Customer Reviews Birkenstock Mayari - Birko-Flor™ & Birkibuc™

Love these sandals! I finally broke down and bought a pair after years of wanting them, and I'm so glad I did. The part around the toe was a little uncomfortable at first but only took about a day to break in and now they are super comfy. In fact, after only wearing them a few days to work, I wore them all day sightseeing around Boston without any issues (I brought a backup pair just in case but didn't need to use them. As with other Birks, I find I need to size down from the listed guidance. I typically wear a 7 or 7 1/2 (usually 7), which suggests a 38, but 37 is the perfect size for me. I have slightly wider feet and a high instep, which this style works well for. I was trying to decide between the Gizeh and these, but I tried them both on and I thought these were much more flattering and feminine. My only complaint (why I took off one star) is that I bought the Habana oiled leather version, but the leather did not appear as dark and rich as it does in the photos. It was lighter, had an almost rose-colored tint, and had a dry/ashy quality about it. I'm hoping some leather oil will help darken it up and restore its condition. I'm going to try Otter Wax brand which is all natural.

After reading so many stellar reviews, I was anxious to received these sandals. I have a pair of Arizonas, and they felt really chunky, so I went a size down in these. I have gone back and forth with Zappos (thanks for the amazing customer service) to try to get the correct size. In my regular size (39) they felt wide enough, but too short. The customer service rep suggested I move a size up, but try the narrow. They feel too narrow. I'm going to wear them for a while to see if they conform to my foot before I make my final decision on how I feel about these. I'm the Goldilocks of Birkenstocks!

My daughter and I both had to go down one size for this shoe. Runs big!

I bought these becasue I wanted comfortable walking shoes to wear for an upcoming trip to Europe, and I wanted something g that could go day to night as we're trying to be minimal packers. These would have been my first pair of Birkenstocks, but I returned them, as the color, which here looks to have a metallic sheen, does not. As I'm bringing a lot of black clothes I anted something far less brown and far more metallic.

I normally never have any trouble with Birkenstock sandals but these are longer and wider than other Size 36 Birkenstock I have purchased.

Definitely had a break in period for these shoes...but it was really quick and now have a great pair of sandals that fit to my feet! Favorite part about these...is that they come in narrow (PERFECT!!) and I love the silver color...a snazzy and stylish upgrade to the original brown.

*sigh* I've wanted a pair of Birkenstocks since the 7th grade, almost 25 years ago. I had a knockoff pair of the "Arizona" style sandals from a big box store, but they never fit quite right and they looked too hippie-ish. However, they were comfy and utilitarian. I've been lusting after the Mayari style for about a year and I finally caved, hoping that this style would look a little more feminine and hippie chic. Sadly, these well-made, supportive sandals were every bit as awful on me as the knockoffs of my youth. My feet felt big and manly, so I returned them. Your feet may be different, however. I would recommend them as far as quality and fit go, but the style just wasn't for me.

These Mayari are definitely more fashionable than other Birki's and in a fun color they really dress up. The only thing negative that I can say about them is that I think this style runs a half size big (I have 2 other styles in sz39, but I wish I would have gotten these in a 38). With that said, once they form to my foot I'm sure they'll still be supremely comfortable like my others.

I really wanted these to work. However, if you are truly a size 12, the 42 may not fit you. The shoe was too short and since there is a raised lip around the toe box, you really can't get away with wearing a size smaller.

Foxy little sandals! Got the silver and they're cute as a button. Almost thought they weren't going to work because my big toe was getting pulled to the side...l had the strap closest to the toes fastened too tight. Once l loosened it l didn't have any problem. Hardcore Birk arch support as usual, which my flat feet love. If you're new to Birkenstock, take heed of all the advice out there to slowly increase wearing them over time. Even seasoned Birkenstock peeps will gradually break a new pair in. Save yourself the pain and trust me on this. Couple hours at a time over the span of several days, or a week. The cork foot bed will adjust to the contours of your foot for a perfect fit. I highly recommend the cork saver to prolong the life of your shoe, and as fussy as this sounds, don't let them get wet. It really degrades the life of the shoe. One last tip: If you find a style and color of Birkenstock you love and don't want to live without - get two pair! You won't be sorry. They change their colors and styles more often than they used to. Finally... Zappos has the VERY BEST people to take the VERY BEST care of you ?

Super cute style! Took a few wears to break in. After being broken in, they are really comfortable and can be worn everywhere! I see another pair in my future!

super comfy after the break in period. not the greatest for the first 2 weeks but after that it forms to your feet and its god sent! also the girliest birkenstocks i've seen, lots of unsolicited compliments from strangers. 4 stars because the footbed eventually gets discolored and turned my foot orange once. still my favorite sandals and i have bought a second pair that i'm breaking in. turned my sister and my best friend into birkenstock believers as well!

I loved my Birkenstock Gizehs and wore them until they were falling apart. I had my eye on these Mayaris to mix it up a little bit. I usually wear a US size 5, and had to get Gizehs a size smaller (4-4.5). I ordered the Mayaris in the 4-4.5 size, and was disappointed that they fit larger than the Gizehs - like at least a half size too big still! I shouldn't have to be considering exchanging for a kids style (3-3.5) for the best fit. In the end I kept my sandals but was bummed that they don't fit as great as my Gizehs. The strap also rubs against the edge of my pinky toe a bit, even after breaking them in for a couple of weeks. I still wear them if I know I won't be on my feet for too long - hopefully they'll get even more comfortable. I do like the style of the Mayari straps though - cute yet functional.

I have a pair of these that are a few years old and I love them! They are one of two styles of Birkenstocks I wear. That said, this year's version of this style seems to be running huge. I slipped it on and had a full inch behind my heel! I tried the size smaller and it "just" fit to the point it was ultimately going to be a bit uncomfortable. I'm going to try the narrow to see if that will work. The regular width went back. I still recommend this style!

These sandals are very cute. They go with any outfit. I will bye more colors!

Adore these Birks, even though they're not the cutest. Thankful for narrow sizing!

Very attractive for Birkenstocks, and that's what I was looking for and this style is feminine, not clunky. Unfortunately, for me, the toe strap was quite uncomfortable and the golden finish looks a bit garish. Back to Arizonas.

These are great every day sandals. The arch support is wonderful and made a big difference in my plantar fasciatis. The shoes are casual enough to wear with jeans, but nice enough to wear with a summer dress. I get compliments on them often.

Bought these for my daughter and she loves them. I don't care for the texture of the foot bed, especially when they get wet, but it doesn't seem to bother her. Can't believe Birks are back in!

Very comfortable, just takes awhile to break in the foot bed. Great alternative style for your Birk needs!

This is my 2nd time purchasing Mayari. I wore my 1st pair so much, they started to come apart. I suspect Birkenstock quality has dropped in recent years because I often read reviews about those having the same pair for 10 years, but mine lasted 2 summers. Sizing for me is tricky because one foot is larger than the other. I am supposed to wear a 40, but there is far too much space in front of my toes and behind my heel. I have done much research on sizing, and I have learned that your heel is supposed to sit all the way back, and there should be no more than 1/4 inch space in front of your toes. However, the 39 is somewhat snug on my larger foot, but it's better than being too large. For reference, I always wear a size 9 or 9.5 in shoes. The regular width is just wide enough and I have wide feet. These are definitely not as wide as the Boston or Arizona.

I wanted these to work but found Birkenstock Rio to be a better choice for my foot.

My favorite. Love the silver, looks great. I have over a dozen pair of Birkenstocks. I have a very wide foot and a high arch. I have learned to order the narrow width. Wore these around the house for a couple days and they now fit perfect!!

Way too big ! Wear 7-7.5 in most any shoe. Tried 38 and way too big. Ordering 36 and 37 to try