Customer Reviews Propet Mary Jane Walker Medicare/HCPCS Code = A5500 Diabetic Shoe

Bought this shoe to wear in my culinary lab. Not much arch support to speak of, calves feel a tired by end of lab. Price is right, shoe is comfortable.

These shoes were great...for the first month. I live in Chicago, so winter can treat shoes poorly. Still, after about a month, the outer leather began to crack where the shoes bend. It's not near a seam, so this isn't fixable. Other than that they're comfortable and have great traction. Too bad they won't last even one winter.

Handsome, but snug - I have a slightly wide foot and found the D width not as wide as I normally find a D width. They were overall just too snug, so back they go!

Hard to fit feet - I have a 7-7.5 EE and on this particular shoe, the right foot is loose and the left is a bit tight. They do fit my orthodics, but they are slightly pinching across the toe line.

Propet MJ Walker - This is my second pair of this style. I ordered a size smaller they feel snug but ok.

Was hoping for more support - I was hoping that these shoes were constructed like my Propét Stability Walker shoes, but they have less support on the sides and through the mid-sole. However, they are more attractive and I plan to wear them with a skirt.

Too short! The shoe was comfortable but ran way too short. Much cuter on the feet than out of the box.

Maryjane Walker-comments - The only disappointment I've experienced with the Maryjane Walker is that the material used on the inside of the front part of the toes is all worn out to the point that the little toe area has a hole and I need to replace the shoe. Otherwise the outter appearance/sole just never appears to show wear and tear.

Disappointment - The W width was not wide enough - my little toe was crunched in this shoe. I also expected the sole to be more cushiony and substantial, judging from the photo, but I don't think this is the supportive walking shoe that I thought it was going to be. I am returning this shoe.

Middle of the road - This shoe is a good step towards a shoe that you can wear all day. It accepts an orthotic with a removable insole. It is a hair narrower than the Propet walking sandal, especially in the toe box.

Concerned - I love the shoes as far as comfort and looks, but the fact that my feet are black when I take them off while wearing panty hose does not make me happy.

Comfortable... at first- Overall I like the shoes. They are right on that line between cute Mary Janes and my grandmother's orthodics, but I think they lean more to the cute side. They are a bit wide, and don't provide as much arch support as is described on the site, but they're generally pretty comfortable.

This is the 1st time buying Propet. I thought the fit of the shoe was pretty good, but it rubbed in the wrong places after a while. My feet tend to swell pretty badly, and I think this was the wrong pair to purchase with that condition.

Propet Mary Jane Walker - While the shoe was comfortable when I first put it on, as the day progressed, the front edge of the shoe top kept digging into my feet. By later in the day, I could not walk easily with these shoes.

Zappos wide width shoes - The shoes is great. The velcro strap is to short to close I will have to have an extention added. Now you need to get 71/2 EE's in and I will buy them too.

Problem with the velcro. These shoes are EXTREMELY comfortable and are very attractive. However, the strap does not completely cover the velcro. When I crossed my legs or ankles in the least, the velcro snags on my stockings, totally ruining them. I suggested to the company the velcro was too long and they said it was probably made for more narrow feet so the strap could be pulled more tightly to cover. I don't have wide feet but at least an inch or more of the velcro is not covered, leaving it to snag on everything. Zappos was very good to let me return the shoes.

Troublesome quality - These shoes are SOOOO cute. Too bad I am now returning the second pair I've tried. First time I ordered a 9, my usual size. They were a beautiful set. Unfortunately, my toe hit the tip of the shoe, so back they went, and I sent for a 9.5, which arrived within 24 hours of my reorder. (Zappos is the candy for quick and easy ordering and delivery.) And the 9.5s fit MUCH better and I could tell they'd be great everyday shoes. Here's the bummer, though: the right shoe looks very different and is poorer quality than the left. Under the black leather, the straight outline of the toe box reinforcement is obvious (a line straight across the toes), and the leather itself puckers on that shoe (poor quality area of the hide, maybe?). Plus, the throat is cut slightly different on the right shoe as on the left (wider opening). It's just not a pretty shoe; where was quality control? So, back go the 9.5s. I'm not willing to try a crap shoot on a third pair; I'm running out of time and patience.

The leather was so hard. Shoes too wide. All together very uncomfortable. I have to return them.

Very little cushioning and quite stiff, so not comfortable. Too bad, because I liked the look.

More than a half-size too large, and way too wide. Nice looking, well-made shoes, but it's annoying that Propet chose to have their own sizing from the norm.

I had these shoes a while back and needed a new pair. I have both an extra wide foot and and extra high instep. I'm not sure if the styling has changed, my foot has changed, or both, but they were extremely uncomfortable where the shoe hit the top of my foot. Sadly, I will be returning these.

inside soles came unglued within three months. Disappointing.

The shoe is very stylish but it didn’t fit so I would like to return it

I bought this shoe because another reviewer said it accommodated her custom orthotics, and its cute. Maybe my orthotics are really different, but this shoe did NOT work with my orthotics. A couple hours in, my feet were DYING in these shoes. I think the shoe wasn't wide enough to accommodate the orthotics, or perhaps not tall enough? I'm really disappointed these have to go back. I'm not going to try another width because I'm not convinced they'd be deep enough.