Customer Reviews Frye Melissa Button

I am LOVING these boots! I ordered the grey, which is more like a brownish-grey. They aren't really "true" cowboy boots. It's more like if a cowboy boot and a riding boot had a baby, it would be this boot.

Love this boot. Super comfortable to wear, even when walking all over town. I bought boots true to size -- the half-size down also fit, but I felt my normal size were more comfortable with a sock. Like others have said, the first couple times taking the boot on and off is a bit tough but the leather stretches to make it easy to wear. It does bunch slightly at the ankles for me, but I suspect that's because I have slightly wider athletic calves. Still, definitely will be buying Frye boots again in the future!

I have wanted to buy these boots for a long time but hesitated because of the price. I am so glad I did. Very comfortable. True to size. Look amazing. Thought and thought about it. If I spend money on boots each year for the next few year, I reach the cost of these eventually. Now, I know I am not going to need a pair of boots for many years; these are timeless and well made. Just buy them already!

I bought these to surprise my long distance girlfriend just because. Someone told me to buy them a size small, because they run big. They apparently fit perfectly, and I got major bonus points. These boots are epic.

Beautiful boot. They look almost black in the picture but are actually dark chocolate. The leather is excellent quality but soft making them scuff on the outside very easily. So if you're rough on your boots you may not like the boots in this color. The fit is true to size. I wear a 6 and these boots fit perfect. I was worried about the calf circumference because of the different comments but they fit perfect for skinny jeans or skirts. I'm 5'5 and 112lbs with average calves so hopefully that helps some of you. If you're on the fence about these boots don't be they're very comfortable with no break in time and they're beautiful excellent quality boots.

I have thought about Frye boots for several years and I was so excited when they arrived today. Unfortunately, it is too difficult for me to get my foot in and pull them up. They are well made so I will try again with a zipper!

I love these boots and where them with everything - dresses, skinny jeans, skirts. So versatile. I get compliments on them whenever I wear them!

I love these boots. I already have the Frye Shirley riding boots in brown and have enjoyed them for some time. I was looking for a pair of tall black riding boots and tried on MANY in a lesser price point. I decided not to be penny wise and pound foolish and splurge on quality. I don't have skinny calves but I'm not in the range of wide calf but Frye seems to fit perfect. I can even fit a skinny pant in too! Broke a bit of a sweat getting them on, but I think that will ease with time as the leather softens (can't wait)!

Beautiful boot! It was true to size. I have average sized calves and did not have trouble pulling it on.

It really doesn't get better than the Frye boot, amazing craftsmanship and beautiful leather. These are easy, and go with everything. I was most concerned with the shaft circumference, but it's just right. My calves measure 15, and so do the boots. I know over time they will stretch some, so it's a good fit. I love them!

Buy these boots. I have had mine for almost two years and they are perfect. I wear them with jeans, dresses, skirts and always feel like they add style and class to every outfit. After trying many sizes and colors, I selected the Vintage soft black in my normal size of 7 1/2. I lived in Washington DC and walked everywhere when I bought them. These were always my go-to for a day of sight seeing followed by dinner. I now live in Alaska and wear them year round. You won't be disappointed.

I love these boots. I wear them everywhere for work or walking when I'm traveling. I have to wear them over tights with skirts and dresses though, because they won't fit over pants. I've been meaning to get a second pair in black or gray, but I've held off because the cost.

I love these boots. I wear them almost every day in the fall and winter. I've even worn down the soles and need them replaced! My only problem was that they started to slouch, but they still look great, its a more relaxed look now. I have the Dark Brown Antique Soft Full Grain Leather color and they seem to go with everything, even black. I highly recommend these boots.

I really love these boots but will need to exchange them for a half size bigger. I wanted to write a review though because I'm so impressed by Zappos. I ordered the boots yesterday around lunch time. When UPS showed up today (less than 24 hours later) I thought I forgot about something else I'd ordered. I thought there was no way it could be the boots already, but it was. Ridiculously fast! I will definitely be a repeat customer.

These boots are awesome but the beautiful color and stiffness goes away really quickly. They are still my favorite pair of boots to wear but they definitely look worn just after a few months, even if you take care of them.

These are very comfortable and cute boots! They are versatile as well. You can wear these boots with jeans or with summer dresses. This cognac color is particularly matchable with pretty much any outfit. If you are looking for year-round, solid, well-made boots, then these are the shoes for you.

This is my favorite boot. it runs a bit larger than my true size. I'm usually an 8 or 8.5 in shoes and a 9 in running shoes. I purchased the 8 and it fits perfectly. The leather is soft and the boot is so much more comfortable that I thought it would be. Awesome quality boot that will last. My only negative - it's pretty hard to get my foot in - I have to wear a nylon otherwise my foot will not slip in, I have narrow feet.

My Melissa Buttons are finally dying, after three years of near constant wear. I had them resoled twice. They were well worth every cent.

I am a new fan of Frye boots, and wasn't sure which size to buy. My Campus boots are 7, but I go between 7 - 7.5 on shoe size. Zappos Customer Service suggested going to 7.5 which I did. Perfect fit. They are beautiful, easy to pull on, and I am in love with them. My only concern was the durability of the leather sole, but time will tell (and I won't wear them on wet surfaces).

The most comfortable pair of boots I own. I have no doubt that they will last year. An investment piece that is well worth the price.

This are the most awesome boot that I'll ever have in my closet. Very comfortable and goes w/everything.

These boots are great. Unfortunately I ordered the dark brown brush off but received the light brown brush off, a color that I did not find the least bit appealing. Returning isn't a good option for me as I live in Ecuador and shipping both ways is quite expensive, so after consulting with Frye customer service I treated them with a dark brown polish. After buffing they now look more like the brown antique, which is a much better color. I think after a few more polishings (somewhat labor intensive) they'll be closer to the color I was hoping for. This might be something to consider if you're thinking of buying the light brown brush of for the discounted price but don't really love the color.

Love these boots. True to size and very comfortable right from the start. More on the casual side. Wish Zappos Canada had worked out.

I order the black vintage leather and I just received them, they are beautiful and fantastic except they look completely different from the picture on the website. In fact they have a grayish sheen to them because of this white powdery substance on them which is not what I wanted. I will probably be exchanging them for the other black.

I got the Cognac, which is a lovely color. I have high arches and the boot was a bit tough to get on the first couple of times (tight getting my foot through the ankle), but still very comfortable, and getting easier. I'm a size 6 shoe and a 26-27 jean, I wear them with skinny jeans and they fit perfectly in the calf, not tight but no gaping either. I'm very happy with my purchase. Beautiful boot.