Customer Reviews Frye Belted Harness Mule

I hate to do this, because these boots are a work of art. Unbelievably thick leather, beautifully crafted, they and go with everything. But they are downright painful to walk in. Each shoe weighs 1.5 lbs. I believe the sole is made of wood. The toe is narrow, and the heel is loose (I have a medium foot--pretty average). Even after inserting the most expensive gel inserts, my shins and feet ache after walking only a small bit around the office. I still wear them because they are gorgeous. But then I have to put them away for at least a week to let my feet and lower leg bones recover.

Loved the brown belted harness mule from a year ago so much that I finally bought them in black too (I'm such a procrastinator; luckily they had my size! whew). This mule is weighty and solid. I like my jeans bootcut and long and it entertains me to no end when I can look down and peek at the hardware on these short short boots. I'm not a clog fan because they always seem to slip off my feet, so what's fantastic about this shoe is the rear harness can slip up around the back of your foot for stay-on-ability (that's my new word for the day). I love boots and Frye seems to be built well and solid and they last a long time. I'm addicted to Frye and this shoe-boot does not disappoint!

I absolutely love these shoes! They are very well made and look great. They are a bit heavy but definitely worth it.

Absolutely love these mules! I typically wear a 7 or 7.5 and ended up buying 7's.

The shoe is just beautiful & of impeccable quality however it really is too heavy for me to wear.

This is my first pair of Frye and it is better than anticipated. I'm already looking at the Frye Harness boots. The greasy (oiled) leather is just lovely; it will take on a beautiful patina over time. I chose the black leather as it looks more 'motorcycle' than 'country'. I haven't worn it extensively yet but I can tell there is no pinching of the toes, with plenty of space toward the tip so your toes don't get jammed. The most impressive thing about this mule is the stability it offers with the 2" heel. I have bought other boots with 2" heels and I always feel like I'm going to trip and fall. Not these Frye mules. Very solid block heel that helps stabilize the whole foot. It is the most expensive shoe I've ever purchased, but it's a very good investment and that's high praise coming from a bargain hunter and picky shopper. As usual, I got superior service from Zappos, ordered the evening before, received the following afternoon!

Just what I expected - I ordered half a size down (as suggested), and the fit was perfect. I already own the low brown Harness boot and have enjoyed them for almost 5 years now. They are still in tact and as comfortable as ever! These are even easier to wear, because they slide on. I am sure I will enjoy them for many years to come.

After my last pair of clogs (which were not Fryes, mind you) fell apart, I resolved not to buy any more glued-together plastic-soled shoes. When I clicked on Mules & Clogs at Zappos and saw these Frye mules, it was love at first sight! I fully admit that their styling had me hooked, but their solid, USA-made construction was the icing on the cake. I was surprised to find shoes still made in the US - it's like finding a unicorn. Did I mention how comfortable they were from the moment I donned them? No breaking-in period. Yes, they're heavy, but in a fun way. I feel like a little kid kicking around in my parents' shoes. I feel ready for the Zombie Apocalypse.

Love these! I have a pair of Frye Engineer boots that are my faves, and I have ogled these for quite some time. I could not be happier, they fit right off the bat whereas my full size boot was a bit slim until I stretched them out. They are really stable too. I have an ankle that easily rolls and these feel great! And they are just totally sassy and wonderful!

I typically can't stand to wear boots because I'm a plus gal afflicted with hot feet (ugh). These Frye mules are just perfect! Lets your feet breathe while giving you the look of an enclosed boot when worn with the bootcut jeans (I wear Levis 512). They are heavy but you get used to them after a few times out with them. For anyone who needs orthotics, you might have to velcro your inserts in, there is just a little lip at the heel so the insert doesn't show. I've tried the Harley-Davidson mules Zappos sold here and I have to say the Frye style blows them away with the ruggedness and sexiness they give my whole look.

I ordered this shoe a half size smaller based on the reviews I had read. The size was correct but it was too narrow. I loved the look but not sure another size would resolve the issue so I returned.

These shoes should last an entire lifetime as they are superbly made with extraordinary leather. I didn't pay attention to those who said to get a half size smaller. It was not a problem to order a size smaller which were, as it turned out, perfect. They do need to be broken in because of all the leather. Made in America is important to me. Love them! Love Zappos!

Love these shoes, a little heavy but you get used to them. These are my second pair of Frye, the quality of the leather will last forever.

Look great! I have been stopped and asked where I purchased them. If your familiar with Frye footwear, they're a bit heavy. The thick leather stretches, so I recommend going 1/2 size down.

Life-changing. When I had my daughter 15 years ago, the bones in my feet spread & now I have an extremely wide foot (size 9W). For 15 years, I've been only wearing sneakers & Uggs. I have a half-dozen other 2" heels in my closet that I sometimes suffer through a few hours of wear at a time - that's all I can stand, my feet hurt so bad from too-narrow shoes. Threw them all away now that I have these beauties! I've tried on (literally) thousands of pairs of shoes. None fit. Until now - this & another pair of Frye mules ("Carson Clog" in color Tan, with a 2" heel). I was just gearing up to plan a trip to an out-of-state boot-maker to have something custom-made, which would have cost $500-$1K for a single pair. As a last ditch effort, I ordered these 2 Frye mules, Hallelujah! They fit, have a sturdy, comfy heel, breathe (so no stinky feet), look great, feel great, at a great price even when not on sale! I am now going to try to scour the marketplace for years to come to find a few more pair. I just can't believe they fit, and feel great, and look great, and have a heel, and are obviously a craftsman-quality product which will last indefinitely! No, they are not runway 5" heel Manolo Blahnik's or Christian Louboutin or whatever, but I'd never wear a heel that high at all, even occasionally. I am so thrilled with these 2 pair of Frye's! By the way, I'm a 9W & ordered a size 9 in each - these black pair fit perfectly (not too long at all), while the Tan also fit me (because I need the width). I would suggest on that other pair that anyone who has a normal or narrow-width foot could likely go down a 1/2 size in length. But in this Black Mule Clog, they are dead-on perfect size. Yes they are heavy. This is what a quality shoe feels like - the leather is so thick, the finish is glossy, the heel is sturdy, the sole is thick, and that all adds up to a heavy shoe. Don't even notice it once it's on, my feet just feel snuggly & comfy! Gazillions of compliments, everyone asking me where I got them. Enjoy!

What a wonderful surprise to buy a pair of Fryes. I had a pair of boots in college and all but forgot about them. These mules fit great and look great. I am really hard on shoes but these mules kick it! Zappos rocks too!

First time ordering shoes online - was a little concerned about how this would work. The ordering was really easy - came REALLY fast - and this was over Xmas - in like 2 days. Shoes are PERFECT - love them, love them, love them. They are comfortable, they are incredibly stylish, they are solid and look like they will last a very long time. In fact, I had to go out to get new clothes to show off these shoes - I wear them at least 4 days a week. Now I have to save up to get the same shoes in brown. I heard these fit 1/2 size small - they do so that was good advice. The whole process was super easy - will use this site again.

I have lusted after these for over a year. I finally ordered my usual size and they fit perfectly. Not too tight, not too loose. They look great and are comfortable even after several hours of walking in them.

I like this shoe! Cute shoe...looks great with boot cut jeans. It is quality built. I'm a true 6 but my feet are sort of dainty...on me, this shoe was surprisingly snug.

Perfect mix of comfy and stylish - I love these shoes! I wanted something really easy for when I'm running around with the kids so that I can slip them on and off with no hands. These look and feel great!

Takes a little time to break in - These shoes are so cool, but they are heavy and take a little time to break in. After that, it is nothing but good looks.

The BEST - made in the USA! These are SO cool! I now own two pair. Your ankles don't get all hot and sweaty, they stay on fine and are super comfortable. Just be sure your jeans are long enough to cover the top and you've got that awesome biker cool look!

Frye-an American classic - You cannot go wrong with a Frye shoe or boot-maximum quality. It is a heavy shoe, but is great when broken in. Comfortable and attractive. Love these shoes!!!

Cute, but needs to be broken in - The shoes are very cute. The sizing is correct, but a bit narrow at the toe. I wear them with black dress socks and they are still a bit tight in the toe. I've worn them all day three times now and they are starting to form to my foot better. They have kept my feet toasty this winter and look super with a pair of jeans and a black leather jacket. One additional note... they are heavy. I'll be getting these in brown, too. Worth the price.