Customer Reviews Sebago Classic

Just a half size too short and just a little too narrow.

This is a beautiful shoe, but did not fit me. Also, it is very stiff. I am returning it for a similar style in a different brand.

I started using Sebago shoes during my high school days (70's),upto the present, may i suggest that u should bring back the sebago classic with stitched in front of the shoe,that was the original classic i've been looking for....

My opinion - The service was great, one day, and it was at my fore step. Even though it fits, it is a little tight on the arch, strange for an E size.

Penny loafer - This shoe is classic and sturdy. It goes with dress clothes and can be worn with jeans. Very flexible.

Shoe Review - Not bad for the price. It's very difficult for me to find shoes that actually fit. I wear a 10 1/2 A. These shoes fit OK, and felt better after a breaking in period. The workmanship is fair. They're not bad as a causal loafer.

A good versatile shoe - I wanted a shoe that I could dress up or down. I wear orthotics so I needed some extra room. This shoe fit well. My only complaint was that it was a little stiff and took some time to break in. It works well with khakis or a suit (and even jeans) and will be a regular part of my work wardrobe.

Sebago Classics - Men's are good - I like the shoe; however, it run's a little narrow.

I've been wearing this shoe for many years. Typically lasts over a year despite very hard wear. Comfortable but a bit stiff out of the box and becomes more comfortable with age.

Overall fine shoe - Good looking shoe, a bit wider than my size but then I wear between an A and B. Also did not notice that it has a metal shank (normal) rather than a plastic shank in the inner sole. I put a support insole in them and now they fit snugly. I'll keep them.

Value for the money - The Classic arrived on time and packed very well. I wanted the Whisky color but it wasn't available in a size 10. I took the brown and it looks very nice and wears well. The sizing was just right. I have a high instep and the shoe still fit and did give as I wore it more often. Now it is one of the most comfortable shoes I own. If the whisky color ever comes in my size I’ll probably order another pair and get them thru Zappos.

Sebago loafer - Shoe fits well and looks nice initially. Not the most durable shoe - after a few months, the sole separates and there are also holes worn into the shoe. Should last longer.

Sebago classic - The quality of the shoe is superb. I did find that the shoe size took some adjusting and has now 'worn to fit' after several weeks of use.

Nice shoes - Nice shoe and comfortable fit. Leather finish is OK and not what I would call top grain by any means.

Sebago Classic - Better fit than the Bass Loafers, which I have worn for years but are too narrow for my older fatter feet. This E width in Sebago is not too narrow.

The Classic shoe! This shoe really solves the issue of mixing proper summer work attire with summer in the HOT city!! Sebago absolutely comes through, as with all their shoes of this type, the loafer looks great, and is comfortable for a long day at the office. A great all round work and leisure shoe for the business casual customer LIKE ME. Thank you Zappos for the difficult to find sizes as well!

Excellent service from Zappos - The shoes arrived in a timely manner. I remain disappointed in the very small selection available to me in my size 7 1/2 C.

Sebago's Review - Sebago's Classic is very comfortable, constructed of good materials with average looks. Needs to be updated in appearance. Too many manufacturers’ shoes have similar style.

Nice shoe. I’d tried a legion of penny loafers before committing to the "Sebago Classic". Proper shoe fit is my personal neurosis, and I sampled loafers at every price point from Bass to Allen Edmunds. The Sebago most closely satisfied my fit criteria. I found them to be all-day-wearable after a couple of break-in laps around the house. The materials are not quite on par with the Johnston & Murphy "ski moc". I would rank these as a high grade disposable shoe (like a Cole Haan), not a resole-able heirloom (Johnston & Murphy, Allen Edmunds). Addendum: these shoes are made in the Dominican republic-- not Maine.

Traditional loafer - Zappos promptly exchanged the medium loafer for a wide when I discovered that the loafer I had orginally ordered did not fit.

Great shoe! Comfortable shoes right out of the box. This won’t be my last pair.

McCoy-SB review - I have worn the Sebago classic for many years. Right now have three pair on my shelf. Since I have a hard size (7-A). Three cheers to Sebago for keeping this size available. THANKS!!

Incredible service - Ordering was relatively easy on-line, but once I place the order my shoes were delivered within a couple of days. Terrific service. Thanks

Comments on the Sebago Classic - My shoe size is 11 1/2 A, so I'm accustomed to not having a lot of choice of styles. My preferred style is something like the Florsheim Como Imperiale, but that was not available in black. The Sebago was stiff and tight when I first put it on, but after a few days it became quite comfortable. It's a well constructed shoe and seems like it will wear well. Even if it was not my first choice, I'm very happy with it.

A real classic! Shoe is just as pictured; nice classic styling. It takes just a few days to break in and feel like you've been wearing them for years