Customer Reviews Foamtreads Coddles

I returned these slippers. The size (my normal 7.5) felt a bit tight and they were stiff-more like shoes than slippers. I kept the Acorn which were comfy and true to size.

Warning. Black is not black, its gray.

I am returning these. They say they have memory foam but they had very little. My feet ached especially the heel since it felt like I was walking on tile floor barefoot. They are a good looking house shoe but very poor in the comfort zone.

I normally wear a size 8. I have narrow feet and bunions. I ordered an 8.5W and they fit fine. I wore them in the house for half an hour and my feet would not warm up!! (Yes, I also had on socks). WTH!! Not impressed. Also, I received "black", but the color is a smoke gray with black accents, which was a pleasant surprise.

Foam treads seems to be declining in quality - these slippers are pretty but have no support on the sides and they are also narrow in spite of ordering a wide!

Quite awhile back I had a pair of these and loved them, and I know they run smaller in length than most shoes. So, I was glad to see a wide width offered now since my feet swell, and ordered a half size larger than my other shoes. Turns our their "wide" is probably another shoe brand's "medium" or even "narrow"; and I would have needed to order a full size larger (10.5 rather than 9.5). They didn't come even close to fitting. If you have small, narrow feet, you'll like these shoes...if not, sorry, but they won't fit. I really do wish Foamtreads would make them in actual wider widths, as it's hard to find houseshoes for wider widths that are more than just open backed scuffs.

Runs a full size small. I should have believed the previous reviews. I ordered a 2nd time in wide, but it was the same fit as the medium.

Very nice looking shoe, but it did not fit well. I was expecting a nice comfortable slipper, but was disappointed because the shoe fit narrow and is too short. It is not true to size and I will return this shoe!

Not exactly as expected. The "black" I ordered is color blocked black and grey. And this shoe, while of a light terry-like material at the top, has a rather heavy and dense plastic stacked bottom. Did not meet my need for a comfortable, supportive shoe.

I was very disappointed. I tried 3 different pairs of Foamtreads slippers and each one had the same trait - they all felt one size too small. I had to return each pair.

These are essentially comfortable death-traps. The tread is really insufficient for use on wooden stairs. I've fallen multiple times since purchasing these shoes (a problem I used to have). PLEASE be careful, I know someone who passed away after falling down stairs, I particularly worry about the elderly who may be considering these shoes. I would not recommend, unless perhaps you have carpeting.

I ordered these in 8 1/2 Wide for my 88 year old mother. She wears 8 1/2 wide in tennis shoes, so felt the size would be close. They were not. I wear 8 narrow and couldn't get my foot in there. Way to narrow, not wide at all. And the 8 1/2 and was about 1 size to small. Even if I had gone to a size 9 or 9 1/2. The width is not for wide feet. Pretty slippers tho' we loved the style and look.

Have ordered Foamtreads slippers before and have been quite satisfied. These navy "Coddles" are useless - they are like cardboard with no support. Did not send them back because I wanted navy slippers and these seem to be the only ones available.

This isn't a warm fuzzy soft slipper - it's more like a shoe. It's heavy and there is a felt lining on the bottom that moves with not much cushion.

The footbed is not as depicted. It is actually hard and smooth and cold--not what I'm looking for in a slipper. Couldn't imagine wearing without socks.... What happened?

The lining in the sole came out on the second wear, so quality is lacking here. The outer is comfortable, and gives a little as you walk because of the fabric. But I can't recommend and won't order again due to the quality issue.

I have purchased multiple pairs of this slipper. In have enjoyed 2 pairs that fit wonderfully from day one, bu not more. I wear a 6 M, but the 6 is to short and the 6.5 is too large. The last pair I purchased, which I have now sent back, was a 6.5 W, and they fell off my feet. I saw a note that said the 6M was no longer available. I really liked these slippers. They gave support, did not slip off and kept my feet warm. I am disappointed with the changes in this product.

Disappointing. No support. Felt cheaply made.

This shoe has a weird fit. I ordered it originally in my normal size- 9 1/2 W. It was enormous all over. I exchanged it for a 9W. The instep is very tight, but the heel is loose and floppy. Sadly, this shoe isn’t going to work for me.

While cute, these didn't hold up well. The soles wore out after only about a year of wear.

Stiff

These slippers are great looking; however, the insole is very uncomfortable, rough. I thought they might get better with wear, but was greatly disappointed. Since I had worn, I did not attempt to return and just passed them on to our "homeless". I simply cannot understand what has happened to women's slippers, but I have been unable to find a comfortable pair in the past seven years!

The box says 9 wide but the shoe says 9 only, and it just looks like a size 9 shoe. so disappointing.

I have bought these for years, the last several pairs I bought the stitching inside has been horrible, hurts my foot when I put it on rubs also the stitching on the top of my foot... very disappointed in these seems like they were cheaply made, not as good as before

I originally ordered a pair over a year ago and they were wonderful. Gave me support and lasted a long time. Since then, I ordered two other pairs, returning both of them after wearing them for just a few weeks. The soles seemed to be cheaply made with no support and totally different that that very first pair. Very disappointed in this slipper