Customer Reviews Allen Edmonds Fifth Avenue

Within the last 5 months I've bought 7 AE shoes. Two in particular is the Fifth Ave in Walnut and Chili. I must say, this is easily the best dress shoes I've ever bought. It is so easy to match a whole attire. It is very classy with just a hint of brogueing - not too much not too little. I love wearing navy or sky blue shirt and pants, and the Fifth Ave is the perfect compliment, especially with the matching Manistee belt. They are very comfortable as well. I work in an office and my job involves walking around the building. Wearing the Fifth Ave does cause any stress on my feet and even my back. I find the last to be the perfect fit for me also - in size 8 and standard width (D). I highly recommend these shoes in practically any/all color. I have enough shoes to wear daily without wearing the same twice a week. I also have Wednesdays dedicated for my Fifth Ave in Walnut - you know Walnut Wednesday? But I find myself wanting to wear the Fifth Ave everyday. Casual Fridays have been very difficult since I would always want to wear the Fifth Ave also. Good thing I have the Chili so atleast I can start calling Fridays Fifth Ave Fridays.

I ordered these in the dark chili. Great color. Versatile. The first pair came with some puckering in the leather. I sent them back, after contacting customer service, and got a second pair without issue. The second pair arrived with the V tread sole. This was not an option that I ordered, but I was very happy to have it. On a brannock I am an 11.5 D/E, so I ordered an 11.5 E. The width is great, but I should have gone with an 11 on this (the 5) last. I have a pair of Cornwallis 11.5 E on the 1943 last that fit better length-wise. That said, the 11.5 E 5th ave. is still quite comfy. I can wear them for 12 hours at a time without any issues. Great shoes.

I have been wearing the Fifth Avenue as a uniform shoe and the Park Avenue for over20 years for a major airline. They are extremly comfortable. When greeting passengers I'm always receiving complements on the shine and beauty of the make of shoe. I also purchased a pair of the Hampstead in Chili and the matching belt. No matter where I go I am always complemented on my selection of shoes. When they start to show wear I send them in for recrafting and the shoes look as good as new.

I was looking for a new dress shoe to add to my boring collection of just black dress shoes and these Fifth Avenues in the walnut calf are the perfect addition. The best part is knowing how long they'll be a part of my wardrobe.

These were my third pair of AE shoes. The quality of materials and construction are good, and the fit is great. These are very comfortable shoes that require very little break in. The dark chili color is beautiful and very versatile. What really stands out when visiting one of AE's stores is the level of service provided. All the sales people I've dealt with have been knowledgeable about the products, friendly, and professional. I highly recommend visiting one of the stores if you have one in your area.

I own several pairs of AE shoes so these fit exactly as expected. Great customer service and a deep, rich brown color that will never go out of style.

My first pair of Allen Edmonds dress shoes and I have no regrets. Not only do these shoes look phenomenal, they make you feel phenomenal.

I got these shoes for my wedding. Very happy with them. They're comfortable, well-made, and they work with many outfits (not just my wedding suit!)

I own over 20 pair of AE shoes and I have this style is black, walnut, chili and merlot. One of my favorites.

I purchased the Walnut-colored Fifth Avenue. They are very stylish and look great. I added a custom feature to it - the PORON cushion inner solee. They are comfortable to wear. I definitely recommend these shoes.

Had these shoes for about 3 years. I wear them once or twice a week. They still look perfectly. Definitely will get another pair if the price is right.

Just like the Park Avenue this shoe has an identical fit and similar appearance. The brogue added to this paired with the appropriate belt such as the Manistee belt is a great combination and look's great. I would highly recommend this product to anyone who is looking for a similar shoe to the park avenue but wants a little more flare from the brogue. Great construction, somewhat conservative but respected and will never go out of style.

This is my third pair of Allen Edmonds shoes and it did not disappoint. The Fifth Avenues are stylish (conservative enough for court) while being very comfortable.

The 5 last has to be the absolute best fitting shoe for me. All around fantastic feel. I picked these up as an alternate between my Park Avenue and McAllister Merlot shoes (all 5 last) and they make an excellent addition to my collection!

I am very happy with my pair of Fifth Ave's. Basically they are your classic cap-toe oxfords, but the little bit of perfing on the toe gives them a bit of character and makes them seem slightly less stuffy. I wear them to work often in a business casual environment, but they also work great with a suit or sport coat. My pair does seem a bit tighter than other AE shoes I have in the same size built on the 65 last, but they have broken in nicely and are quite comfortable.

I'm a CEO of a company and own many pairs of AE shoes. I recently bought a pair of Fifth Avenue's in Walnut with a dainite sole. The shoes, as always, show extreme attention to detail. They fit perfectly, are comfortable and look excellent. The stitching is spot on. The leather chosen has no blemishes. It's simply a great pair of dress shoes to wear to a meeting or any other company function.

The Fifth Ave shoe in brown was a perfect choice for me as I wore it at my son's wedding. This classic style is very comfortable. The quality, craftsmanship and value for money is fantastic.

I have purchased no fewer than four pairs of this shoe! The dark chili pair is my favorite because they stand out enough to make sure I wear the right belt, but not enough to be over the top. A great fit, these shoes are holding up well and don't make me fee like I have been running through airports all week. Great value, great look!

The shoe looks great and holds up well. I am a 9 E, so my foot is wide and the shoe is very comfortable if you get the right size. Also, I got the rubber sole, a good touch.

These shoes are hands down the best I've ever purchased. Having been a J&M and Ecco guy previously, the difference in quality and fit is remarkable. I found these to be comfortable right out of the box and even more so after 2-3 days of wearing as the footbed molded to my foot providing a custom fit. Perfect balance of support and and flexibility without any pinching or hot spots, which I attribute to the leather quality and craftsmanship. In the relatively short time I've owned and worn these, I've received more compliments than I ever received for all the shoes I'd worn previously. A truly great product and great value, I'm an Allen Edmonds guy now.

I will never again buy any dress shoes other than AE!

Ordered a EE width for my wide feet and these shoes fit like a glove. Finally found a great looking shoe that fits comfortably. Top notch shoe! Will not be using anything else in the future.

The one thing that I love most about all AE shoes is the thickness of the sole - the leather sole is thicker than the average European counterpart.

This shoe has a great combination of style and comfort. The shoe has a classic elegance and is perfect for business.

These are really the gold standard, in my mind, for shoes. Once they're broken in, they're extremely comfortable and they look great. People always compliment me on my shoes when I wear these. I can't say enough good things about them.