Customer Reviews Sperry Billfish 3 Eye

My son has these in 11 but this in 11 did not work. Must have changed styles. Will order 1/2 size down

These are narrow and run VERY small. My husband has narrow small feet and while he could get them on, they were very tight. Order a min of 1/2 size up if not 1 full size. Didn't love the color either

Wow! I have a wider foot and felt comfortable through the typical width point. When it came to the "Toe Box" this shoe tapers fast and just not a good fit for my foot. Too bad, Im a big fan of the style and color.

I ordered these shoes for my fiance for Christmas about a year and a half ago. We were almost at the year mark when I noticed that they were starting to develop some wear and tear. I expected that as he wore them quite a bit. What I didn't expect was for holes to develop in the shoes shortly thereafter. By then, we were past the 365 day return policy for Zappos. I bought him Sperry's thinking they would last a very long time as mine had. I have had the same pair for over 6 years and they are still going strong. I'm not sure if maybe they fell apart so soon because he wore them so much or what. I was extremely disappointed to spend so munch on shoes that didn't not hold up since that was the whole reason I bought the Sperry's as opposed to another brand. If you plan on wearing these a lot, I would NOT suggest buying these.

narrower than sized...

These look great and fit great but were not very durable. We are out of the Zappos return window but are sending back to Sperry because the sole has pulled apart from the rest of the shoe and they are just falling apart. Sperry agreed to take a look so we'll keep you posted to see if they do right.

This is my second and last attempt at this shoes because these shoes lack good construction. The sides of the shoes have torn in the cloth area of both shoes and I only had them since 2014 I notice the price has dropped on them and they may be the reason why!

I like these shoes a lot for their classy look. But on my left foot the left side of the shoe rides up and hits my ankle bone. Unfortunately I have to return them.

I usually wear 8.5 or 9 in 3E. Initially ordered 8.5 XW which is supposed to be 3E, and it was half size too large, and just wide enough. Exchanged to 8 XW, and it is too narrow, definitely not XW. Have to return. The shoe seems to be well made and would have been comfortable if the size fit. Not too much support, but good enough for a boat shoe.

This has been one my favorite shoe models for years. Noticed my new, latest, pair has a nylon covered insole instead of the leather insole in previous editions I own. How well it will endure remains to be seen. I think the leather insole will prove to be more durable however. Also, the main leather of the new version was more weathered, distressed, looking than I expected from the online pictures. Not the oiled, or waxing, looking leather I expected. Since I usually apply Sno-Seal along the way, it my not be a problem, but overall I feel the product has been cheapened in materials. Sad to see after a good run with the Billfish. Fit and comfort remain constant.

I have been wearing Sperry Top-Siders for 25 years and for the first 20 years their quality control was nearly perfect. However, in the last five years or so I have noticed more and more inconsistency. The last two pairs of Billfish shoes that I have bought are over sized. I have always worn size 11 but the last two pairs were a little loose.

Loved the shoes but the cloth part ripped after only 2 yrs of infrequent usage. What a waste on a pair of shoes... guess Sperry is the same ole Chinese crap we have come to expect not the good Sperry's that would last for many years becoming more like a lover than a shoe. this is for the Sperry top sider billfish 3 eye shoe