Customer Reviews Hunter Original Short

These boots are really cute - they are a little uncomfortable though, very stiff through the ankle. Do not wear them without socks, you will get blisters for sure. However, I'm sure after a couple of wears with some nice thick socks they will break in well! The short boots are a good option for people like me who have "athletic" calves. I am also very short and have tiny feet, so the shorter style is not as overwhelming to my frame.

At first I was skeptical to spend $125 for a pair of rubber boots, but with these boots you get what you pay for! These boots are awesome, they are a good quality boot that will last a few years. I love the matte eggplant purple, They do scuff a bit but I like that look. I typically wear a size 8.5- 9 woman's and I bought a size 8 and it fits perfect, so they do run a bit larger.

I have large calves and the circumference of this boot was too small by just an inch or so. It was almost there, but because of my large calves, the shaft of the boot puckered a bit. The size of the shoe seems about a half size larger, but it was probably designed to be worn with either thick socks or the welly socks. I didn't try it out, but I think it would fit perfectly in terms of foot size with the thick/welly socks. I wish the boot fit so I could have kept them, but it just didn't work out. So those of you with large/wide calves, be aware this may or may not work for you.

I bought these in black with a welly sock, and I looked like I was wearing Santa's boots! These are much wider than the original tall. I am 5'8" 130 and these did not work for me at all. The size 9 fits w/ the welly sock, the 8 fits me w/out, I normally wear 8.5 in shoes.

So I should start by saying I ordered these boots after reading numerous reviews that said the calves were larger than usual. So I knew before hand what might happen when I got these boots. And it did. The boots were fine. A little short on my legs, but the tall Hunter boot was too tall (I am 5'2"). So I ordered a size 5 (I usually wear a 6½ or 7 in women's) in the kid's version and voilà! They were perfect. So if you have small calves (mine are 13½") this might work better for you, not to mention you can save money!

I really like these boots - very sturdy and comfortable. Sizing is the biggest issue. I am a 9 1/2, not quite a 10. I originally bought the 8/9 because everyone said to size down, but I ended up buying the 10. The boots are meant to wear with socks, even thick ones, so I wanted that option. If I were to wear thin socks then I will need to put a liner in the boot to prevenet my foot/heel from moving a little bit. Also, because these are the short boots, I can see myself either wearing taller socks or tucking my pants in because the top of the boot touches my calf when I walk. Without fabric next to my leg I think it might end up driving me crazy if I was walking a lot. I bought these to work in the garden, not to strut around city streets.

I live in Chicago and need warm boots to last through the winter months. While I accepted that these were mostly stylish, I still expected them to be somewhat practical! They are excellent for keeping me feet dry from snow and rain, have a great grip on the bottom and are easy to walk long distances in, but warm they are not. The description also listed that the lining wicks away moisture, which is not true. I ended-up needing to also purchase sheep's wool insoles and thick socks to help keep my feet warm and dry on the inside. (The Hunter brand fleece socks are only for the taller boots.) I don't think I'd purchase another pair, but they will work while they last.

I ordered a size smaller than I wear and with insoles they are a pretty good fit. They are very cute and I am quite pleased.

Amazing and perfect. Everything I could ask for in a boot. I bought the short ones because the tall ones seem unnecessary to me given the amount of snow we receive. They are not warm at all so in the winter I just put on two pairs of socks for snowy and cold days. In the spring they will be perfect to keep my feet dry as I commute.

Even though my boyfriend thinks they look dumb, I love these boots. I have really big calves so with jeans tucked in the boots look silly, but I don't really care; form over function. Not only are my boots totally waterproof, but I don't have to worry about slipping, even in an ice storm! And with wool socks I can even wear these in a Chicago winter and be comfortable. I have blue and they go great with everything! Also I have a wide foot and these fit perfectly.

Disappointing boots for actual wet weather. I’ve had these a while but they fairly quickly started leaking at the seam with both soles. And the leaking has happened with another pair of Hunters. Now the rubber is splitting across the top. Dry rot? They may be fashionable but they don’t hold up under normal use. As an alternative i love my deck height XtraTuffs and wish they weren’t sold out of their version of this boot.

A little narrow and very little to no support. I ended up keeping the London fog boots as they were a bit wider and more supportive.

This review won't be very helpful for many. I bought these boots thinking they would be large enough for this year but the ankle was too narrow for my 6-month-out-from-surgery-fibula. Hopefully I can try again next year! They were very nice looking in the box!

I so wanted to love this boot. The the top of the boot hits at the back of my calf (no surprise there), but it quickly became uncomfortable to walk with the edge of the boot rubbing against the back of my legs. I have a pair of the tall ones and find them much more comfortable to wear for hours at a time.

Heavy and not very comfortable. I tried the tall boots first and actually liked them better. These feel heavier and dont fit well in the calf area. They stick out in the front and pinch slightly in the back. They are going back!

Love the style and overall look for the purpose the Hunter Original Short boots serve however they are heavy to wear.

Difficult to get into, buckle doesn't lay flat

These didn't work for me. Tried them in two sizes, based on reviews. I'm a seven, and these fit length-wise, but there was too much room around my foot and heel. They are heavy; I imagine if I tried walking in them in mud my foot would come out. As a point of reference, my feet are long, flat, and bony, and I have Morton's toe (second toe longer than first). I'm also short (5'2") and these banged uncomfortably on my legs as I walked in them. The material is thick and stiff. Nice looking, if you have the right feet and are maybe a taller person.

I like them but why are they nearly impossible to get on.

Cute boot and good quality. However I think it would be a difficult fit for anyone with a high instep or slightly wider (but not wide) foot. It was just too hard to get on and off.

These are very cute in style, but they were huge around my calves and flopped against them when i walked. I ended up choosing the ankle style hunter boots and love them so far

Very heavy boot that kids felt dug into achilles. But they look great!

They fit fine, but the color was off

Made well but the short shaft looks funny on.