Customer Reviews Johnston & Murphy Waverly Wing Tip

After a year and a half of use, I still love this shoe! It looks great and feels great. It has kept the style going for a long time, and I think it will last a while more.

Left shoe developed a hole in the sole after just 3.5 months of wear. Very stiff leather that does not give over time. The shoes looked great, but the quick wear on the sole after a few short months required me to buy a new pair. I will eventually get the sole repaired, but it is frustrating that I have to do so on a more expensive pair of shoes after such a short period of time.

Good value - I was a bit disappointed that the right shoe has a scuff on the tip. I tried polishing it off but the mark is still visible. Since I had to travel for a business meeting, I wore the shoes anyway. I hope next time the shipper would examine the product first before shipping. Having said the above, I'm impressed by the quick shipping and the product variety on the website. The J&M wingtip is exactly what I was looking for. It's very comfortable and elegant.

The Bar For Shoes - Classic, modern, comfortable, stylish and professional. As they say suit yourself.

Nice Business Shoe - Still breaking this shoe in. I have not bought such well made shoes in the past, so I am unfamiliar with their "break in" period. Shoe is very good quality.

Truly a classic! The quintessential black wingtip. Classic look, feel, and style. Break in takes a little time, so don't be discouraged right out of the box. They only get better!

Good looking and good fit. The uppers held up well, but the soles wore through after 9 months. Most of my shoes last for 2 years before needing re-soling.

Great shoe - a little stiff - These are well-made shoes; but they are a bit smaller than normal. However, they were delivered faster than quick - satisfied customer here!

I will be returning these. The quality does not seem 100%, mostly in the area between the leather upper and the sole of the shoe, there are a few imperfections.