Customer Reviews Propet Mary Jane Walker Medicare/HCPCS Code = A5500 Diabetic Shoe

This shoe was very ugly. The depth of the shoe was very shallow. I could barely get the shoe on and it felt like it was only coming up the foot part way. I couldn't even close the velcro strip. I have multiple pairs of Propet sandals and I ordered the same size I've always gotten.

I am returning shoes. The width is alright in the toe area but the heel is too wide for me. I need a narrow heel. If it wasn't for the strap, the shoe would be flopping as I walk.

This is the second pair of this shoe I have ordered, and was very happy with the first pair. However, in my second pair I find the leather not as soft or comfortable. The side seems higher and hurt my feet when walking or sitting. The shoe also feels tight. Very disappointed in Propet.

Really dowdy - I'm sending these back right away. With Mary Janes like these it's a thin line between funky and cute or dowdy gramma with orthotics. This is definitely the latter. Thank goodness for Zappos free return. I also bought the SoftWalk Jupiter to compare - that's the keeper.

Very Sad : ( I was disappointed with this shoe after reading all the glowing reviews. I really wanted it to be the right shoe for me! I wore the shoe with my orthotic inserts. I found my foot moved around too much in the shoe and wasn't stable, even when I tightened the strap quite a bit. Also the top of the front of the shoe rubbed my left foot. I am continuing my hunt for a comfortable shoe I can wear to the office.

Propét Mary Janes - There were very tight around the top of my foot every time I rolled my foot forward. The width was ok but I did not like fit over the top of my foot.

Beautiful, comfortable shoe, but doesn't wear well. This shoe is attractive on one's foot and very, very comfortable. However, it has a design flaw in that one of the deeper lines across the sole of the shoe falls below the ball of the foot, where the shoe bends as one walks. With the bending, that line cracks so that, in five months time, my shoe leaked water from the bottom. With a different sole design, I do not believe that this would be a problem.

This shoe fit true to size, and was comfortable. But .. when I walked from the carpet to the wood floor, I nearly slipped and fell! The bottom is made of plastic, not rubber, which makes it extremely slippery. I could have skated across the floor, considering how slick the bottoms are. Had to return what would have otherwise been a good shoe.

The shoes were at least a half size too large and very wide.

They are too big

I have to return these cute shoes. Finally with a huge bunion, I have some fashionable options. I'm young, I don't want to wear nursing shoes the rest of my life. But with Rheumatoid Arthritis and severely in one foot, these shoes are rock hard, with zero give. Roomy because they offer these in 4E, but if you have sensitive feet, arthritic, then these will NOT work for you, PLEASE, OH PLEASE Prophet, make soft leather Mary Janes and I will be your first customer.

I have bought and loved this shoe for years. I recently ordered another one and something has changed! It did not fit like it did. My heel slipped out as I walked and the overall comfort was not the same. Have they changed the design?!

For the first two months I loved these shoes. But then the glue holding the insoles down gave out, and now the insoles peel upward in the back and generally slide around inside the shoe. They are garbage. Expensive garbage. What a waste of money.

Way large on my size 10 WW foot, my regular size due to bunions. I could stick my hand under the top of the shoe without any problem. The space was that large.

Squeaky! These shoes squeak every time I wear them.

These are the most uncomfortable shoes that I have ever purchased. I thought they would be OK, but the cushioning broke down immediately and wearing them is pure torture. I have flat arches and these shoes really hurt! I am very disappointed!

I bought these because I needed comfortable shoes for work (I stand for eight hours a day). They hurt my feet so bad I bought gel inserts after which they hurt less but they less but I still regret buying them. Also, they don't breathe so my feet were moist most of the day.