Customer Reviews Sperry Angelfish

These run huge! I ordered an 8 (my usual size) and they're way too big. I don't know if even a 7 will be small enough. I will update the review if/when I find a size that fits, so that I can tell about the shoe rather than the size. The shoes might be wonderful, but I'm giving only 3 starts right now because they should be sized similarly to other brands of shoes.

Too tight for me. I don't believe in having to break in shoes. They should fit right out of the box. Lovely look to the shoe, but I'm returning.

Shoe looks great and gets compliments but the con is that it gives me blisters on my heels which is annoying when you pay this much for shoes that are supposed to be comfortable.

I wanted to love these... but the shoelaces refuse to stay tied for more than one minute at a time, they gave me awful blisters even being worn with socks. The shape is a bit odd as well.. the width is true until the toe area where they become really narrow.

There's something about my darn feet, I can never find a well fitting flat, moccasin, or boat shoe. It's so frustrating! The style of these shoes are adorable! I ordered the grey and yellow. I loved that they had soft cozy lining on the inside. I am usually at 5.5 in boots, I size down to a 5 for heels and flats.. I ordered a 5 in these because I saw they ran large. When I first slipped these on, I thought. "Hey, maybe I finally lucked out! These are super comfy!" But then I started walking and my heel kept slipping out of the back. :( Yet another pair of flats sadly sent back to Zappos. Well, at least Zappos is so fabulous with their shipping and returns, it makes it practically painless!

I have wide feet, but often make do with an 8½ standard width. I ordered an 8½W in the linen/oat. the toe box is absolutely perfect, and the footbed is cushiony. With socks, these fit nicely length wise, but without socks, I feel like these may just be slightly too long. Because these are made of leather, they are probably going to stretch, I am concerned that they may get too long. I could have gotten past that, but the top back part of the heel was unexpectedly narrow, causing it to pinch with every step. I also noticed that there were scratch marks on the leather on the top part of the toes (on both shoes); that could be from bumps during shipping. It seems like the leather could get scratch marks easily from something like a fingernail. I really want to keep these, but the pinching heels are a deal breaker, to say nothing of scratch marks on a new pair of shoes.

Painful on bunions. This is well made with plenty of cushioning in the arch and heel. Unfortunately, the grommet and leather cord land exactly on the bone of your big toe. Too painful to wear. Sadly I will be returning them.

I ordered my regular size. The length was fine but they were too wide in the heel. Too bad I had to send them back, I loved the looks of them.

I bought these shoes as a birthday gift for my girlfriend and the size 7 was too tight on her feet. I bought her a pair of 7.5 to try then and they were slipping off of her heel. She loves the style but neither size fits her so both pairs are being sent back to pick a different type of shoe possibly still Sperrys.

Not the most comfortable but they're adorable shoes. I love how they look with some shorts or skinnies. They take some time to wear in and the process is painful but worth it.

ORDER A HALF SIZE LARGER! Most Sperrys will stretch not these. I wound up with huge blisters. Super cute shoes other than that :).

Caution: This shoe will cause a corn on your little toe and on the bone of the top of your foot if not padded out properly by a Dr. Scholls Pad... After walking around in them, the skin on the back of my upper heel tore... but I got tons of compliments! Unless you can order a full size higher, stay away!

This shoe felt small but the width was perfect. The leather was very stiff feeling which makes the shoe uncomfortable for me.

These are the cutest Sperry's ever! Unfortunately had to return because they are also the most uncomfortable shoes ever. Extremely tight (even at the right size) and left red mark on the insides and heel of my feet.

I have no idea why this just does not fit my feet! I tried regular and wide, my size, up and down 1/2 size. Very impressed with Zappos return, but disappointed at the shoes! I really really wanted to like them too.

I like the look, but I do not like that I have to always pull the ties to make them the right size. Then after I walk in them a few hours I have to tighten them up again.

Best looking most uncomfortable shoes ever! The seam rubs furiously right where your bunion is, and only multiple band-aids can help.

Cute looking and Sperry's certainly have a long reputation, but they are not for my foot...at least not this loafer. The footbed does nothing to support my flat feet, and thus the shoe spreads out unflatteringly and accentuates innward pronation. All it would take is to replace the plain footbed with one that cups the bottom of the heel (to prevent the heel shifting sideways when walking) and a cushioned arch support...that's whey my foot spreads the shoe. Cute in the pix but not on my foot.

Love the way they look. I purchased them because I was looking for a cute comfortable spring/summer shoe. I have bunions which get irritated when I wear these shoes. They also seem to run big as my heel slips out of the back when I walk. Also the laces came undone after only wearing them a couple of times and I can't seem to figure out how to tie them in a way that won't cause the laces to stick up.

Very cute. However, if you have bunions, do not buy these shoes. I've been told they will stretch, but I'm in extreme pain until then. Ordering a wide wouldn't work, they would be too big everywhere. I have another pair of Sperry Angelfish and for some reason they are not this tight.

These shoes are very comfortable. I ordered them because the design was cute. However, when looking down at them from the top they are the same color as grandma's orthopedic shoes - not cute! Returning them for other colors! Love Zappos returns are so easy!

The gold is very sparkly in person. A little too much flair for me. Back they go. They also seemed a 1/2 size too big.

I ordered this shoe half a size small based on reviews, and when I got the shoe it was too small so I had to return it and reorder in my size. When I got the replacements they did fit so definitely order true to size. The shoe is cute and very stylish, I love it. However, the leather on the toe area of one of the shoes I received is scratched and on that same shoe, the heel part also has a blue stain. It's pretty disappointing paying this much for shoes and them coming stained/scratched. I don't think I am going to send it back just because it's too much of a hassle and I don't have the time to keep reordering and shipping items back. I guess since no one is going to be down at my feet looking at my shoes it won't be noticeable to anyone else.

I love the Angelfish style, but it isn't a great choice if you have narrow heels. I sized down by a half size. Just by walking around in the store, I could tell that my heels were struggling to stay inside the shoe. I can't imagine what they'd be like after the leather stretches a bit. These also hit at a weird point on my foot. Despite being too wide, they cut right across the joint area. I could tell they'd be very painful after a few hours. On the plus side, the footbed is cushy and offers more arch support than most slip-on shoes. I'm really sad these didn't work for me, but I'm hoping the Bluefish style will be a better match for my foot issues.