. Thank you, Zappos for being so understanding!

Nice shoe, supportive foot bed. Edges sharp and uncomfortable at shoe opening and strap.

These shoes are huge! I have wide feel and like the wiggle room that Keen provides, so I ordered my usual 8.5. The boats that arrived look like 10s. I do get the idea that they'd be comfortable if they didn't fit like Pippi Longstocking's shoes, but they're going back.

These shoes did run 1/2 size large. I'm between a 6-1/2 and 7 and even the 6-1/2 were a little big. My main problem with these shoes was that they're hot! They're going back.

These are LARGE shoes. I put them next to other MJ's that I have and other Keen's and these are just bigger, mostly in the width. These shoes were too wide and very unattractive on my foot. I wanted something that I could wear with shorts, skirts, pants (I know, tall order), especially when traveling, but these weren't it. Too bad! I love my other Keens. So glad Zappos makes returns so easy!

I ordered these a 1/2 size smaller because reviews were that they ran big. But they were really big. Normally I wear a 7.5 in Keens and other shoes. So I ordered at 7. I think I'd have to re-order at size 6.

Researched & ordered based on the many favorable reviews. Fit was horrible, however, for my feet (non-meaty / med width, so oftentimes Narrow sizing work better). Not only does sizing run large, many other aspects also big -- side width, front top, heels! My feet were swimming in these! Reviewers also reported great support. I found this not to be so -- more like 50% for my high arches. No comparison to my Olukai & Chaco zoris. Cute chunky MJ otherwise.

I really wanted to keep these shoes. Sadly, they are going back. When I put them on for the first time they felt great. The arch support was wonderful and they are super cute. However, the back of the shoe is so wide it flopped when I walked. A 1/2 size smaller would be to short. So back they go!