Customer Reviews Sebago Classic

Finally, a good looking NARROW shoe for men - Attractive, well-made, and fits like a glove. Fit was just as indicated by previous reviews.

Sebago Loafers - I've worn this type of shoe for over 40 years and still think they're in style. There have been many companies that have tried to copy them but there is nothing like the real thing. They do have to be broken in to become really comfortable. The service from Zappos is still the very best!

Shoe Review - Not bad for the price. It's very difficult for me to find shoes that actually fit. I wear a 10 1/2 A. These shoes fit OK, and felt better after a breaking in period. The workmanship is fair. They're not bad as a causal loafer.

A good versatile shoe - I wanted a shoe that I could dress up or down. I wear orthotics so I needed some extra room. This shoe fit well. My only complaint was that it was a little stiff and took some time to break in. It works well with khakis or a suit (and even jeans) and will be a regular part of my work wardrobe.

Sebago Classics - Men's are good - I like the shoe; however, it run's a little narrow.

They were just as described and the comments from other buyers helped me to get a good handle on the width and length.

Poor sizing on A width - I wear a men’s 9-A so it's hard for me to find shoes. I ordered this in black and even for an A it was too narrow. My guess is that it was mis-labeled and is an AA but I don't know. I've worn it around the house for five or six hours hoping to stretch them out. I even bought thin nylon socks. No joy. I doubt I can return them as they are obviously not in 'as new' condition after 6 or so hours of wear. Quality looked good. I'll donate them to a clothing drive or something.

Finally A Shoe That Actually Fits! I have always had a problem finding shoes that are actually my size. I have short (6-7), narrow (B width) feet. In the past, I would by a size 6D slip on (Florsheim) and use a Spenco insole to tighten them up. I just purchased a pair of Sebago loafers (6.5 B) from Zappos and I'm extremely elated with how they fit. No insole needed to make them fit. What fantastic shipping! I had my shoes 24 hours after placing my order. Zappos is in San Francisco, I live in the Windy City. I'm so happy with these shoes I may order another pair in black. My plea to Zappos is please keep short narrow widths in stock!

Very Good - I ordered two pair of Sebago shoes. One black pair and the other brown. The brown ones are very comfortable, but the black ones seemed tighter so I am hoping to stretch them out a little.

I've been wearing this shoe for many years. Typically lasts over a year despite very hard wear. Comfortable but a bit stiff out of the box and becomes more comfortable with age.

Love the Loafer - I ordered these for a business trip my husband was taking. He literally tried them on on his way out the door, threw them in his luggage and wore them with no complaints. I got him the wide, because dress shoes are sometimes "pinchy" on the toes for him. They work perfectly and look classic with his business casual attire. The price was right for the quality of the shoe. They appear to be sturdy and well supported his big size 13 foot. We would buy again and again.

Great shoe! Great shoe and value. The shoe has classic penny loafer styling and details and is sturdy and comfortable.

Sam - These shoes are just what I was looking for and the price was great. I liked the fact that I had so many options to look for in penny loafers and there by was able to find the ones I was looking for and Zappos delivered with free shipping in 2 days, I am contemplating another pair in black.

A very good shoe - For me it was a very pleasant experience, as I had an accident several years ago that has made it very difficult to find shoes to fit, that not only look nice but are a good fit for me. It has been a very frustrating time for me to purchase any type of shoe without getting fed up going from shop to shop and still finding nothing, to be able to shop on line here and get the shoes that fit is truly great. Thanks Zappos.

Deserves the name "Classic" What can you say about this shoe that hasn't been said? Almost perfect. "Almost" because the quality/fit has suffered a bit since the move to offshore production--but after buying/returning three pairs, I landed on the right one, what must be my 10th or so pair over the last 15 years.

Sebago Classic [Penny Loafers] I bought them for my Husband Who is a size 16 narrow. Very hard to find. It was very easy to order on line. They were here within 2 days. He said that they were very comfortable and likes them very much. This is coming from a man who has worn work boots & cowboy boots all his adult life.

Solid, comfortable loafer - This is my first pair of Sebago's and I am impressed with their sturdy construction and comfort. The shoes have a more solid feel to them, unlike many loafers which feel more like slippers than shoes.

Overall fine shoe - Good looking shoe, a bit wider than my size but then I wear between an A and B. Also did not notice that it has a metal shank (normal) rather than a plastic shank in the inner sole. I put a support insole in them and now they fit snugly. I'll keep them.

Value for the money - The Classic arrived on time and packed very well. I wanted the Whisky color but it wasn't available in a size 10. I took the brown and it looks very nice and wears well. The sizing was just right. I have a high instep and the shoe still fit and did give as I wore it more often. Now it is one of the most comfortable shoes I own. If the whisky color ever comes in my size I’ll probably order another pair and get them thru Zappos.

Great Shoe - This is my third pair of Sebago Classics in the past 25 years. It's definitely a GREAT shoe.

As expected - I have these in brown as well. I have difficulty finding wide shoes properly sized. These meet expectations.

Sebago Classic-Men's - This was my first Zappos and Sebago purchase. Based on other customer comments, I bought a narrower width than I used with other brands and the shoes fit great. I'm impressed with the service and return policy also, but these shoes will not be returned.

Pleased with fit - I've never bought shoes online before. Stores don't carry my narrow width, so I gave it a try and was pleased, the shoes fit well. The old shoes said 10 1/2 C, the measuring device at the store said size 12. The salesman couldn't explain the discrepancy. I went with the smaller size and they fit right off. I was concerned that there would be a lot of back and forth mailing which I wanted to avoid.

Sizing runs a bit small in width - The shoe looked nice, but was smaller in width than expected. I've worn them several times hoping that they would stretch a bit, but they continue to be too snug.

Dancin' shoes - I had the guts to wear these for the first time to a dinner dance. Amazing comfort right out of the box. No pain, no blisters, and no problem! I have worn Sebago boat shoes for years but this is the first time trying a regular shoe. Every bit as comfortable as the boat shoes and are among the few shoes offered in a B width that I need for my narrow feet. Quality of material and workmanship are very, very good. Zappos your service and commitment to customer satisfaction definitely set the standard for internet commerce. Thanks for a rewarding buying experience.