Customer Reviews SOREL Cumberland™ II

Was a little skeptical of how these would look but when they arrived I loved the style and color. After wearing them around the house they starting rubbing around the ankles. Just a little too uncomfortable to justify the price so sent them back. Still searching for the right winter boot!

Boot is cozy and warm and waterproof throughout for moderate time in snow. Extended stay in snow will chill toes easily.

These shoes were a little clunky and pushed down a little on the top of my foot. They are certainly warm though. I ordered a half size up from what I would normally wear to accommodate thick socks and they were a little big, they're pretty true to size. Good boots but I will be exchanging them for a different pair.

I almost always wear a size 8 - pretty standard for every shoe I own. I always read the reviews to see how a shoe or boot fits so I decided to go with an 8 which is my normal size. The 8 was so tight and narrow. Returned them and ordered an 8 1/2 - still tight and too small! I decided to not order a size 9 - figured they would be narrow as well (and I do not have a big wide foot or anything either!). I'm moving onto another brand if I can find one I like. Too bad because they were cute and not too bulky either. I'm moving onto plan B. Thank god for Zappos easy returns and no return shipping or I'd be shopping on another website!

I bought these boots a year ago and in the past I have always had the Sorel Caribou. They are comforable and warm but I was not impressed with the traction. I would recommend the Sorel Caribou that boot has better traction.

In regular shoes I'm usually a 7.5 and in running shoes I'm an 8. I ordered these in an 8 and my big toes come all the way to the end in medium weight socks. Initially I tried them on in Thorlo hiking socks and they were too tight at the toe. In the medium weight socks the length is wearable so I walked around the house for 5 minutes to try them out. They are so loose at the heel they pulled my sock almost off. Sending them back and will try another style. Also, the sole is very thick and inflexible so I can't imagine they'd be comfortable for long.

While these boots are pretty light and comfy, they are not for playing in the snow all day, or very cold temps. I will be ordering another set of boots this year that will hopefully keep me warm in the cold temps of WI.

Nice boot, but a bit to heavy for walking in. I guess these would be fine for often heavy snow use.

Perfect size and so cute!

Ordered these boots for walking dogs in the Wisconsin winters. Good traction, warm, and waterproof. They met my expectations.

Wisconsinite with two dogs - these are great. Kept my feet warm, dry, and good traction, while still looking stylish for the job they are meant to do.

Love EVERYTHING about these boots. Not too heavy, warm, comfortable and cute to boot! (Get it? Boot?) I usually wear a wide shoe, but these fit perfectly! Sorels traditionally last forever ..... I suggest you go for it.

Solid boots for Chicago winters! Bought them for my work commute (imagine a couple miles in feet of snow!!), and they’re perfect. Super comfy and warm, and they keep water out. Love the white color, but of course got them dirty on day 1, but what can you do. I’m a huge Sorel fan, and would def recommend these - I wasn’t willing to spend a few hundred on boots, so super happy on value.

Boots are excellent. The color was more cream than white but the fit and warmth are just what I was looking for.

Love these boots so much!!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!! I would buy them again!!!

These boots are really nice and I really wanted to keep them, so much so that I tried them in 2 different sizes. Unfortunately, the Size 7-1/2 was too big, even with my own arch support orthotic inside it and 2 pairs of thick socks. My heel kept sloshing about. The Size 7 was too small in the toe width, even without the orthotic, which I needed as I felt the arch support without it was lacking. My usual shoe/sneaker size is 7. Perhaps if the boot came in a wide size it might have worked, but one was not available. I felt that there was no arch support for me without inserting my own. I was hoping to use these for walking the dog in the Connecticut winter snow/slush/ice. They had great flexibility for walking, a nice tread for grip on the bottom, and even though I never was able to wear them outside, I know they would have been perfect if I could only have found right size!

The size felt less than 1/2 smaller but that wasn't an option. My big toe just barely tips the end but not bad at all. They are VERY warm and comfortable. I did not notice anything about the arch support. These are very classy looking. Easy to get on, just loosen the lace about half way down and my foot slides in perfect. When i first got them, i wore them around the house to see how i really feel in them, and about and hour later, i didn't want to take them off, but my foot got hot in the Texas weather. (I purchased these for skiing in Canada). I would recommend to a friend.

This is my second pair of Sorel Cumberland II boots. First pair I've had for 2 seasons already and they are holding up great. I wanted a second color for variety. Extremely comfortable, warm & durable. They are a bit chunky but I think they look great with legggings and skinny jeans. I wear them to hike and walk in snow and ice, play in snow with kids, and around town when it's wet and messy. Slip on and off easily, 90% successful at keeping snow out (sometimes we play a little rough.) I am extremely satisfied with my purchase.