Customer Reviews Sperry A/O 2-Eye

Shoe Not as expected I thought it would be exactly like the ones I had 25 years ago with a squared off toe. These were too long and narrow in the toe area.

I am a women with a wide foot and a long foot. I need a size 11W. I am not the only women who needs that size and you don't even carry your shoe in that size. Shame on your company. I was buying Sperrys for All of my children, but since you can't make them to fit me. I will not buy anymore.

Tried a medium in blue, but it was too wide. Narrow is VERY limited and only come in one color. Quality isn't like it used to be.

The boat shoes are way to narrow! I actually order a 1/2 size up to hopefully account for all the reviews that cited shoes being to narrow and that was not enough.

Actual colour much different/darker than pictured.

I love these shoes. This one came with a full length scratch across the top.

I have purchased the Authentic Leather Boat Shoes before and was very pleased and decided to try the Authentic Tonal Leather Boat Shore. I was very disappointed when I got them. The shoes appeared to have been worn and scratched. I did not try them on. I will return them and try at another time to purchased only the "Authentic Original" boat shoe that I know works for me.

The grey model does not match the images advertised.

That your shoes don't come in a 10 1/2 narrow. 10s are too short and 11s are too long. Also everyone doesn't have a wide foot !

These shoes are a great fit, and the leather lis lovely & soft, unfortunately there is a clear plastic thread (think fishing line) that pokes into my right foot. I can either learn to live with the discomfort, or clip the thread, running the risk of having the entire top run of stitching come undone.

Had to return these shoes that are so beautiful. The ankle is too loose on this style of shoe for my narrow foot. I have always been able to purchase the medium widths with Sperry's, but not this shoe.

These fit too narrow for my foot. I ordered the angelfish in wide and the fit was perfect. Unfortunately, these do not fit and are not comfortable.

Poor quality of leather. Thin, flimsy with no support. Hard to walk in. Color beautiful, on size. Disappointing for Sperry.

The shoe was not sized correctly. It was marked 9.5M but was actually a 9M ... I had to return as it was too small.

Do not buy these colored shoes. The minute they get wet, the dye will transfer all over your feet. How can boat shoes not be able to get wet? You can see the transfer on the inner sole. Unfortunately, most of it is on my feet. I couldn't even scrub the dye off my feet with a stiff pedicure brush. Totally ruined my pedicure. :-(

The shoe really looks great until you try it on. I'm an 8.5M and it fits true to size. But that's it! The plaid lining feels and looks like thin paper and only is 3/4 quarters in the length in the shoe. It keeps lifting and curling as you walk. The rest of the shoe is a rough rawhide grain. The Sperry label is sewed in the paper plaid lining close to the heel and part way in the arch so you can feel the rise of the stitching and label as you walk. I found it irritating to my feet. Walking with this shoe feels like walking on concrete. I just cannot believe this is a Sperry made shoe. They arrived today and already are being shipped back to Sperry.

I brought the same pair years ago and love them. I wanted a new one because my old ones where getting worn. Too tight and small. They don't seem to be the same size.

I needed a White boat shoe for a yacht club event so ordered this shoe in "Ice". It is definitely off-white or even a light tan. I returned the shoe and bought a different pair. The color on the description should be renamed I think.

The shoes camE scratched and worn looking. They were a bad buy. I dont recommend. Im returning the pair i ordered now..

This Sperry Top Sider is not true to size. My daughter is a size 9 and that's what I purchased, but way too small. I'm a size 8 and they are small and tight on me. They are also very narrow. I don't have flat feet at all and they are tight. I also didn't realize that you can't exchange for a bigger size. You have to Return them and reorder them again. Not Happy about that at ALL...

After only one week of wear the stitching on upper toe became loose and the shoe began to fall apart.The item was returned to Sperry! This was not the typical quality I would expect in any Sperry shoe let alone an "Original". I sure hope that this is not an indication that the quality that most people expect in a Sperry shoe is deteriorating. Perhaps just an isolated problem but certainly worth a quality control check in the factory. At this point not sure whether I will reorder the same item or not.