Customer Reviews Sebago Classic

Best Penny I've owned. I've been wearing pennies for over 20 years and all different brands...Johnston Murphy, Rockport, Weejuns, Florsheim. I feel that these are the best from style to comfort. Took a little to break in at first. I have wide feet with a very high instep and the 3E was perfect.

Great Product - The loafer was a perfect fit. I have not worn loafers in years due to having a narrow foot, and I could never find a pair that would fit. There was also no break in time. They are extremely comfortable.

Shoe is fine for dress, which is what I needed for my son. It isn't particularly soft or comfortable but looks good.

Sebago Loafer - These loafers are extremely narrow if anyone else has that problem! They fit great and are made wonderfully! VERY HAPPY with the product!!!!

SUPER PERFECT! Great classic loafer. Very comfortable. Fits true to size. I'm a transplanted Yankee, so this brings me back to my youth.

Excellent shoe - I've been using this Classics Sebago for more than 20 years and I always found them very comfortable. I use the extra wide model and for me is perfect shoe.

Sebago Classic, still a classic - This shoe is essentially identical to the entire penny loafers sold in the era of l955-1970. It has all the usual features: beef roll sides, classic moccasin construction and even heel stitching, which some leave off. It is also a shoe that one can wear with anything, except a tuxedo. Leather quality is average, but even this is traditional for this shoe. It is durable: once broken in, it is resoleable, so it could last a decade.

I have loved Sebago Classic Penny Loafers for years, and have owned and enjoyed 20 pair or more. However, the last two pair I have bought have had a raised place in the insole of one shoe making it uncomfortable. I returned the first pair but kept the second. I can't wear them for long at the time, however. I will probably give Sebago’s one more try.

Great business casual shoe - I love the shoe and it is gorgeous; it is still taking a little time to break-in but feels very good.

Extra Narrow for Narrow Widths - I ordered a pair in 12A. I have feet that are 12A and 12AA with a 4.5 arch. My AA foot just fit in them, but was uncomfortably tight. My A foot would not hardly even go in at all, very painful. Also, the top of my foot hit the tongue in a painful location. I'm not sure if I'll try a B width or try a different brand. One thing for sure, Zappos shipping and return policies are outstanding!

Too Small - I have worn Sebago's Classic for years, this pair of shoes are too small, short. I have some that are 9 and some that are 9 and some 9 1/2. These are small. I am trying to figure out how to exchange them.

Sebago classic penny loafer - The shoe is everything it was pruported to be. I did find the initial fit to be a little stiff, but that should relax with wearing. The traditional look and leather sole add to the overall satisfaction. The cordovan color is well suited for a variety of clothing colors, and goes well with both grey and tan trousers.

Strongly recommend - Purchased this shoe for my husband for his birthday. His main concern was comfort. He loves the shoes. He was able to wear the shoes for a 12 hours work day without a problem.

Wrong color and incomplete stitching - I ordered antique brown classic loafer and was sent the cordovan color shoe. The stitching on the beef roll came loose on the first day of wear. I am taking it to the shoe repair shop today. I really wanted the antique brown, but decided to keep the other. I have worn both colors for over 25 years and prefer the antique brown. This is the first time ever that I have had trouble with a Sebago shoe. I think you should send me the brown shoe or at least take care of the cost of the repair bill. Also the quality of the leather used is inferior to what had been used previously. Bob C

Very pleased!!! I really enjoy my new Sebago’s. The service at Zappos is remarkable. With a little mix up in the size (shoes in box were different size than what was labeled on shoe box) Zappos exchanged them fast and easy. Zappos sent a coupon worth $15 toward future purchase for the inconvenience. I've bought two other pairs of shoes since. The Cordo Classic and the Beckenridge. Excellent pairs of shoes. I’m waiting for the Classic authentic brown to become available in my size.

My opinion - The service was great, one day, and it was at my fore step. Even though it fits, it is a little tight on the arch, strange for an E size.

Penny loafer - This shoe is classic and sturdy. It goes with dress clothes and can be worn with jeans. Very flexible.

Sebago is nice - My new Sebago pair of shoes are just what I needed. They look so professional, yet are nice to have on anywhere I go. I wear a narrow shoe and the medium size was just perfect.

Men's Penny Loafers - I have not had a pair of these in quite sometime. My wife said I needed a pair for more casual situations. The first thing I had to get used to was that the leather is a lot stiffer than some other loafers. However, I have been wearing them on alternate days and seem to getting them broke into my feet. I had first ordered the correct size for my feet in an A width. When they arrived I tried them on and with the bunion on the left foot I could not wear them. So I sent them back for a B width. The B width was perfect. So I guess from now on I will be ordering B width shoes.

Sebago's classic is a Classic - Good shoe - comfortable - true to size - great for the traveling I do. Would order again. Great for my big feet with narrow heels. Well built. Like steel shank and leather soles, which you don't see often anymore in this price range.

Good shoe - looks good out of the box. After a few days of wear, the top of the toe area showing some "wrinkle" look.

These are the best casual shoes I have ordered through Zappos. Great fit for my narrow feet.

The stitching tore! I can't believe it. After maybe 3 weeks of occasional wear, the top stitching on the right shoe tore.

Great shoes - Maximum comfort; wear them for 10 years now! The fact that you can order different width is fantastic. It seems you walk on clouds!!